Federal court confirms that Alina Habba works as a prosecutor illegally in the USA

A federal appeals court ruled this Monday (1st) that Alina Habba, former personal lawyer of President Donald Trump, illegally holds the position of acting federal prosecutor (US
The unanimous panel of Terceiro Circuito confirmed the first instance decision that found a violation of the appointments law by installing Habba in the post without approval from Senado.
The ruling highlights that the government attempted to circumvent the constitutional process of presidential nomination and legislative confirmation.
The case may affect other prosecutors’ offices where the Trump government also does not have nominees confirmed by Senado.
Details of the maneuver rejected by the court
The justices rejected Departamento’s thesis that Attorney General Pam Bondi could indefinitely delegate powers from US Attorney to Habba.
The lawyer had been appointed interim for 120 days, the maximum period provided by law. At the end of this period, Habba formally resigned and was redesignated as “special attorney” and then as “first assistant”, receiving full delegation of authority.
The court classified the sequence of acts as an attempt to circumvent the constitutional requirement of confirmation by Senado for highly relevant positions.
Panel composition and scope of the decision
The trio of judges was formed by Michael Fisher and D.
The decision directly covers Nova Jersey, Pensilvânia, Delaware and Ilhas Virgens Americanas.
Although it does not have binding force throughout the country, precedents of Terceiro Circuito are usually followed in similar cases of constitutionality of appointments.
Recent precedents in other districts
Last week, a federal judge in Virgínia dismissed two charges against former FBI director James Comey and the attorney general of Nova York, Letitia James.
The reason was identical: attorney Lindsey Halligan also held her position in a manner considered illegal.
In the affected districts, most criminal cases continue to proceed normally, but some judges have already postponed trials and sentences pending a definition of the prosecutors’ legitimacy.
Next steps for the government
Departamento of
The department may request a review of the case by the plenary of the Terceiro Circuito or appeal directly to the Suprema Corte of the Estados Unidos.
To date, there has been no official statement from the government or Attorney General Pam Bondi regarding the decision.
Reaction from the authors of the action
The defendants who questioned the legitimacy of Habba celebrated the result.
Lawyer Thomas Mirigliano, who represents one of the three defendants, stated that the panel issued a clear and reasoned decision.
He highlighted that the judgment reinforces the limits imposed by Congresso on the exercise of the position of federal prosecutor.
The precedent reinforces the constitutional requirement for chief prosecutor positions in 93 federal districts in the country. The decision does not automatically invalidate actions carried out by Habba until now, but it prevents her from continuing to perform her role. Similar Casos already appear in Los Angeles, Las Vegas and other districts where the government maintains interim prosecutors without confirmation from Senado.






