Meta, the parent company of platforms such as Instagram and Facebook, recently launched a new artificial intelligence image generator, Muse Image, which allows the creation of visual content from public Instagram photos. The functionality, presented this week, quickly provoked a series of questions and criticisms from users and privacy experts, due to the way the data is used.
The feature generated controversy for automatically including any adult with a public profile on Instagram, without the need for prior explicit consent. The company defends the initiative as part of a larger effort to integrate AI into its various platforms, seeking to innovate in content creation.
The controversy over the use of public profile data
Muse Image’s functionality surprised many by revealing that users with public Instagram accounts were automatically included in the system. The Meta AI app, an independent chatbot from the company, allows other users to access “part or all of your published photos” to generate new images based on artificial intelligence, as detailed in an official Meta blog post.
More on this story: Meta launches Muse Image and reveals preview of Muse Video with advanced artificial intelligence
The public’s negative reaction didn’t take long to emerge. The main complaint is the lack of notification to users whose accounts were used for AI image generation, in addition to the absence of a direct consent mechanism. Hundreds of people took to social media to express outrage, describing the move as a “privacy landmine” and seeking information on how to disable the feature.
Guidelines for protecting your Instagram photos
Faced with the negative repercussions, Meta issued a statement clarifying that private accounts and users under 18 are automatically protected and excluded from the new functionality. For those who want to keep their profiles public but prevent their images from being used by the AI generator, there are specific steps to disable the feature:
- The most direct way to protect your content is to change your Instagram account privacy to private mode.
- If you prefer to keep your profile public, navigate to your Instagram settings and find the “share and reuse” tab.
- Within that section, look for the option “Allow people to reuse your content on Instagram and with AI features” and turn it off.
- There is also the ability to adjust artificial intelligence settings individually for specific photos and videos, giving the user greater control.
It is important to note that Meta informed that the blocking does not extend to users’ audio, texts and comments, which can continue to be used by its artificial intelligence systems.
Learn more: Meta closes artificial intelligence tool that used Instagram profile photos
Differences in approach to privacy between AI platforms
Meta’s decision to adopt an “opt-out” system for the use of data in its artificial intelligence image generator generated comparisons with other companies in the sector. OpenAI, creator of ChatGPT, also faced privacy concerns with the launch of Sora, its AI video generator.
However, the big distinction between the two approaches lies in the premise of consent. OpenAI, to use a person’s image to create videos with Sora, required an “opt-in” process, meaning the user needed to give explicit and active consent to participate. This model directly contrasts with Meta’s practice, which automatically included users and required them to search for settings to disable functionality.
Sora was discontinued by OpenAI in March, in part due to high operational costs, but debate over different consent policies remains. While one company prioritizes explicit user authorization, the other assumes permission, generating ethical and legal discussions about the ownership and use of digital content in a rapidly evolving AI landscape.
This fundamental difference underscores the importance of users being aware of technology companies’ privacy policies and how their public data is used in training and content generation by artificial intelligence systems.
On the same topic: New Meta feature creates images using artificial intelligence on WhatsApp
Meta’s artificial intelligence strategy
The launch of Muse Image is an integral part of Meta’s ambitious strategy to enhance the presence of artificial intelligence across all of its platforms. The company is investing significantly in integrating AI into its apps, such as Instagram, Facebook, WhatsApp and Threads, aiming to transform the user experience and expand content creation capabilities.
In addition to the image generator, Meta has already introduced “AI characters” with different personalities, allowing users to interact with sophisticated chatbots. The company also announced plans to launch an artificial intelligence video generator, Muse Video, in the coming months, which demonstrates the company’s commitment to leading innovation in the field of generative AI.
These initiatives reflect Meta’s commitment to exploring the potential of artificial intelligence to reshape digital interaction, even amid the ethical challenges and privacy discussions that accompany the rapid advancement of this technology.
More on this story: Learn how to disable WhatsApp’s artificial intelligence and protect your data
Use of minors’ data and Meta guidelines
A crucial aspect in discussions about the use of images by artificial intelligence is the protection of minors. Meta has ensured that underage user accounts are not used to generate images by AI, even if these profiles are public. This security measure aims to protect a more vulnerable public and is in line with the company’s child protection policies.
Additionally, Meta prevents teenagers from using the resource to create content based on photos of other people, reinforcing restrictions on the tool’s reach among younger people. The company reaffirms its commitment to taking action against any content that violates its Community Standards, establishing strict guidelines to prevent abuse and misuse of technology.