Botafogo is ordered by CAS to pay US$21 million to Atlanta United for Thiago Almada

The Corte Arbitral of the Esporte (CAS) confirmed this Tuesday (9) the decision of the pay installments for July and September of that year. Caso does not make the payment, Botafogo may suffer a transfer ban, preventing him from registering new athletes.
The dispute began when Atlanta United charged the full balance of the transfer agreement. Botafogo initially contested, claiming that it should only pay the outstanding amounts at the time of the action, estimated at R$32 million. The CAS’s final decision, filed after a hearing in October, maintained the full charge.
OFFICIAL NOTE
—Botafogo F.R. (@Botafogo)December 9, 2025
Botafogo, represented by the law firm Bichara and Motta Advogados, received this Tuesday (09/12) the arbitration decision given by Corte Arbitral ofpic.twitter.com/bqoy2zkQzK
Almada transfer details
Thiago Almada arrived at Botafogo in July 2024 from Atlanta United, from Major League Soccer. The total value of the negotiation was fixed in installments, with part of the payments conditional on the player’s performance.
After a successful spell at the Rio club, the Argentine won the Libertadores and the Brasileirão in the same year. It was then loaned to Lyon and then definitively traded with Atlético of Madrid.
Failure to pay the 2024 installments motivated Atlanta United to take action against Fifa. The case advanced to CAS following an appeal by Botafogo.
SAF official position
Botafogo spoke out through an official note released this Tuesday (9). The club confirmed receipt of Corte Arbitral’s decision from Esporte and informed that it will adopt all applicable legal measures.
SAF highlighted the work of the Bichara and Motta Advogados office in defending the case. The text reinforced the commitment to transparency with fans.
John Textor, majority shareholder of Eagle Football Holdings, presented financing proposals to cover all outstanding issues with Fifa. The businessman also guaranteed resources for the hiring budget in January and during the 2026 season.
Risk of sports punishment
Failure to comply with the decision may result in a transfer ban imposed by Fifa. The punishment prevents new players from registering until the debt is completely settled.
Brazilian clubs have already faced similar restrictions in previous cases of international default. Botafogo finished Brasileirão 2025 in sixth place and plans reinforcements for the next season.
The board works to prevent punishment from affecting sports planning. Textor’s proposals depend on the approval of the Eagle Football Holdings board.
Recent case history
- July and September 2024: Botafogo stops paying installments for the transfer of Almada
- Atlanta United sues Fifa charging the full balance of the agreement
- Botafogo appeals alleging payment only of late installments
- October 2025: hearing held at Corte Arbitral of Esporte
- December 9, 2025: CAS confirms Fifa’s decision maintaining full collection
The club’s next steps
The Botafogo legal department reviews the full CAS decision. Novas legal measures can still be adopted within the deadlines established by the court.
The board holds internal conversations to define the payment schedule. Debt settlement is treated as a priority to avoid punishments.
The club continues to prepare for the 2026 season while resolving the financial issue. The expectation is for a solution before the opening of the next transfer window.
Management context Textor
John Textor acquired SAF from Botafogo in 2022 and invested heavily in rebuilding the squad. The Libertadores 2025 title marked the club’s first continental trophy in 64 years.
The subsequent sale of Almada to Atlético from Madrid generated additional revenue for the club. Parte of these resources can be used to pay off the debt with Atlanta United.
Eagle Football Holdings controls other clubs besides Botafogo, such as Lyon and Molenbeek. The financing proposals presented by Textor cover all of the group’s pending issues with Fifa.
Botafogo seeks to maintain financial balance despite the conviction. The board avoids commenting on the exact values of the Textor proposals until formal board approval.






