Remember the death of Liam Payne: Investigation points to negligence in Buenos Aires hotel

Argentine authorities are making progress in investigating the circumstances that led to the death of Liam Payne, former member of One Direction, on October 16, 2024. The 31-year-old British singer fell from the third floor of the CasaSur Palermo hotel, in The autopsy confirmed polytrauma as the cause, with multiple injuries and internal and external bleeding.
The incident occurred around 5pm local time, when hotel staff called an emergency due to an aggressive guest under the influence of substances. Payne, in the city to attend a show by Niall Horan, a former bandmate, was taken back to his room in an altered state, without immediate medical attention.
- Toxicological report: Presença of cocaine, alcohol and antidepressants in the body.
- Forensic examination: Ausência of protective reflexes during the fall, indicating unconsciousness.
- Evidence in the room: Garrafa of whiskey, used cans and suspicious white powder.
Circumstances of the fall
Investigators reconstructed that Payne passed out in the hotel lobby minutes before the accident. Três employees dragged him to his room, ignoring the risk of the balcony. Judge Laura Bruniard highlighted that the state of intoxication worsened the situation.
Reports indicate that the singer consumed cocaine nasally and inhaled hours before. Autoridades found damaged items at the scene, reinforcing the disorder.
Accusations against those involved
Five people faced initial cartoons related to the case. Roger Nores, a friend of Payne, was accused of abandonment of a vulnerable person. Gilda Martin, manager, and Esteban Grassi, receptionist, were charged with manslaughter due to negligence in emergency protocol.
Ezequiel Pereyra, a former employee, and Braian Paiz, a waiter, were indicted for supplying drugs. Pereyra surrendered to the police in November 2024, after Paiz was detained three days earlier.
In February 2025, a court acquitted Nores, Martin and Grassi due to lack of direct evidence. Pereyra and Paiz remain in prison, with proceedings ongoing and sentences of up to 15 years expected.
The acquittal decision was based on expertise that did not link direct actions to the fall. No However, drug defendants deny the allegations in depositions.
Prosecutors appealed the acquittals, but a judicial panel denied the request in March 2025. The case remains focused on the supply of substances.
Discovery of the mysterious bag
A guest on the second floor found a leather bag on the balcony on December 5, 2024. The item contained pills, a bottle of Jack Daniel’s, and a note addressed to “Liam”.
Experts believe that Payne dropped her bag while trying to leave the room. The action suggests an effort to escape, possibly linked to drug hallucinations.
The bag, identified as his, differs from another found next to the body. Análises confirmed that it did not contain items that would change the cause of death.
Ongoing court case
The trial of Pereyra and Paiz began in June 2025, with testimonies from hotel witnesses. Autoridades Argentine and British countries collaborate via diplomatic channels.
Paiz admitted shared drug use with Payne, but denied sales in an interview. Pereyra requested freedom, which was denied due to risk of flight.
Final toxicological tests, released in January 2025, indicate cocaine consumption 72 hours earlier, with recent traces. The British inquiry, opened in December 2024, confirmed polytrauma and is awaiting details from Argentina.
Payne’s family criticized media coverage in March 2025, citing emotional harm. Geoff Payne, father, sued Nores for defamation in April.
Trajectory at One Direction
Payne joined the group in 2010, via The The band sold 70 million records across five albums. Global Turnês marked the peak, with hits like “What Makes You Beautiful”. The hiatus came in 2016, leading to Payne’s solo career.
His debut “Strip That Down” reached the top of the charts in 2017. The 2019 album LP1 included partnerships with Rita Ora. Payne canceled a show at Brasil in 2023 due to a kidney infection. Ele spoke publicly about addiction in 2024 interviews.
Reactions from colleagues and fans
Former members of One Direction issued a joint statement in October 2024, expressing mourning. Harry Styles called the years in the band “the most beloved”.
Louis Tomlinson described Payne as “vital” to the group. Cheryl Cole, mother of his son Bear, asked the media for privacy.
Fans organized vigils in Buenos Aires and Londres. Artistas as well as Paris Hilton and Rita Ora posted tributes online. The family administers the £24.3 million estate to nine-year-old Bear without a formal will.






