Crystal Palace blocks Marc Guehi’s transfer to Liverpool on final day of window

In the frenzy of the final day of the European transfer window on September 1, 2025, Crystal Palace blocked the departure of their captain, Marc Guehi, to Liverpool, despite an initial £35 million agreement and completed medicals. The decision came after a twist involving Brazilian defender Igor Júlio, who chose to join West Ham instead of Palace, leaving the London club without an immediate defensive replacement. The move shook the English transfer market, with Liverpool, aiming to bolster their defense, now facing uncertainties, while Palace reinforces its squad with other options. The news, confirmed by sources close to the clubs, underscores the complexity of deadline day negotiations and Guehi’s importance to the current FA Cup champions.
Liverpool, who had already invested heavily in the window with signings like Alexander Isak, saw Guehi as the ideal long-term replacement for Virgil van Dijk. Palace’s refusal to release the player without a solid defensive alternative reflects the cautious strategy of manager Oliver Glasner. Meanwhile, Igor Júlio’s choice of West Ham, influenced by the promise of more playing time, altered the course of negotiations.
- Key developments in the transfer window:
- £35 million agreement between Liverpool and Crystal Palace for Guehi.
- Guehi’s medicals completed in London.
- West Ham intercepted the deal for Igor Júlio, who rejected Palace.
- England’s transfer deadline: 7 PM (3 PM Brasília time).
The Crystal Palace decision sparked immediate reactions among fans and analysts, with many highlighting Guehi’s importance to the club, especially after his leadership in the 2025 FA Cup triumph.
Twist in Igor Júlio’s transfer
The transfer of Igor Júlio, a 27-year-old Brazilian defender, was seen as key to enabling Guehi’s departure. The player, who has been with Brighton since July 2023, underwent medicals in London on the morning of September 1, initially to sign with Crystal Palace. However, West Ham, led by Brazilian Lucas Paquetá, presented a more attractive offer, ensuring Júlio a starting role. The change of plans caught Palace off guard, forcing the club to reassess its defensive strategy.
The impact of Júlio’s decision was immediate. Without a suitable replacement, manager Oliver Glasner chose to retain Guehi, prioritizing squad stability. The move also affected Liverpool, who were awaiting Guehi’s release to strengthen their defense alongside Virgil van Dijk and Ibrahima Konaté. The outcome exposed the fragility of last-minute negotiations, with clubs racing against the clock to finalize deals.
- Factors influencing Igor Júlio’s decision:
- Promise of a starting role at West Ham.
- Less competition for a spot compared to Crystal Palace.
- Prior Premier League experience with Brighton.
- Loan deal with an option to buy.
Crystal Palace’s defensive strategy
Crystal Palace, aware of Liverpool’s interest in Guehi, had been exploring options to bolster their defense. In addition to Igor Júlio, the club secured the signing of Jaydee Canvot, a 19-year-old defender from Toulouse, for £20.8 million. Canvot, who signed a four-year deal, is seen as a long-term investment, but his lack of Premier League experience raised doubts about his ability to replace Guehi immediately. Palace also maintains interest in Serbian defender Strahinja Pavlovic from AC Milan, but the deal did not progress before the window closed.
Palace’s stance reflects a dual strategy: protecting the current squad while planning for the future. Guehi, with 155 appearances for the club since 2021, is central to Glasner’s system, especially after leading the team to a victory over Manchester City in the FA Cup final. The decision to keep him, even with his contract nearing its end in 2026, avoids the risk of losing him for free next year.
The club also faced financial pressures. Selling Guehi for £35 million, while lucrative, required an immediate replacement to maintain competitiveness in the Premier League. Without Igor Júlio, Palace opted for caution, prioritizing squad continuity.
Impact on Liverpool and alternative plans
For Liverpool, the collapse of the Guehi deal marks a setback in their ambitious transfer window. The club, which invested around £200 million in players like Florian Wirtz, Milos Kerkez, and Alexander Isak, saw Guehi as a cornerstone for the next decade. The absence of a new defender may overburden the starting duo of Van Dijk and Konaté, with Joe Gomez and young Giovanni Leoni as limited bench options.
Liverpool’s strategy now shifts to the winter window in January 2026, when Guehi could sign a pre-contract with other clubs if he does not renew with Palace. The club is also monitoring other targets, such as Alexander Isak, but the priority remains strengthening the defense. The amicable relationship between the clubs, reinforced by mutual respect between manager Arne Slot and Palace chairman Steve Parish, may facilitate future negotiations.
- Liverpool’s defensive options:
- Joe Gomez as an immediate backup.
- Giovanni Leoni, signed from Parma for £26 million.
- Potential interest in new defenders in the winter window.
- Monitoring Guehi for 2026 if he does not renew.
Market and fan reactions
The deadline day twist sparked intense debate among fans and pundits. At Crystal Palace, the decision to retain Guehi was celebrated by many fans, who see the defender as a symbol of the club’s recent success. His performance in a 3-0 win over Aston Villa, where he scored a goal, reinforced his importance. However, uncertainty about his future, with his contract nearing its end, worries supporters, who fear a free exit in 2026.
At Liverpool, fans expressed frustration on social media, with many criticizing the reliance on last-minute deals. The English press, including The Mirror, praised West Ham’s ability to capitalize on the situation, securing Igor Júlio and disrupting their rivals’ plans. Analysts like Paul Merson lauded Guehi, calling him a “bargain” at £35 million, given his quality and international experience.
- Fan sentiments:
- Crystal Palace: relief at Guehi’s stay, but concern about his future.
- Liverpool: disappointment with the deal’s collapse, optimism for 2026.
- West Ham: excitement over Igor Júlio’s arrival.
Premier League deadline day landscape
The final day of the transfer window saw intense activity in the Premier League. Beyond the Guehi and Igor Júlio saga, other English clubs sealed significant deals. Liverpool, for instance, confirmed the signing of Alexander Isak for £125 million, one of the largest in football history. Manchester City explored a move for goalkeeper Gianluigi Donnarumma, while Fenerbahçe secured a Brazilian goalkeeper, outbidding rivals Galatasaray.
Crystal Palace, despite not releasing Guehi, bolstered their squad with Canvot and continues to pursue Pavlovic, signaling ambition for the 2025/26 season. West Ham, with Igor Júlio, strengthens its defense and gains momentum to compete for higher positions. The activity reflects the competitiveness of the English market, where last-minute decisions can shape a team’s trajectory.
- Other deadline day highlights:
- Liverpool: signing of Alexander Isak for £125 million.
- Manchester City: interest in Donnarumma, contingent on Ederson’s exit.
- Fenerbahçe: deal for a Brazilian goalkeeper, outpacing Galatasaray.
- Crystal Palace: arrival of Jaydee Canvot for £20.8 million.
Marc Guehi’s future and implications
Marc Guehi’s future remains uncertain, despite his stay at Crystal Palace for the current season. With his contract expiring in 2026, the defender could negotiate with foreign clubs starting in January, increasing pressure on Palace to renew his deal or sell him in the next window. His importance to the club, proven by consistent performances and leadership on the pitch, makes him a valuable asset but also a target for Europe’s top clubs.
For Liverpool, the winter window will be crucial to revisit their defensive strategy. Confidence in the Guehi deal, expressed by journalists like Ben Jacobs, suggests the Reds won’t give up easily. Meanwhile, West Ham celebrates Igor Júlio’s acquisition, who could become a defensive cornerstone under Julen Lopetegui.
The 2025 deadline day showcased the unpredictability of the transfer market, with last-minute decisions shaping the future of clubs. Crystal Palace, by holding onto Guehi, maintains its defensive strength but faces the challenge of planning ahead without losing their captain. Liverpool, though frustrated, remains a Premier League powerhouse with a reinforced squad and high ambitions for the season.






