Skip to content
Menu
Mix Vale

Quentin Tarantino harshly criticized the Jogos Vorazes franchise during his appearance on the Bret Easton Ellis podcast. The American director classified the literary series by Suzanne Collins as direct plagiarism of the Japanese novel Battle Royale, by Koushun Takami. Ele stated that the original author should have sued the writer for misappropriation of the central idea.

The statement came as Tarantino presented his personal list of the 20 best films of the 21st century. Battle Royale, directed by Kinji Fukasaku in 2000, appeared in 11th position. The filmmaker highlighted the similarities between the two works and questioned the lack of critical recognition about the origin of the story.

Playlist reveals preferences

Tarantino started the countdown with different titles. The list included productions such as West Side Story, A Paixão of Cristo and Escola of Rock.

The films positioned between 20th and 11th place were:

  • West Side Story (20th)
  • Inferno’s hut (19th)
  • Moneyball (18th)
  • Chocolate (17th)
  • Rejected Pelo Diabo (16th)
  • To Paixão of Cristo (15th)
  • School of Rock (14th)
  • Jackass: The Filme (13th)
  • The Lobos Maus (12th)
  • Battle Royale (11th)

The director justified the inclusion of Battle Royale due to its narrative strength and visual impact.

Similarities highlighted between works

Both stories feature teenagers forced to fight to the death in a government-controlled setting. Em Battle Royale, Japanese students participate in annual state program. Jogos Vorazes shows young people from selected districts for the televised arena.

Tarantino declared that literary critics ignored the reference due to their lack of knowledge of the Japanese film. Ele stated that film professionals immediately identified the inspiration.

The director mentioned that many considered Jogos Vorazes original until they watched Battle Royale. Após comparisons, the work came to be seen as a softened version for teenage audiences.

Personal relationship with Japanese film

Tarantino revealed his friendship with Kinji Fukasaku. The Japanese director screened Battle Royale in a private session during location scouting for Kill Bill.

The screening took place at Japão before the official launch. Tarantino stated that he was impacted by the violence and originality.

Months later, he participated in a midnight session at Festival of Seattle. The American public was still unfamiliar with the film and reacted intensely.

Repercussion of the statements

Tarantino’s speeches reinforce an old debate about literary influences. Suzanne Collins always denied having knowledge of Battle Royale before writing the first book in 2008.

The Japanese film, based on the 1999 novel, gained an international cult following. The work faced censorship in several countries due to its extreme themes.

Tarantino keeps Battle Royale as a constant reference in interviews. The director has already cited the film as an influence on his own projects.

Context of the two franchises

Battle Royale sold millions of copies at Japão and generated a literary following. The 2000 film grossed around $30 million worldwide.

Games Vorazes has become a global phenomenon with more than 100 million books sold. The film adaptation grossed nearly $3 billion across four main films plus a prequel.

The director’s statements reignite discussion about originality in young adult adaptations. Críticos are divided between considering it a tribute or a direct copy.

Beatriz Lima é colaboradora da redação do Mix Vale, portal de notícias com cobertura de Brasil e mundo. Produz conteúdo nas editorias de economia e benefícios, com foco em informação de serviço para o leitor brasileiro. Escreve para o portal desde 2024.

Related news

Sua privacidade

O Mix Vale usa cookies para medir audiência e exibir anúncios que sustentam a redação. Você escolhe. Política de privacidade.