A new petition filed with Comissão Interamericana from Direitos Humanos, in Washington, brought to light reports from criminal police officers about conversations in Tremembé’s prison. The document mentions the name of Antônio Nardoni, father of Alexandre Nardoni, as a possible mastermind behind the murder of Isabella Nardoni in 2008.
Associação of Orgulho LGBTQIAPN+, chaired by Agripino Magalhães, is responsible for the initiative. The text calls for the reopening of investigations, preventive arrest of Antônio Nardoni and face-to-face monitoring of the case by the international court.
Relatos of criminal police based petition
Policiais criminals who worked in Tremembé’s prison unit would have heard statements from Anna Carolina Jatobá. Segundo the document, she would have indicated that she acted on orders from “that guy”. A nod of the head would confirm the reference to the father-in-law when asked directly.
The confidential statements were attached to the petition. Pelo at least three servers would have witnessed the dialogues. The association maintains that the information reveals direct participation by Antônio Nardoni in both the planning and execution of the crime.
- Depoimentos secrets from criminal police officers who worked on Tremembé
- Gestos and Jatobá’s emotional responses during conversations
- Acusação guidance for changing the crime scene after the fact
- Pedido of breach of telephone confidentiality to prove procedural fraud
- Solicitação witness protection measures
Family’s Defesa denies allegations
The Nardoni family rejected the new accusations. The defense informed that it will take legal action against the authors of the statements. Antônio Nardoni denied any involvement in the case.
Alexandre Nardoni and Anna Carolina Jatobá are serving open sentences. Eles were convicted by Tribunal of Júri in 2010. Alexandre received 31 years and one month in prison. Jatobá was sentenced to 26 years and eight months.
Pedidos include international tracking
The petition requests that the IACHR monitor the case in person. Lawyer Angelo Carbone represents the association in the action. The document also requests an analysis of possible procedural fraud in the original investigation.
Agripino Magalhães defends urgency in taking action. Ele argues that the new information warrants review of the trial. The entity had already questioned São Paulo court decisions in other instances.
Repercussão on Alphaville and region
Moradores from neighborhoods like Alphaville, in São Paulo, expressed apprehension about the couple’s freedom. The circulation of Alexandre Nardoni and Anna Carolina Jatobá generated debates on networks and in local groups.
The complaint revives discussions about the case that shocked the country in March 2008. Isabella was five years old when he died after falling from his sixth-floor apartment. The building is located at Zona Norte in the capital of São Paulo.
Detalhes from the original conviction
The jury found that Alexandre Nardoni and Anna Carolina Jatobá killed the girl. The body was found on the sidewalk of the building. Peritos pointed out injuries compatible with beatings before the fall.
The sentence considered aggravating factors such as the victim’s age and family ties. The convicts served part of their sentence in a closed and semi-open regime before progressing to the open regime.
Initial Investigação ruled out third
The investigations of Polícia Civil and Ministério Público at the time did not indict Antônio Nardoni. The hypothesis of his participation was analyzed, but did not succeed due to lack of evidence.
Especialistas consulted by press outlets recall that similar suspicions circulated shortly after the crime, without support for criminal action. The new petition attempts to reopen this debate internationally.
What the IACHR can do
Comissão Interamericana of Direitos Humanos receives reports of violations in OAS member countries. Brasil is part of the organ. Casos like this undergo preliminary analysis before possible admissibility.
The process can take years. The court does not have the power to directly arrest, but recommendations influence national authorities. The association calls for urgent precautionary measures.
The Isabella Nardoni case continues to generate commotion. The new complaint adds a layer of complexity to what was already one of the crimes most closely followed by Brazilian public opinion.
