Defense of driver accused of killing Gaudreau brothers calls for dismissal of charges

The defense of the driver accused of killing brothers Johnny and Sean M. Higgins, 45, faces multiple serious charges in connection with the accident that occurred on August 29, 2024, in The case gained new attention after the American hockey team honored the Gaudreau brothers with the Olympic gold medal won the Sunday before the hearing.
Higgins’s lawyers argued that the alcohol test carried out on the night of the accident used blood plasma instead of whole blood, which would have artificially raised the result. The value presented to the jury was 0.087%, above the legal limit of 0.08% in Nova Jersey, but an analysis by an expert hired by the defense indicates that the real content would be 0.075%, below the limit. Essa discrepancy, according to the defense, compromises the validity of the accusation, as the jury may have been influenced by inaccurate information about driving under the influence of alcohol.
The prosecution said it needs to review the full request and consult with its own expert on the testing method before deciding whether the case should return to the grand jury. The judge responsible for the hearing did not immediately decide on the archiving, and the case remains in the pre-trial phase. Higgins admitted to having consumed alcoholic beverages before driving and failing a field sobriety test at the scene, in addition to leaving the scene of the accident.
Request for dismissal of charges
Attorneys filed the motion on the Monday before Tuesday’s hearing, at Tribunal Superior of Condado of Salem, at Nova Jersey. Eles highlighted that the incorrect presentation of the blood alcohol level to the jury represents a serious procedural failure. The central argument is that the inflated result may have impacted the indictment decision on all counts.
The defense emphasized that it seeks the dismissal “as a precaution”, even though it recognizes that the alcohol issue may not directly affect all charges. Previous Movimentos to dismiss evidence or charges were denied by the same court on earlier dates.
Details of the charges against the driver
Higgins is charged with two counts of first-degree aggravated manslaughter, two counts of second-degree reckless vehicular homicide, one count of fourth-degree tampering with evidence and leaving the scene of a second-degree fatal accident. The most serious charges can carry significant penalties if convicted.
The accident occurred on the eve of Gaudreau’s sister’s wedding, which added to the emotional toll on the family and the hockey community. Johnny Gaudreau, aged 31, was a star forward for Columbus Blue Jackets in the NHL, known as “Johnny Hockey”. Matthew, 29, had played in the AHL minor league before becoming a coach.
Tribute from the American hockey team
The Estados Unidos men’s team carried Johnny Gaudreau’s number 13 jersey and took his sons, Noa and Jogadores as Dylan Larkin and Auston Matthews commented on the moment, highlighting the absence of the brothers and the support for the family.
Larkin said the children’s presence on the ice seemed appropriate, prioritizing Johnny’s family. Matthews mentioned that Johnny’s spirit accompanied the team throughout the tournament. The tribute took place two days before the hearing on the request for dismissal.
Technical arguments about alcohol testing
The defense presented an analysis indicating that the use of plasma in the test increases the result compared to whole blood, the standard for determining the legal limit. The hired specialist recalculated the value to 0.075%, which would place Higgins below the level of drunkenness per se.
Assistant Prosecutor Michael Mestern said he will evaluate the material carefully and hear from the state’s expert before making any formal position. Não there is an immediate date for a new court decision, but the case continues with the next hearing scheduled for April 14th.
Background to the court case
Higgins rejected a plea offer in January 2025 that called for 35 years in prison. Moções previous requests to dismiss charges were denied by judge Michael J.
The accident involved Higgins’s vehicle hitting the brothers who were cycling on a local road. Higgins initially left the scene, but was located and tested by authorities.
The case remains ongoing in the Nova Jersey court system, focusing on the evidentiary issues raised by the defense.






