Women’s union denounces Flamengo president Luiz Baptista to STJD for discriminatory statements

The Brazilian Women’s Union (UBM) has formally filed a complaint with the Superior Sports Justice Tribunal (STJD) against Flamengo’s president, Luiz Eduardo Baptista, known as Bap. This action follows highly controversial remarks made by the executive, which have been widely deemed sexist and discriminatory, directly targeting sports journalist Renata Mendonça of Grupo Globo. The UBM’s move seeks to hold the football club’s top official accountable for statements that, according to the entity, inappropriately devalued a professional woman working in journalism.
The controversy stems from declarations made by the rubro-negro leader during a meeting held on December 23, 2024, at the club’s Gávea headquarters. The journalist became the subject of Bap’s criticism after she publicly questioned the significant disparity in investments allocated to Flamengo’s men’s and women’s football programs, highlighting a common point of contention within the sports community. Her investigative commentary sparked a heated response from the president, culminating in the formal complaint now before the STJD.
UBM alleges discriminatory conduct
The Unión Brasileña de Mujeres asserts that Bap’s actions not only targeted a specific professional but also undermined the standing of women in sports journalism more broadly. The complaint highlights how the president’s comments reduced a respected media figure to her physical appearance, employing derogatory, vexatious, and discriminatory language. This incident underscores ongoing challenges faced by women professionals in male-dominated environments within sports.
The entity’s formal representation requests that Bap be formally charged under Article 243-G of the Brazilian Sports Justice Code. This specific article addresses acts of discrimination, outlining severe penalties for individuals found guilty of such conduct. The UBM emphasizes that the nature of the president’s statements falls directly within the scope of this legislative framework, warranting a thorough investigation and potential conviction.
Flamengo president’s controversial statements
During the December 23 meeting, Bap referred to Mendonça in a highly disparaging manner, stating, “There’s the ‘big-nosed one from Globo’ who keeps badmouthing us and everything, about football, saying we don’t stimulate it.” His comments escalated further, suggesting, “It makes you want to say: ‘Daughter, convince your company to put R$ 20 million a year into broadcasting rights and things will get better. But what applies to João must also apply to Maria.'” This phrase, a common Brazilian idiom, was used in a context perceived as dismissive and belittling.
These remarks quickly drew widespread condemnation from various sectors, including fellow journalists, women’s rights advocates, and even prominent figures within the sports world. The incident became a focal point for discussions regarding gender equality and respect within Brazilian football. The public outcry highlighted a persistent issue of sexism that female professionals often encounter when challenging established norms or critiquing powerful male figures in the industry.
Backlash and broader context in sports journalism
The Flamengo president’s comments ignited a significant wave of protest and solidarity across the sports journalism landscape. Numerous female sports professionals and their allies took to social media and various platforms to express outrage and support for Renata Mendonça. This collective response underscored a growing demand for greater respect and accountability in how women are treated in professional settings, particularly within high-profile industries like sports.
The incident further brought to light the entrenched challenges women face when venturing into traditionally male-dominated fields such as sports commentary and management. Mendonça’s original critique about investment disparities in women’s football is a legitimate journalistic inquiry, frequently raised by critics advocating for gender equity in sports. Bap’s personal attack, rather than addressing the substance of her reporting, diverted attention to her appearance and professional standing.
Many observers connected Bap’s behavior to a broader pattern of disrespect toward female journalists who dare to question or criticize powerful football figures. The widespread condemnation reflected a societal shift, where such discriminatory remarks are increasingly being challenged and are no longer tolerated without significant pushback. The ongoing dialogue around this event is pushing for greater ethical standards and professional conduct from sports executives.
Legal repercussions and potential penalties
The specific article cited by the UBM, Article 243-G, covers acts of discrimination related to race, color, ethnicity, religion, origin, gender, sexual orientation, or disability. If Bap is found guilty under this article, the penalties can be substantial, ranging from a suspension of 30 to 360 days to a significant fine. The maximum financial penalty specified in the code for such infractions is up to R$ 100,000.
The imposition of such a fine, coupled with a potential suspension, would mark a significant disciplinary action against a prominent club president. This outcome could serve as a precedent, signaling a stronger stance by sports authorities against discriminatory behavior within the Brazilian football community. The gravity of the accusations underscores the STJD’s role in upholding ethical standards and promoting fair conduct across all levels of sports.
STJD to analyze complaint in early 2025
The STJD’s prosecution department is scheduled to thoroughly review the inquiry into the Flamengo president’s conduct starting in January 2025. This phase will involve a detailed examination of all evidence submitted by the UBM, including transcripts of Bap’s statements and any supporting documentation or witness testimonies. The department will determine if there is sufficient grounds to formally prosecute Baptista, initiating a full disciplinary process. The outcome of this review will be crucial in defining the next steps for the case, potentially leading to formal charges and a subsequent trial before the sports tribunal, where both sides will present their arguments regarding the alleged discriminatory acts.
Call for respect and equality
This case serves as a poignant reminder of the ongoing struggle for gender equality and professional respect within sports. Advocates are calling for greater accountability from sports leaders, urging them to foster environments where all professionals, regardless of gender, can operate free from discrimination and personal attacks.






