Carolina Panthers running back Jonathon Brooks will miss the entire 2025 NFL season, a significant setback for the team’s second-round draft pick from 2024. The franchise announced on May 8, 2025, that Brooks was placed on the physically unable to perform (PUP) list, effectively ruling him out for the upcoming season. This decision follows a devastating series of injuries, including a second ACL tear in his right knee sustained during a game against the Philadelphia Eagles in December 2024. The move underscores the Panthers’ cautious approach to Brooks’ recovery, prioritizing his long-term health over immediate contributions to the roster.
The news has sent ripples through the Panthers’ fanbase, with many expressing disappointment but also support for the young athlete’s recovery journey. Brooks, a former Texas Longhorns standout, was seen as a high-potential player despite his injury history. His limited action in 2024—nine carries for 22 yards and three receptions for 23 yards—offered only a glimpse of his capabilities.
- Key details of the announcement:
- Brooks placed on PUP list on May 8, 2025.
- Second ACL tear occurred in December 2024 against the Eagles.
- Recovery timeline suggests no return until at least 2026.
- Panthers made additional roster moves, including releasing Jadeveon Clowney.
The PUP designation ensures Brooks has a full year to rehabilitate, but it also raises questions about the Panthers’ backfield strategy moving forward.
Second ACL tear halts Brooks’ progress
Jonathon Brooks’ placement on the PUP list stems from a non-contact injury sustained during a Week 14 game against the Philadelphia Eagles on December 8, 2024. On his first carry of the game, Brooks attempted a cut and collapsed, clutching his right knee. Medical evaluations confirmed he had re-torn the same ACL he initially injured in November 2023 while playing for Texas. The Panthers, who had taken a calculated risk by drafting Brooks 46th overall despite his prior injury, now face the challenge of planning without their promising rookie for another season.
The second ACL tear, occurring just 13 months after the first, has sparked concerns about Brooks’ long-term durability. He underwent successful surgery in January 2025, performed by renowned sports medicine specialist Dr. Neal ElAttrache. Despite the procedure’s success, the typical recovery timeline for an ACL injury—9 to 12 months—means Brooks is unlikely to see meaningful snaps until his third NFL year. The Panthers’ decision to place him on the PUP list early reflects a strategy to avoid rushing his return.
Panthers adjust backfield with Rico Dowdle signing
In response to Brooks’ injury, the Panthers signed running back Rico Dowdle to a one-year deal in March 2025, a move that signaled their expectation of Brooks’ prolonged absence. Dowdle, who rushed for over 1,000 yards with the Dallas Cowboys in 2024, provides a reliable option behind starter Chuba Hubbard. The signing came shortly after the Panthers released Miles Sanders, who was later picked up by Dallas in a swap of sorts. This roster adjustment highlights the team’s need to bolster their backfield depth, especially given the high injury rate at the running back position.
Hubbard, who had a breakout 2024 season, remains the Panthers’ primary running back, with a recent four-year contract extension securing his role. Dowdle’s addition ensures the team has a capable RB2, reducing pressure on Hubbard and allowing Brooks to focus on recovery without immediate expectations. The Panthers’ backfield strategy now hinges on this duo, with Brooks’ return not anticipated until 2026.
- Panthers’ running back depth:
- Chuba Hubbard: Lead back, extended through 2028.
- Rico Dowdle: Signed for 2025, 1,000+ yards in 2024.
- Jonathon Brooks: On PUP list, expected return in 2026.
Brooks’ brief 2024 stint showed promise
Despite his limited playing time, Jonathon Brooks displayed flashes of the talent that made him a top running back prospect in the 2024 NFL Draft. His debut came in Week 12 against the Kansas City Chiefs on November 24, 2024, after spending the first 10 weeks on the non-football injury (NFI) list recovering from his college ACL tear. In three games, he recorded 12 touches—nine carries for 22 yards and three receptions for 23 yards—demonstrating his versatility as a runner and pass-catcher.
His most notable performance came against the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, where he showed agility and vision before his season-ending injury in Philadelphia. Fans and coaches alike were excited about his potential to complement Hubbard, but the second ACL tear cut short any chance to build momentum. Brooks’ brief stint remains a tantalizing glimpse of what could have been, with his future now dependent on a successful rehabilitation process.
Surgery and recovery process underway
Brooks underwent his second ACL surgery in January 2025, a procedure deemed successful by medical staff. Performed by Dr. Neal ElAttrache, the surgery addressed the re-torn ligament in his right knee. The Panthers have emphasized a cautious approach, with general manager Dan Morgan stating at the 2025 NFL Scouting Combine that no specific timeline would be placed on Brooks’ recovery. This stance reflects the team’s commitment to ensuring Brooks returns at full strength, even if it means missing an entire season.
The recovery process for a second ACL tear is complex, often requiring extensive physical therapy to rebuild strength and stability. Brooks, who has prior experience with ACL rehabilitation, expressed optimism shortly after the injury, citing his faith and support system as key motivators. He has been present at team practices, maintaining a positive demeanor despite the setback. The Panthers’ medical staff will closely monitor his progress throughout 2025, with regular evaluations to assess his readiness for a 2026 return.
- Recovery milestones:
- Surgery completed in January 2025.
- Physical therapy ongoing, focusing on knee stability.
- No set timeline, with 2026 as the earliest return.
- Regular check-ins with Panthers’ medical team planned.
Fan and team support for Brooks
The Panthers’ organization and fanbase have rallied around Jonathon Brooks since his latest injury. Head coach Dave Canales has been vocal about his support, emphasizing that the focus is on Brooks’ personal journey rather than immediate team needs. During a press conference, Canales described Brooks as “heartbroken” but praised his resilience, noting the team’s commitment to supporting him every step of the way. Teammates, including Chuba Hubbard, have also expressed solidarity, with Hubbard stating that the injury would ultimately make Brooks stronger(“This will only make him better”).
On social media platforms like X, fans have shared messages of encouragement, with hashtags like #GetWellJonathon trending in the days following the injury announcement. Some fans have drawn inspiration from former Panthers linebacker Thomas Davis, who overcame three ACL tears to earn three Pro Bowl selections. Davis himself reached out to Brooks, offering words of encouragement and sharing his own story of perseverance.
Roster moves signal strategic shift
The Panthers’ decision to place Brooks on the PUP list was part of a broader set of roster moves announced on May 8, 2025. In addition to Brooks’ placement, the team released veteran edge rusher Jadeveon Clowney, waived tight end Colin Granger with an injury settlement, and made several other cuts, including defensive tackle Popo Aumavae and receiver T.J. Luther. These moves reflect a strategic effort to reshape the roster while managing salary cap constraints and addressing injury concerns.
The release of Clowney, a high-profile signing in 2024, underscores the Panthers’ focus on building a younger, more flexible roster. Meanwhile, Brooks’ absence has prompted the team to explore additional backfield options, with speculation about potential free-agent signings or draft picks in 2025. The Panthers’ front office, led by Dan Morgan, is navigating a delicate balance between immediate competitiveness and long-term development.
Brooks’ college career set high expectations
Before his NFL journey, Jonathon Brooks was a standout at the University of Texas, where he earned a reputation as one of the nation’s top running backs. In his final college season in 2023, he rushed for 1,139 yards and 10 touchdowns, earning semifinalist honors for the Doak Walker Award. His ability to break tackles and contribute as a receiver made him a coveted prospect, despite the ACL tear that ended his college career prematurely.
The Panthers traded up to select Brooks in the second round of the 2024 NFL Draft, viewing him as a high-reward pick despite his injury history. His college tape showcased a blend of speed, vision, and versatility, qualities that the Panthers hoped would translate to the professional level. While his NFL career has been delayed, Brooks’ college achievements remain a reminder of his potential once he returns to full health.
- College highlights:
- 1,139 rushing yards, 10 touchdowns in 2023.
- 212 touches in his junior year at Texas.
- Semifinalist for the Doak Walker Award.
- Known for versatility as a runner and receiver.
Challenges of repeated ACL injuries
Sustaining two ACL tears in the same knee within 13 months is a rare and daunting challenge for any athlete. The physical toll of such injuries includes not only the ligament damage but also potential complications like cartilage wear or muscle atrophy. For Brooks, the mental hurdles are equally significant, as he faces the prospect of another grueling rehabilitation process. Experts note that while recovery from a second ACL tear is possible, it often requires additional time to restore confidence in the injured knee.
The Panthers’ cautious approach aligns with broader NFL trends, where teams increasingly prioritize long-term player health over short-term gains. Examples like Thomas Davis, who thrived after multiple ACL tears, offer hope, but Brooks’ limited professional experience—12 touches in three games—means his development will be further delayed. The team’s medical staff is working to ensure that Brooks’ rehabilitation addresses both physical and psychological aspects of his recovery.
Strategic implications for 2025 season
With Brooks sidelined, the Panthers are reshaping their offensive strategy for 2025. Chuba Hubbard’s emergence as a reliable RB1 provides stability, while Rico Dowdle’s signing adds depth. However, the team may still look to the 2025 NFL Draft or free agency to bolster their backfield, especially given the position’s high injury rate. Top running back prospects like Quinshon Judkins could influence the market, potentially prompting the Panthers to invest in additional talent.
The Panthers’ offense, led by quarterback Bryce Young, will rely heavily on Hubbard and Dowdle to maintain a balanced attack. The team’s decision to part ways with Miles Sanders, who struggled in Carolina after a strong 2022 season with the Eagles, further underscores their shift toward a Hubbard-centric backfield. Brooks’ absence, while disappointing, allows the Panthers to focus on other areas of need, such as the offensive line and receiving corps.
- Panthers’ 2025 backfield outlook:
- Hubbard to carry the bulk of the workload.
- Dowdle as a complementary back with proven production.
- Potential draft or free-agent additions under consideration.
- Focus on protecting Bryce Young with a strong run game.
Brooks’ resilience draws attention
Despite the setbacks, Jonathon Brooks has maintained a positive outlook, earning praise for his maturity and determination. In comments made shortly after his injury, he spoke about trusting in a higher plan and drawing on his previous rehab experience to navigate the process. His presence at Panthers’ practices, even while sidelined, has been noted by coaches and teammates as a sign of his commitment to the team.
Brooks’ story has also resonated with fans, many of whom see parallels with other athletes who have overcome significant injuries. Social media posts on X have highlighted his upbeat attitude, with some fans sharing clips of his college highlights to remind others of his potential. The Panthers’ organization has emphasized that Brooks remains a key part of their future plans, with his recovery being closely monitored by the team’s leadership.
Looking ahead to 2026
As Jonathon Brooks embarks on his second ACL rehabilitation, the Panthers are preparing for a 2025 season without one of their most promising young players. His expected return in 2026 will be a critical moment, as he aims to prove his worth after two years of limited action. The Panthers’ investment in Brooks, both in draft capital and emotional support, reflects their belief in his ability to overcome his injury history and contribute to the team’s success.
For now, Brooks’ focus remains on the day-to-day work of recovery, with the Panthers’ medical staff and coaching team providing a structured plan to guide him. Fans continue to express hope for his comeback, with many citing his college production and brief NFL flashes as evidence of his potential. The road to 2026 will be long, but Brooks’ determination and the Panthers’ support system provide a foundation for his eventual return to the field.
