Comet 3I/ATLAS: NASA’s blurry HiRISE photos fuel discussions about mysterious origin and technical quality

NASA released, on November 30, 2025, images captured by the HiRISE camera on board the Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter probe of the interstellar comet 3I/ATLAS. The event took place at Centro of Voo Espacial Goddard, at Maryland, at Estados Unidos, after a delay caused by a 43-day government shutdown. The release was intended to present initial scientific data, but the blurry photos sparked immediate disappointment among researchers and skywatchers.
The comet, discovered on July 1, 2025 by the ATLAS telescope at Chile, represents the third interstellar object confirmed at Sistema Solar. Sua hyperbolic trajectory and atypical chemical composition attracted global attention from the beginning. The expectation was for clear images that would clarify anomalies such as the anti-solar tail and gas jets, but the inferior technical result fueled questions about transparency and capacity.
Amateur astronomers, in turn, shared clearer views obtained with affordable equipment, intensifying contrast.
The Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter probe recorded the comet from about 30 million kilometers away, on October 2 and 3, 2025.
Delay in disclosure and technical context
The government shutdown in the Estados Unidos, which began in September 2025, prevented the processing and release of images for more than a month. NASA’s Equipes prioritized data calibration, but the live event prioritized scientific explanations over visual quality.
Tom Statler, chief small-body scientist at NASA’s Sistema Solar, emphasized that the photos are for spectral analysis, not aesthetics. The HiRISE camera, designed for stable planetary surfaces, faced challenges with the fast-moving object at three times the average orbital speed of stars in Via Láctea.
Astronomers highlight that space transmissions compress data, reducing resolution compared to terrestrial observations.
Process involved multiple missions, including MAVEN and Perseverance in Marte, which paused operations for captures. Preliminary Dados confirm halo of gas and dust, but fine details await integration with Telescópio Espacial Hubble observations.
Discovery and initial characteristics
Comet 3I/ATLAS appeared in alerts from the ATLAS system, designed to detect asteroids close to Terra. Observações pre-discovery dates back to June 14, 2025, revealing marginal coma and tail elongation of 3 arc seconds.
- Hyperbolic trajectory confirms interstellar origin, with speed of 26 km/s.
- Composition rich in carbon dioxide, with traces of water ice, carbon monoxide and carbonyl sulfide.
- Activity detected at 3.5 and 6.5 astronomical units from Sol, unusual for comets.
Telescopes such as Canada-France-Hawaii at Mauna Kea, at Havaí, and Very Large Telescope at Chile corroborated cometary activity on July 2, 2025. move away.
Core estimated at less than 5.6 km, with 16-hour rotation, defies post-perihelion fragmentation models on October 29, 2025.
Contrast with amateur observations
Amateur astronomers surpassed the official images with low-cost equipment, such as the $600 Dwarf 3 telescope.
Images from backyard telescopes at Nova México and Espanha reveal subkilometer jets and negative polarization of -2.7%, absent in the HiRISE photos. Compressão of spatial data explains part of the difference, but raises debates about scientific prioritization versus public accessibility.
Online community shared stacks of long exposures, highlighting unnatural asymmetry and solar activity. Essas contributions accelerate independent analyses, focusing on non-gravitational acceleration.
NASA recognizes the value of citizen observations by integrating them into global databases.
Observed anomalies and scientific debates
Avi Loeb, from Projeto Galileo, cataloged 12 anomalies, including the absence of a dusty tail despite gas ejection and non-gravitational acceleration without fragmentation. Probabilidade of natural origin falls below 10^{-30}, according to calculations.
Images of James Webb Space Telescope show elevated Ni/CN ratios and H2O content of 4% versus typical 80%. Anti-solar tail, seen from the side by HiRISE, suggests ram pressure greater than the solar wind.
- Extreme polarization indicates exotic composition, possibly pure nickel without iron.
- Post-perihelion glow defies solar models, with excessive energy output.
- X-shaped structures, stretching 1 million km, question satellite artifacts or fragments.
Scientists like David Jewitt, using Nordic Optical Telescope, confirm active diffuse appearance. Debates persist if patterns indicate internal propulsion or exotic astrophysical chemistry.
Observations from multiple missions
Varied missions contributed to the comet’s portrait. Telescópio Espacial Hubble captured an image on July 21, 2025, 277 million miles from Terra, revealing a dust droplet-shaped cocoon.
Perseverance, on Marte, used Mastcam for a photo on October 2, 2025, the first of an interstellar object on a planetary surface. MAVEN detected hydrogen and coma, while SOHO recorded a glimpse of the solar array on October 21, 2025.
PUNCH mission combined images from September 20 to October 3, 2025, showing an elongated short tail. Psyche, STEREO, Lucy and MRO provided spectroscopic data, confirming cyanide and atomic nickel vapor similar to solar comets.
These contributions form an initial gallery, with data expected from Webb in December 2025.
Trajectory and future approaches
The comet reached perihelion at 1.36 astronomical units from Sol on October 29, 2025, between orbits of Terra and Marte. Maximum Aproximação to Terra occurs on December 19, 2025, at 170 million miles, with no risk of impact.
Retrograde orbit with ecliptic alignment below 0.2% suggests thick disk of Via Láctea, possibly older than 7 billion years. Velocidade implies prolonged time in interstellar space.
Nations Unidas activated planetary defense exercise on November 27, 2025, tracking the object via International Asteroid Warning Network. Exercício lasts two months, testing global coordination.
Extended observability favors studies, with Vera C. Rubin Observatory predicting more interstellar detections.
Implications for interstellar research
The case of 3I/ATLAS reinforces the need for telescopes dedicated to hyperbolic objects. Anomalias as dustless ejection and stable rotation drive hypotheses of interstellar shells or exotic chemistry.
NASA plans additional releases of raw data, including FAST and VLT spectra. Comunidade scientific integrates findings to refine models of cometary formation.
Presence of carbonyl sulfide and carbon monoxide suggests “frozen fossil” from another star system. Estudos futures via Webb target isotopic composition, clarifying galactic origins.
Debates between Loeb and space agencies highlight a balance between skepticism and openness to new evidence.






