Consumer receives condensed milk instead of iPhone purchased by Amazon in SP

A 23-year-old woman received a box of condensed milk instead of the iPhone 16 she had received as a birthday present from her husband. The device was purchased online from Amazon and should be delivered to Praia Grande, on the coast of São Paulo. The frustration was so much that Valentina Vitória cried all night after discovering the error.
The order was placed last Friday (30th) via the platform, with delivery scheduled for Saturday (1st). The package arrived at the entrance of the building where the victim lives, in the Canto neighborhood of Forte, on Monday (4). A man made the delivery, as recorded by the building’s security cameras.
Como error has been discovered
Valentina was not home at the time of delivery. Ela asked her mother-in-law to receive the order in her place. Pouco Some time later, the husband arrived home with the intention of unwrapping the iPhone again and giving it to her as a surprise. When he opened the box, he found the condensed milk and immediately began filming the situation to record what happened.
The images that the husband captured show his shocked reaction to the wrong content. Câmeras building monitoring confirmed that an employee of Amazon left the package at the entrance. Valentina consulted the object trace and verified that the code was correct on the packaging.
Posicionamento by Amazon
The consumer contacted Amazon as soon as she discovered the problem, via phone call and email. The company, according to a report by Valentina, expressed solidarity with the situation and promised to investigate what happened. Até at the time of publication, g1 awaits an official position from the platform on the case.
Orientações from Procon
Procon-SP issued a note clarifying that, when a consumer purchases a product on a marketplace, both the store and the platform must guarantee delivery as advertised. In situations of this type, the consumer has the right to request another equivalent product or request a full refund of the amount paid.
Caso the company does not resolve the problem, the consumer can register a complaint on the Procon website in their city or state.
Consumer Direitos when purchasing online
Advogados specialized in consumer law indicate preventive measures to avoid fraud when purchasing online:
- Realizar purchases exclusively on recognized and trusted platforms
- Nunca make direct payments to the seller outside the platform environment
- Registrar photos, videos and purchase tracking data
- Formalizar complain to the intermediary in case of irregularity
Matheus Tamada, one of the experts consulted, recommends documenting all evidence when an irregularity is found. Thyago Garcia, another lawyer, highlights that large marketplaces offer greater security and traceability, in addition to responding jointly for damages to the consumer.
Possibilidade compensation for moral damage
Garcia highlighted that receiving a low-value product in place of a high-cost good can constitute so-called presumed moral damage. Isso means that jurisprudence recognizes the psychological shock, the frustration of legitimate expectations and the feeling of humiliation experienced by the consumer without the need for specific proof of the damage.
In his speech to g1, Valentina compared the experience to that of buying a product in a physical store: “Imagine that you go to the mall, choose an iPhone, pay in cash, but the attendant gives you condensed milk. The feeling of humiliation is the same, added to the expectation of the delivery of a product that never arrived.”
Casos like this highlight the importance of strict supervision in the logistical processes of large e-commerce platforms and serve as a warning for consumers to keep detailed records of their online purchases.







