Analysis by Avi Loeb rules out the danger of cyanide released by comet 3I/Atlas for our planet

A detailed analysis conducted by astrophysicist Avi Loeb, from Universidade Harvard, brought peace of mind to the scientific community and the public about the passage of the interstellar comet 3I/Atlas. The study, focused on the materials released by the object, concluded that there is no threat to the safety of the Terra, even with the detection of cyanide in its gaseous composition.
The comet, which represents the third visitor from outside our Sistema Solar already confirmed, reached its closest approach to our planet on December 19, 2025. At the time, it was at a safe distance of approximately 269 million kilometers, a crucial factor for the absence of direct risks.
Loeb’s conclusions are based on data collected by cutting-edge observatories such as Telescópio Espacial James Webb. The action of the solar wind and the vast orbital distance have been identified as natural mechanisms that ensure the dispersion of any potentially harmful compounds long before they could pose a danger.
Discovery and trajectory of the interstellar visitor
Comet 3I/Atlas was identified for the first time on July 1, 2025, by the astronomical survey system ATLAS (Asteroid Terrestrial-impact Last Alert System), located at Chile. Sua detection quickly caught the attention of astronomers around the world due to its unusual trajectory. Análises orbitals confirmed that the object followed a hyperbolic path, indicating that it was not gravitationally bound to the Sol and therefore originated in interstellar space. Sua’s speed, exceeding 60 kilometers per second, reinforced this classification, placing it on the select list of visitors from other star systems, alongside ‘Oumuamua and Borisov. 3I/Atlas’ journey through our system was meticulously monitored, providing a rare opportunity to study the composition of a celestial body formed around another star.
The comet’s closest approach to Sol, known as perihelion, occurred on October 29, 2025, at a distance of 1.36 Unidades Astronômicas (AU) from our star. Após this maneuver, he continued his journey, passing through the closest point to Terra in December of the same year. The minimum separation between the comet’s trajectory and the Terra’s orbit was calculated at more than 55 million kilometers, a safety margin that eliminated any possibility of collision. Telescópios, like Hubble and James Webb, recorded the evolution of its appearance, which went from an initial reddish coma to greenish tones, a phenomenon associated with the release of specific gases under the influence of solar radiation. Após its passage, the celestial object continued on its journey, destined to leave our Sistema Solar and return to the vast interstellar space.
The chemical composition revealed by James Webb
The spectroscopic analysis carried out with the powerful Telescópio Espacial James Webb was fundamental in revealing the chemical secrets of 3I/Atlas. The data revealed that carbon dioxide (CO2) was the dominant component sublimating from its icy core, a feature observed in many comets. However, detection of other compounds has provided valuable insights into their place of origin. Traços of cyanide (CN) and cyanogen were identified in the gas cloud surrounding the nucleus, the so-called coma. Although the presence of cyanide is common in our own Sistema Solar comets, its quantification in an interstellar object is crucial for comparing the chemistry of different planetary systems. Além of these, Webb’s instruments also found evidence of carbon monoxide, water vapor and even nickel, a metallic element that offers clues about the conditions of the comet’s formation. The absence of significant non-gravitational accelerations indicated that the comet’s activity was driven purely by the sublimation of its ices, behaving like a natural comet without any anomalous characteristics.
Risk assessment by Avi Loeb
Astrophysicist Avi Loeb used data on the mass loss rate of 3I/Atlas, measured by James Webb, to calculate the dispersion of its materials in space.
Its main focus was to determine the fate of gases, including cyanide, that break away from the nucleus as the comet approaches Sol.
Calculations have shown that these gases are quickly swept away by the solar wind and radiation pressure, forming a tail that extends for millions of kilometers, but which dilutes to negligible levels over great distances.
Distance and natural protection
The comet’s closest approach on December 19, 2025 occurred at a distance exceeding 1.8 Unidades Astronômicas, which in itself constitutes an insurmountable safety barrier.
This vast spatial separation prevents the cloud of gas and dust that forms the comet’s coma from interacting significantly with the Earth’s atmosphere.
The solar wind acts as an additional shield, pushing particles away from the direction of our planet, ensuring that the passage is a purely observational event.
Any solid particle that could, hypothetically, cross the path of Terra would be microscopic in size and would completely disintegrate upon entering the atmosphere, generating at most a brief meteor.
Continuous scientific observations
In addition to James Webb, a global network of observatories, including the Gemini and Hubble telescopes, followed 3I/Atlas during its passage.
Images captured by these instruments showed fascinating details, such as complex jets emanating from the nucleus and an ever-expanding, shape-shifting coma.
Data collected by space agencies such as NASA and ESA were compiled to create a complete profile of the object, reinforcing its classification as a comet of natural origin.
These comparative observations with previous interstellar visitors, ‘Oumuamua and Borisov, are vital for building a census of the properties of objects formed in other stellar systems.
What the 3I/Atlas passage teaches science
Each interstellar object that crosses our Sistema Solar offers a free sample of material from another part of the galaxy, an invaluable gift to planetary science.
Studying the composition of 3I/Atlas helps scientists understand the diversity of planetary “building blocks” that exist around other stars, informing and refining models of planet and comet formation.
Solid particles and the atmospheric shield
Loeb also considered the risk of larger solid fragments, but estimated that fewer than a million sizable objects had been released recently, an insufficient amount to pose a statistical threat given the enormous distance involved.
Conclusions on planetary security
The calculations of Loeb and observations from multiple telescopes converge to the same certainty: the passage of comet 3I/Atlas was a completely safe astronomical spectacle for Terra.
The combination of massive orbital distances, the physics of gas dispersion by the solar wind and the natural protection offered by the Earth’s atmosphere ensured that the event posed no planetary risk.







