Astronomer Avi Loeb supports natural origin of 3I/ATLAS; scale 4 waits for data

Astronomer Avi Loeb, of Universidade Harvard, recently published an article detailing the classification of the interstellar object 3I/ATLAS, discovered in July 2025.
Loeb declined to update the score until new data on the object’s closest approach to Terra, which occurred on December 19, 2025, is publicly released. Analysis of this data is crucial to confirm or change the current understanding of the nature of the object.
In a recent interview, Loeb reiterated his position that 3I/ATLAS is likely a natural object, a view he has held since its initial discovery. Ele observed that the object did not exhibit unexpected maneuvers or artificial light emissions during its passage approximately 269 million kilometers from Terra, reinforcing the expectation of a natural origin.
Scale definition Loeb
The Loeb scale was developed and quantified in peer-reviewed scientific publications, and has been expanded to dynamically incorporate new data. Ela allows you to adjust the ranking of interstellar objects as new observations become available, ensuring an adaptable methodology.
For 3I/ATLAS, the initial value of 4 on the scale reflects anomalies identified shortly after its discovery. Loeb explains that classification is an evolutionary process, dependent on additional information, such as jet spectra or orbital behaviors, which can lead to a revision.
Details of the 3I/ATLAS anomalies
The number of anomalies associated with 3I/ATLAS increased from 8 to 15 over the months of observation. Entre’s peculiar features are an anti-tail jet, which extends millions of kilometers towards the Sol, and non-gravitational accelerations detected.
These particularities significantly distinguish the object from common comets found in Sistema Solar, raising questions about its composition and formation. The persistence of the jet after perihelion is one of the factors that most intrigue scientists.
Another point of interest is the alignment of the object’s rotation axis with the solar direction, even at great distances. Esta rotational stability, combined with the speed and composition of the jets, requires in-depth spectroscopic analysis for a complete understanding.
Loeb argues that events with low probability but potentially high implications deserve rigorous attention from the scientific community. Ele compares this approach to Pascal’s bet, prioritizing data collection even in the face of scenarios that seem unlikely at first glance.
Positioning of Loeb in interviews
In a NewsNation interview with Elizabeth Vargas, Avi Loeb reiterated that his perspective on 3I/ATLAS has not changed significantly since its discovery. Ele emphasized that although the object is most likely natural, the observed anomalies justify continued and in-depth monitoring. Loeb criticized the way the media frequently interprets its statements, suggesting that they are often presented as news, when in fact they repeat arguments already expressed, such as those from July 2025. The object, after passing through perihelion in October 2025, now continues on its trajectory away from Sistema Solar.
Spectroscopic analysis as a criterion
The most revealing data for understanding the nature of 3I/ATLAS should come from detailed analysis of the spectrum of the anti-tail jet, which extends over millions of kilometers. Medições precise speed and chemical composition of this jet are crucial to differentiate whether the observed activity is the result of sublimation of natural ice or technological propellants.
In the scenario of a natural origin, the jet is expected to be composed of gases such as carbon dioxide (CO2), carbon monoxide (CO) and water (H2O), expelled at speeds of hundreds of meters per second. Essas features would be consistent with comet activity.
On the other hand, the detection of anomalous compositions or significantly higher ejection velocities could suggest an artificial origin. Loeb also mentioned that the release of smaller objects in the vicinity of Júpiter or the occurrence of unexpected maneuvers would be clear indicators of a possible technology. In the absence of these signals, the rating on the Loeb scale would be revised downwards.
Future observations of the object
3I/ATLAS’s approach to Júpiter, scheduled for March 2026, represents a final and crucial opportunity for more detailed observations. Missões spacecraft already in operation, such as the Juno probe, could monitor any unusual activity or unexpected characteristics of the object during this passage.
Loeb anticipates that the accumulation of data by that date will have the potential to clarify many of the anomalies currently observed. The scientific approach adopted follows a model similar to that of intelligence agencies, which prioritize the collection of information in events of low probability, but with high potential impact.
Route and main characteristics
Discovered by the ATLAS system in July 2025, 3I/ATLAS was the third interstellar object confirmed to pass through our star system. Sua hyperbolic trajectory, a fundamental characteristic, attests to its origin external to Sistema Solar, differentiating it from native celestial bodies.
Although the object exhibited the coma and tail common to comets, it displayed notable peculiarities, such as the persistent sunward jet, that defy conventional explanations. Observações carried out by telescopes such as Hubble and other missions recorded color changes and complex structures in the jets.
The minimum approach distance to Terra was safe, without posing any risks to the planet. Atualmente, the comet follows its trajectory away from Sistema Solar, maintaining a considerable speed that will take it into interstellar space.







