Brazilian Harvard professor detained by ICE after firing pellet gun near synagogue in Brookline

Agents from Imigração and Alfândega from Estados Unidos (ICE) arrested Carlos Portugal Gouvea, visiting professor from Harvard Law School, on Thursday, December 3, 2025, at Boston, Massachusetts. The 45-year-old Brazilian was facing visa revocation after admitting illegal use of an air gun in October, near the Temple Beth Zion synagogue, in Brookline. The detention occurred because Departamento of Estado canceled his J-1 visa on October 16, and Gouvea agreed to leave the country voluntarily to avoid formal deportation, according to a statement from Departamento of Segurança Interna (DHS).
The episode began on the eve of the Jewish holiday A security officer approached Gouvea, who claimed to be hunting rats in the backyard of his residence, located next to the synagogue on Beacon Street. Brookline police responded to a call of an armed person and detained him on the night of October 1, 2025.
Gouvea, associated with Faculdade of Direito of Universidade of São Paulo and CEO of IDGlobal, taught at Harvard during the fall semester. Seu lawyer denied any anti-Semitic motivation, and synagogue leaders confirmed that the incident did not appear to be motivated by prejudice, based on police reports that he was unaware of the temple’s proximity and religious date.
Initial incident details
Brookline police registered the case as illegal use of an air gun, leading to Gouvea’s arrest on October 2, 2025.
On November 13, Gouvea accepted a plea bargain agreement on Tribunal Distrital from Brookline. Ele pleaded guilty only to the charge of illegal use of a BB gun, and the others were dropped by the district attorney for Norfolk, Michael Morrissey.
Local authorities cordoned off the area within minutes, with no injuries reported. The temple issued a letter to the community, highlighting that the episode did not indicate religious bias, and the police corroborated this assessment after investigation.
Court settlement and consequences
The plea deal imposed a six-month probation period on Gouvea, with Massachusetts prohibited from possessing firearms or air weapons. Ele complied with the conditions until the visa was revoked, which occurred two weeks after the initial arrest, amid pressure from the Trump government against Harvard for alleged failures to combat anti-Semitism on campus.
DHS issued a statement on Friday, December 4, 2025, stating that Gouvea is “not welcome here” and that his detention strengthens immigration enforcement. Agentes of the Boston removal operation conducted the arrest without incident.
Gouvea plans to return to Brasil in the coming days, where he will resume his duties at USP. Sua voluntary departure avoids a deportation process, which could bar future re-entry into the USA.
Professional background of Gouvea
Carlos Portugal Gouvea built a career as a lawyer specializing in international and corporate law. Formado from USP, he worked as a consultant in global firms before taking on the role of deputy director at IDGlobal, a compliance and risk company.
His appointment in Harvard took place in August 2025, for a semester of academic exchange. Colegas described him as dedicated to seminars on global governance, with no history of prior controversy.
- Experience in comparative law between Brasil and the USA;
- Publications in magazines such as Harvard International Law Journal;
- Leadership in business ethics projects at América Latina.
The university has not issued official comment on the case, citing visitor privacy.
Reactions from authorities and the community
Temple Beth Zion leaders emailed members in October, reassuring them of the absence of hateful motivation. “Police reported that the individual was unaware of the location of the synagogue and the holiday,” President Larry Kraus wrote.
Departamento of Justiça, under Harmeet K. Dhillon, highlighted the episode in public posts, linking it to concerns about places of worship. However, local prosecutors did not file hate crime charges.
Worshipers reported relief at the quick resolution, but reinforced safety protocols for religious events. The synagogue has increased night patrols on Beacon Street since then.
Brookline Police Department filed the report as an isolated incident, with no links to patterns of violence.
Immigration Context for Academics
The J-1 visa allows temporary stays for exchanges, with the requirement not to commit serious crimes. Revogações occur in cases of violations, such as Gouvea, affecting around 300 thousand carriers annually in the USA.
In 2025, DHS reported a 15% increase in arrests of foreign nationals with criminal histories, prioritizing voluntary removals to speed up processes. Essa approach avoids legal costs and allows negotiations.
For Brazilians, the consulate in Boston assists with returns, guaranteeing documentation for commercial flights. Gouvea must attend final check-in with ICE prior to departure.
Similar cases involving foreign scholars account for less than 2% of annual removals, according to 2024 DHS data.
Implications for Harvard Law School
Harvard faces federal scrutiny for alleged failures to protect Jewish students, with negotiations ongoing for compliance agreements. The Gouvea incident comes at a sensitive time, although it does not directly involve the campus.
Law school administrators paused Gouvea classes in October, replacing them with adjuncts. Estudantes reported normal continuity in international law courses.
The episode highlights tensions between academic freedom and immigration enforcement, with the Trump government intensifying audits at Ivy League universities.
USP directors expressed support for their colleague, awaiting his return to resume lectures.






