Pular para o conteúdo
Menu
Mix Vale

Research shows that the popularization of smartphones, which began with the iPhone, may explain the decline in birth rates

Carolina Costa
Por 5 min de leitura
Compartilhe
Bancada de Smartphones
Foto: Bancada de Smartphones - Foto: Framesira / Shutterstock.com

Recent research, which raises provocative discussions, suggests a direct link between the spread of smartphones and the continued decline in birth rates globally. The study points to the launch of the iPhone in 2007 as a crucial milestone in this demographic scenario.

Publicidade

Economist Caitlin Myers proposes a surprising justification for the reduction in the number of children per woman: the ubiquity of smart phones.

Myers, along with other academics, has been dedicated to understanding the factors behind the sharp drop in fertility rates over the past two decades, with births in the United States recording a 22% decline since 2007.

Publicidade

Initially, economic experts conjectured that the Great Recession was the main cause, expecting birth rates to recover soon, following patterns seen after previous economic crises.

However, even with the economic recovery, the birth rate continued to decline, contrary to expectations.

Given this scenario, the crucial question for researchers was: if the recession was not responsible, what would explain the persistent drop in birth rates?

“Whatever the answer is, it needs to be something that has a big impact and be in line with the year 2007, as that is when we saw a dramatic decrease in the birth rate,” explains Myers, who serves as an economics professor at Middlebury College in Vermont.

Coincidentally, it was that year that Steve Jobs, then CEO of Apple, introduced the iPhone, proclaiming that “every time, a revolutionary product comes along that changes everything.”

Publicidade

This change, perhaps, even extended to birth rates.

In a recently published working paper with the thought-provoking title “Is the iPhone a contraceptive method?”, Myers argues that the popularization of smartphones could be responsible for a significant portion, between a third and a half, of the decline in births recorded during this period.

In its first years of circulation, it was noted that regions where purchasing an iPhone was viable had higher birth rates.

To validate her hypothesis, the economist skillfully used a historical singularity that configured a type of natural experiment. At launch, iPhones only operated on AT&T’s network.

“In certain parts of the country, AT&T had broadband coverage, allowing the purchase of an iPhone, while in others, like where I live in Vermont, this coverage was much more restricted,” recalls Myers. “And what we can infer from this simple comparison is that births begin to decrease where the device can be purchased, and not with the same intensity where it is not possible.”

There were those who considered that the results could be biased, given that smartphones spread more quickly in urban areas or areas with greater purchasing power. However, the findings remained consistent even after Myers adjusted variables such as demographic density and local economic situation.

The decrease in birth rates affected women of all age groups, but was more significant among teenagers. This finding resonates with Jean Twenge, a psychology professor at San Diego State University.

In works such as “Generations: The Real Differences Between Gen Z, Millennials, Gen X, Baby Boomers, and Silents”, Twenge detailed the profound behavioral changes that came with the rise of smartphones, especially among youth.

“The smartphone has fundamentally altered the way teenagers spend their time outside of school,” Twenge told NPR. “They began to spend much more time online and on their cell phones and much less time socializing in person with friends, going for a drive, going to the mall or simply having fun.”

Myers points out that it is not difficult to conceive that such a change in behavior could lead to a lower number of births.

“If there’s anything I learned from abstinence-based sex education in the ’90s, growing up in Georgia, it’s that you probably won’t get pregnant if you don’t interact with people in person—if you don’t have sex,” notes Myers.

In the study, developed in co-authorship with his 24-year-old stepson, Ezekiel Hooper, Myers indicates that smartphones have also democratized access to information about contraceptive methods and abortion, placing it directly in the palm of users’ hands.

Mobile devices may have additionally contributed to the reduction in birth rates by making it easier for people to access pornographic content.

“When I talk to my students at Middlebury College, this is the first question they raise,” reports Myers. “Pornography was functioning as a substitute for in-person social interactions.”

Apple did not comment on the conclusions of Myers’ article when questioned.

Over time, other cell phone models emerged, compatible with different operators, and today smartphones have become ubiquitous. Myers argues that this reality raises the question of whether birth rates will stabilize now or continue to decline.

“I consider it likely that we will continue to see the effects of cell phones on behavior and outcomes such as fertility in the coming years,” she says. “But we will have to continue monitoring the situation.”

Notícias relacionadas