Federal judge dismisses indictments of Comey and Letitia James for illegal appointment of prosecutor

An Estados Unidos federal judge on Monday dismissed criminal indictments against former FBI director James Comey and the attorney general of Nova York, Letitia James. The decision took place in Washington, after magistrate Cameron Currie concluded that prosecutor Lindsey Halligan, responsible for the accusations, held the position illegally. The filing was based on violation of federal law that limits the service time of acting attorneys to 120 days, without Senado confirmation or judicial approval.
The appointment of Halligan, made by President Donald Trump in September, was considered invalid because he succeeded the previous interim, Erik Siebert, after the term expired in May. Currie, appointed by
Comey was facing charges of making a false statement to Congresso and obstructing an investigation, while James was charged with bank fraud and making a false statement to a financial institution. Ambas the defenses claimed that the allegations lacked basis and were aimed at Trump’s political enemies.
Appointment of Halligan under political pressure
President Trump announced Halligan as interim attorney for Distrito Leste of Virgínia on September 20, one day after forcing Siebert out.
The choice came after public posts by Trump on Truth Social, where he pressured Attorney General Pam Bondi to move forward with charges against Comey,
Halligan, a former advisor to Casa Branca and an insurance lawyer with no experience in criminal cases, took office on September 22 and presented the cases to the jury alone.
Details of the charges and defenses
Comey was indicted on September 25, days before the five-year statute of limitations on the charges expired.
James was reported on October 10 with allegations of mortgage fraud.
Career prosecutors at the office recommended against prosecution due to lack of sufficient evidence, but Halligan proceeded alone.
The judge rejected an attempt by Departamento and Justiça to retroactively ratify Halligan’s actions, stating there was no legal basis.
Reactions from those involved to the filings
In a video on Instagram, Comey thanked the court and criticized Departamento of Justiça under Trump as a reflection of malevolence. Ele reinforced the need for an independent Judiciário against presidential abuses.
Letitia James released a statement celebrating the victory and reaffirming its commitment to New Yorkers, despite the unfounded accusations. Seu lawyer, Abbe Lowell, highlighted the president’s extreme measures to replace reluctant prosecutors.
- Casa Branca spokeswoman, Abigail Jackson, stated that the facts of the allegations remain and the case is not over.
- Departamento of Justiça and Halligan did not immediately comment.
- Comey’s lawyer, Patrick Fitzgerald, indicated that the statute of limitations prevents the charges from being refiled.
Implications for other legal proceedings
The filings occurred without prejudice, allowing possible resubmission in six months, in accordance with federal law. No However, lawyers for Comey argue that the statute of limitations has already run, making the case null and void.
Currie expressed skepticism about the government’s defense during a joint hearing on Nov. 13, where a prosecutor called the error a “bureaucratic failure.”
The ruling could affect other defendants in Halligan’s office, such as Cabul airport bombing suspect, Mohammad Sharifullah, who disputes his authority.
In Nova Jersey, the disqualification of another prosecutor allied to Trump, Alina Habba, paralyzed cases pending appeal.
Halligan is the fourth Trump nominee invalidated by federal judges in districts including Califórnia and Nevada.
Carl Tobias, professor of Direito at Universidade of
Comey and James maintain pending requests for dismissal with prejudice, alleging selectivity and revenge in the prosecution.






