Anomalous mass of 33 billion tons of comet 3I/ATLAS intrigues scientists and generates debate at NASA

A new scientific analysis of the interstellar comet 3I/ATLAS has revealed data that is redefining understanding about visitors from other stellar systems. The object, the third of its kind ever detected crossing our Sistema Solar, has an estimated mass of more than 33 billion tons, a value drastically higher than initial projections. Essa’s colossal size, combined with an unusual trajectory, has intensified debate in the astronomical community about its true nature.
The discovery puts 3I/ATLAS in a category of its own, far surpassing the previously detected interstellar objects ‘Oumuamua and 2I/Borisov. The anomaly in its mass and behavior rekindled the controversial hypothesis, defended by an astrophysicist from Universidade Harvard, that the object could be more than a simple comet, raising the possibility that it is a technology of non-terrestrial origin.
While most scientists look for explanations within known natural phenomena, the unique characteristics of 3I/ATLAS ensure that it will remain under intense scrutiny from space agencies such as NASA and ESA. Continuous observations are crucial to unlocking the secrets of this cosmic giant traveling through our planetary neighborhood.
Calculations that reveal a cosmic giant
The surprising mass and size estimate of 3I/ATLAS was obtained through a thorough analysis of its non-gravitational acceleration. The Esse phenomenon occurs when the heat from the Sol sublimates the frozen gases on the surface of a comet, creating jets that function as natural propellants, subtly altering its route. By measuring this acceleration and the amount of dust and gas expelled, the researchers were able to infer the total mass of the rocky core, which turned out to be up to five orders of magnitude greater than that of ‘Oumuamua and 2I/Borisov. With a diameter exceeding 5 kilometers, the solid core of 3I/ATLAS is comparable in size to the island of Manhattan, but with a density that makes it one of the most massive objects to cross our system from another star. Essa feature sets it apart from any other interstellar celestial body ever studied, providing a first-of-its-kind natural laboratory for understanding the composition and dynamics of distant planetary systems.
The controversial hypothesis of artificial origin
Astrophysicist Avi Loeb of Universidade Harvard, known for his provocative theories about ‘Oumuamua, argues that the 3I/ATLAS anomalies justify consideration of a technological origin. Ele and his team point out that the object’s trajectory, with a low retrograde inclination — rotating in the opposite direction to that of the planets — seems optimized for a reconnaissance flyby of the inner planets of our Sistema Solar, passing relatively close to Júpiter, Vênus and Marte.
According to the Loeb hypothesis, a natural object would have a much more random trajectory. The combination of its peculiar route and unusual non-gravitational acceleration would be, for supporters of this idea, a strong indication that 3I/ATLAS could be an alien probe deliberately sent to explore our region of the galaxy. Although this view is minority, it stimulates a fundamental debate about how science should approach phenomena that defy conventional explanations.
The scientific community’s response
Most of the astronomical community, including researchers from institutions such as SETI and NASA, vehemently dispute the theory of an artificial origin for 3I/ATLAS.
They argue that all of its features, although rare, are compatible with natural explanations. The comet’s hyperbolic speed of approximately 58 km/s is considered typical for objects that have been gravitationally ejected from their home stellar systems.
Furthermore, the analysis of the spectrum of light reflected by 3I/ATLAS shows similarities with type D asteroids, rich in organic compounds, and with the interstellar comet 2I/Borisov, whose natural origin is widely accepted.
Scientists also explain that its unusual trajectory can be justified by its origin in the galactic plane, the region of Via Láctea where most stars are concentrated, making its path less anomalous than it appears at first glance.
Monitoring by space agencies
Administração Nacional of Aeronáutica and Espaço of Estados Unidos (NASA) and Agência Espacial Europeia (ESA) keep 3I/ATLAS under constant surveillance. Recentemente, two ESA probes in orbit around Marte, Mars Express and Trace Gas Orbiter, managed to record images and data of the comet, obtaining the closest view of the object to date.
These observations are key to more accurately determining its chemical composition, rotation rate and the properties of its coma, the cloud of gas and dust that surrounds it. The data collected will help confirm whether its behavior aligns with that of a natural comet or whether anomalies persist that require new explanations.
Safe trajectory and next steps
Despite intense scientific interest and speculation, the trajectory of 3I/ATLAS does not pose any risk of collision with Terra. Orbital calculations indicate that it will pass at a safe distance from our planet.
Its closest approach to Sol, known as perihelion, is scheduled to occur on October 29, at which time Terra will be on the other side of its orbit, guaranteeing a considerable safety margin. The object will also make an approach to Marte, but without any danger to the red planet or the probes studying it.
A visitor older than Sol
Detailed analysis of 3I/ATLAS’s orbit suggests that it may have originated in the thick disk of Via Láctea, a region populated by very old stars.
This implies that the comet could be billions of years old, potentially older than our own Sol and Terra, which are around 4.5 billion years old.
If confirmed, this antiquity makes 3I/ATLAS a true galactic fossil, a messenger that carries information about the chemical and physical conditions of our galaxy in the remote past.
Studying such a primordial object offers a unique opportunity for astronomy, allowing us to glimpse the building blocks of planetary systems that formed in times and places very different from our own.
Chemical composition of the comet
Preliminary spectral analyzes of 3I/ATLAS indicate that its composition is rich in frozen carbon dioxide, in addition to other volatile compounds. Essa predominance of CO2 is an important finding, as it suggests that the comet formed in a very cold region of its home star system, far from its mother star. The presence of these materials provides valuable clues about the chemistry of other parts of the galaxy and the diversity of “ingredients” available for planet formation.






