Automotive experts at Consumer Reports have released an updated list of SUVs that should be avoided by consumers in 2026. Esses vehicles present recurring flaws in reliability, comfort and economy, leading to high maintenance costs and accelerated depreciation in the Brazilian market.
The analysis considers data from real tests, reports from owners and comparisons with more efficient competitors. No Brasil, where the SUV segment represents more than 40% of new vehicle sales, these recommendations gain relevance to guide conscious purchases and avoid financial regrets.
Based on international assessments adapted to the local context, including driving conditions on uneven roads and fuel of varying quality, the highlighted models fail to meet basic expectations. Proprietários report issues ranging from inadequate suspension to persistent electronic problems, impacting the vehicles’ overall durability.
Models with reliability flaws
The Jeep Grand Cherokee appears as one of the main vehicles to avoid due to the imbalance between price and performance. Testes indicate that its fuel economy is below the category average, while the driving quality does not justify the initial investment, which can exceed R$300,000 in the Brazilian market.
Furthermore, reports from owners point to expensive maintenance on components such as suspension and transmission. Compared to more balanced options, this model loses points in long-term durability, especially in intense urban use.
Comfort and internal space issues
The Jeep Compass faces criticism for its rigid suspension that compromises comfort on long journeys. Seu Tight interior limits space for rear passengers, making it less ideal for large families.
Problems with driving dynamics are also common, with poor acceleration when climbing or overtaking. Esses factors contribute to a poor user experience, even with recent updates to the external design.
Premium performance that doesn’t convince
The Alfa Romeo Tonale, despite offering 285 horsepower and all-wheel drive, is disappointing due to its interior, which is considered simple for the luxury segment. The level of comfort does not meet the standard expected in vehicles in this price range, which exceeds R$250,000.
Additionally, internal finishing and ergonomic issues reduce its attractiveness. Proprietários mention excessive vibrations at higher speeds, affecting the perception of premium quality.
Problems in hybrid versions
The Mazda CX-90 stands out negatively for its low reliability, particularly in the hybrid variant. Pesquisas show frequent propulsion system failures, leading to costly repairs.
In the Brazilian context, where the use of ethanol can worsen electrical problems, this model requires extra attention in preventive maintenance. Sua Limited off-road capability also makes it less versatile compared to rivals.
Off-road limitations and versatility
The GMC Terrain is criticized for its restricted off-road capabilities, not catering to drivers looking for adventures off the asphalt. Testes reveal instability on irregular terrain, common on secondary Brazilian roads.
Furthermore, high fuel consumption in mixed cycle increases operating costs. Proprietários report the need for frequent replacement of suspension parts, increasing the total cost of ownership.
Vehicles obsolete in technology
The Land Rover Defender, although it offers a spacious interior and iconic design, is seen as obsolete compared to more modern competitors. Suas driver assistance technologies fall short of current expectations, such as advanced autonomous braking systems.
In Brasil, where urban traffic is intense, these deficiencies can compromise daily safety. Proprietários face challenges with software updates, which are not always compatible with local dealer networks.
Recommended alternatives on the market
For those considering the Jeep Grand Cherokee, the Honda Passport appears as a superior option, with a smoother ride and a better balance between cost and equipment. Esse model adapts well to Brazilian conditions, offering fuel savings of around 10 km/l on the road.
The Subaru Crosstrek is suggested instead of the Jeep Compass, thanks to the wider interior and the X-Mode all-wheel drive system, ideal for heavy rains common in the country. Sua maintenance is more accessible, with parts available through extensive networks.
Replacing the Alfa Romeo Tonale, the BMW X1 stands out for its modern interior and balanced features, including advanced connectivity with smartphones. Testes locations confirm its stability in curves, reducing fatigue on long journeys.
The Toyota Highlander Hybrid is preferable to the Mazda CX-90, with greater capacity and a reputation for durability. No Brasil, its hybrid version benefits from tax incentives in some regions, optimizing return on investment.
Devaluation factors in Brasil
In the national market, SUVs like the Renault Captur show an average annual depreciation of 24%, influenced by discontinued production and chronic problems. Esse index reflects the preference for brands with a robust service network, such as Toyota and Honda.
Models like the Ford Ka and Volkswagen Tiguan also lose value quickly, with drops of up to 25% in the first year. Fatores include high insurance costs and limited availability of imported parts.
Experts recommend checking recall histories before purchasing, especially for imported vehicles. No Brasil, Platforms like Denatran provide data on remediation campaigns, helping to avoid recurring failed models.
Economic impacts of the wrong choice
Choosing a problematic SUV can result in extra annual expenses of up to R$5,000 in maintenance, according to data from Mobiauto. Isso includes more frequent oil changes and transmission repairs, common on models such as Jeep and Land Rover.
In addition to the financial cost, there is the time spent in workshops, affecting the daily routine. Consumidores report frustration with prolonged downtime, especially in regions far from urban centers.
Current trends in the segment
The SUV market in the Brasil grew 15% in 2025, driven by hybrid and electric models. However, vehicles with reliability problems lose ground to options like the Toyota Corolla Cross, which combine efficiency and low cost of ownership.
Safety innovations such as collision warnings make outdated models less attractive. Fabricantes invest in updates to meet Brazilian emissions standards, favoring brands with updated technology.
Consumers prioritize vehicles with extended warranties, reducing financial risks. Pesquisas indicate that 60% of buyers consult online reviews before making a final decision.
Care when purchasing
Before purchasing an SUV, check its maintenance history and actual mileage. Test extensive drives reveal issues such as suspension noise or slow acceleration.
Consult independent mechanics for pre-purchase inspections, identifying hidden problems. No Brasil, associations such as Abrac support consumers with guidance on rights in cases of defects.
