Italian court withdraws custody of children from British-Australian couple in Abruzzo forest due to health risks

The Tribunal of Justiça of L’Aquila, in the Itália, ordered the removal of three children from their parents’ custody, The decision took place on November 20, 2025, in the region of Abruzzo, after authorities identified serious violations of the health and safety of minors. The couple lived in an isolated rural house in the forest of Palmoli, without access to running water, electricity or gas, and provided homeschooling for their children.
The family attracted public attention in September 2024 when all five members were hospitalized for poisoning after consuming toxic wild mushrooms collected in the woods. Serviços assessed living conditions as inadequate, citing a lack of regular social interactions and stable income. The minors, an eight-year-old girl and six-year-old twins, were transferred to a sheltered educational community.
Family history at Itália
The couple moved to Itália in 2021, after Catherine left her career as a riding instructor at Austrália to pursue life coaching and spiritual healing practices. Nathan, former professional chef of Bristol, at
They use solar energy for basic needs and draw water from a nearby well, maintaining a routine focused on alternative education. The residence, purchased in a deteriorated state, lacks modern sanitary facilities, which contributed to the judicial intervention.
Conditions that motivated the legal action
Authorities reported a lack of sanitary facilities in the house, which exposes minors to environmental risks. Homeschooling, although legal in Itália, has not been proven with formal curriculum, raising concerns about cognitive development.
The mushroom incident in 2024 accelerated investigations, revealing a lack of regular medical supervision beyond sporadic pediatric consultations. Assistentes social groups highlighted social isolation, with interactions limited to the local community.
- No close family support network;
- Dependence on collecting wild foods without specialized guidance;
- House structure with cracked walls, despite basic maintenance.
Parental statements regarding removal
Nathan described the police operation as sudden, taking place on Thursday afternoon, with ten officers present. Ele denies neglect and claims the children receive adequate care, including visits to a pediatrician.
Catherine, allowed to accompany her children initially to minimize the emotional impact, reported forced separation at the shelter after 10 days. The family’s lawyer, Giovanni Angelucci, disputes legal allegations, alleging inaccuracies in the report, especially regarding education.
The couple plans to appeal the decision, arguing that a simple life promotes better well-being than conventional living.

Public and political reactions to the case
The news sparked a national debate about alternative lifestyles, with more than 33,000 signatures on an online petition calling for reunification. Deputy Prime Minister Matteo Salvini criticized the action as excessive, comparing it to interventions in minority camps.
Children’s rights experts emphasize balancing protection and freedom, citing that similar cases have increased by 15% in rural Italian regions over the past two years.
Legal aspects of home education in Itália
Italian legislation allows homeschooling as long as parents notify authorities and submit annual study plans. No However, juvenile courts may intervene if there is evidence of developmental harm.
In this case, inspectors verified the absence of curricular documentation, leading to the risk classification. Off-grid Famílias faces greater scrutiny, with 20% of removals in Abruzzo linked to isolation in 2024.
The appeals process can last up to six months, during which the minors remain under observation.
Daily life on the rural property
The routine involved shared tasks, such as caring for animals and gardening, promoting practical learning. Parents say this fosters independence, with children helping with seasonal harvests.
However, reports indicate logistical challenges, such as transportation to medical appointments 30 kilometers away. The property, covering an area of 5 hectares, serves as a refuge, but limits access to essential services.
Transition procedures for minors
The children were taken to a welcoming structure in Chieti, with initial psychological support. Autoridades prioritized continuity of routines, including supervised contact with the mother.
Monthly assessments will monitor adaptation, with the possibility of return conditioned on improvements to the residence. The father remains in the house, prohibited from unauthorized visits.






