New York judge suppresses part of the evidence from Luigi Mangione’s backpack in murder case

A Nova York state judge ruled Monday to partially suppress evidence collected from Luigi Mangione’s backpack. The determination comes in the process that accuses the 28-year-old man of the murder of Brian Thompson, CEO of UnitedHealthcare, in December 2024.
Magistrate Gregory Carro accepted the defense’s argument that the first search of the backpack, carried out by the police at Pensilvânia, occurred illegally, without a warrant. Itens as a loaded pistol magazine, a cell phone and a computer chip are excluded from the trial.
BREAKING: Luigi Mangione scoring a partial victory in court as a judge rules that evidence recovered from the alleged UnitedHealthcare CEO killer’s backpack at a McDonald’s must be suppressed.
— Fox News (@FoxNews) May 18, 2026
According to the ruling, that evidence includes a loaded gun magazine, a cellphone, a… pic.twitter.com/uqdsPKVmK3
Initial Busca deemed illegal by Justiça
Police arrested Mangione after five days of searches. Durante the initial approach, agents searched the backpack without judicial authorization. The judge understood that there was no valid justification for the action at that time.
Mangione introduced himself to Manhattan’s Supremo Tribunal for the audience. Ele has remained imprisoned since capture. The decision was announced in a short session, with the presence of the accused.
Itens from second search remains valid
Carro considered the search carried out later, at the police station, to be legal. Therefore, a gun, a silencer, a flash drive and a red notebook can be used as evidence. Esses objects were found in a subsequent procedure that followed appropriate procedures.
- Carregador of loaded pistol and cell phone from the initial search — suppressed
- Arma and silencer recovered at the police station — admissible
- Caderno red with annotations — can be presented
- Pen drive found in second search — valid as evidence
- Original approach computer Chip — deleted
Prosecutors from Alvin Bragg’s office, Manhattan’s district attorney, say they have other strong evidence. Entre has DNA, fingerprints, footage and a second backpack abandoned by Mangione.
Defesa questioned legality of initial statements
Mangione also requested the deletion of statements made shortly after the arrest. The judge rejected this point. The initial statements to the police remain valid for the process.
Advogados of the accused maintained that he did not receive adequate rights guidance. Justiça maintained the statements were admissible.
Julgamento set for September
The case goes to trial in state court starting September 8. The phase should last about six weeks. Mangione has pleaded not guilty to all charges.
The crime occurred on December 4, 2024, in front of a hotel in the center of Manhattan. Brian Thompson was shot while participating in a company event.
Caso federal remains parallel
Mangione also responds to the federal Justiça lawsuit. The charges include murder and gun possession. A separate trial is scheduled for November.
Monday’s decision does not directly affect the federal case, which has its own procedure. State prosecutors emphasize that the volume of remaining evidence is sufficient to support the accusation.
Repercussão case
Thompson’s murder gained national attention. Parte of public opinion associated the crime with criticism of the practices of health insurers. The judge had already rejected the terrorism charge due to a lack of sufficient evidence.
Mangione remains in detention. The next step is jury preparation for the September trial.






