Italian Supreme Court validates new law limiting European citizenship to great-grandchildren and great-great-grandchildren

The highest legal instance of Roma handed down a ruling that definitively changes the immigration policies and recognition of blood ties in the European country. The measure affects a large number of people around the world who seek to formalize their ancestry in order to obtain European documents. The closure of this legal debate establishes a new standard in the relationship between the Estado and the descendants of emigrants who left the territory over the past centuries.
The high court expressed full support for the position of the local executive branch, which defends the strict application of a decree promulgated in March of the previous year. The normative text creates significant barriers to granting civic status to individuals born outside European territory. Magistrados from lower courts had questioned the constitutional validity of the norm, pointing out possible conflicts with legal traditions established since the country’s territorial unification.
During the deliberation sessions, the collegiate considered the challenges raised by lower courts as partially unfounded, confirming the validity of the government’s interpretation. The decision changes a practice of granting rights that has been in force for over one hundred and sixty years uninterruptedly. The full details of the sentence will be published in the coming weeks, formalizing the definitive guidelines for all administrative and consular bodies across the globe.
Documentary requirements and generation limits
To understand the extent of the new requirements, it is necessary to observe the strict criteria established for the assembly of consular processes following the validation of the law, which now requires extremely complex and specific dossiers. Applicants will need to organize documents proving direct kinship limited to the second ascending generation, which means that only children or grandchildren of Europeans born in the original territory will have the right recognized. The process requires the presentation of negative certificates of naturalization of the ancestor in other countries, unequivocally demonstrating that the lineage was not interrupted by voluntary renunciation of the original nationality at any point in the family history. Outro A fundamental point is the mandatory sworn translation and apostille of all foreign civil records, which increases the technical rigor of the documentary analysis carried out by Estado agents. The rule also establishes a practical prohibition on the possession of multiple passports for a significant portion of applicants, requiring that the ancestor who transmitted the right exclusively held European nationality at the time of the descendant’s birth or until the date of his death, eliminating more distant generational pathways in a summary manner.
Changes in blood rights
The legislative change substantially modifies the principle of the right of blood, which since the 19th century has guided the definition of belonging to the nation. The regulations determine that only individuals who have at least one of their parents or grandparents born in European territory will have their requests for recognition accepted by the competent authorities, breaking with the tradition of continuous transmission.
This restriction eliminates the possibility of transmission of nationality through more distant generational routes, directly affecting great-grandchildren and great-great-grandchildren. Anteriormente, these generations had legal support to initiate the administrative procedure, as long as they proved the absence of renunciation of citizenship by their direct ancestors.
Overload on consular infrastructure
The volume of requests for recognition of blood ties has reached unprecedented levels in the last decade, placing heavy pressure on the diplomatic infrastructure. International representation offices face chronic structural difficulties in processing the massive number of applications filed daily by descendants on different continents.
Official data from Ministério of Relações Exteriores indicate significant growth in the population registered abroad over the last ten years. The number of nationals living outside the European continent jumped sharply, highlighting the high demand for civil registration and passport issuance services at embassies.
In Argentina alone, diplomatic representations processed thirty thousand requests for recognition during a single recent year. Esse número representa um acréscimo de dez mil processos em comparação ao período anual imediatamente anterior, o que levou ao esgotamento da capacidade operacional dos órgãos e ao aumento exponencial das filas de espera.
Operating and financial costs
The journey to obtaining a European passport has always required robust financial planning on the part of families interested in dual nationality. The stage of searching and issuing historical documents in small municipalities in the European interior requires significant time and resources, as each birth, marriage or death certificate located and issued by local registry offices has a high cost. Esse value multiplies quickly depending on the size of the family tree and the complexity of the documentary research required by consular authorities to prove the blood link.
In addition to the costs of issuing original documents, applicants face high costs for sworn translations, apostilles and specialized legal fees. Aqueles who chose to sue The new regulations seek to discourage this judicial route, imposing stricter eligibility criteria that drastically reduce the number of people able to initiate the procedure, regardless of their financial capacity or willingness to bear the costs of the process.
Rules applied to female bloodlines
The transmission of rights through maternal means, which historically involved debates about gender equality and required specific legal actions for descendants of women born before 1948, also suffers the direct effects of the new regulations. The requirement of generational proximity and the prohibition of dual nationality in specific cases apply to all applicants, regardless of the gender of the transmitting ancestor, closing an alternative route that had benefited countless people through favorable jurisprudence over the last fifteen years.
Reactions from associations abroad
The ratification of restrictive measures generated strong dissatisfaction among descendant associations spread across several countries. Representantes of these entities argue that the abrupt change in rules harms thousands of processes that were already in the assembly phase or awaiting analysis in diplomatic representations.
Experts in international law point out that the decision fuels complaints about the breach of legitimate expectations by the Estado. Muitas families have invested years of research and financial resources in structuring dossiers that are now at risk of being summarily archived by the competent authorities due to new generational limits.
Next steps for the justice system
The justice system awaits the publication of the complete ruling to align the internal procedures of regional courts throughout the territory. The document will detail the technical basis used by the superior court judges to reject the allegations of unconstitutionality presented previously.
Diplomatic representations will also go through a period of adaptation to the new operational guidelines established by the central government. Consular employees will receive updated manuals for rigorous screening of pending processes and new requests that are entered into the system.
The objective of the executive branch is to ensure that only applications that strictly comply with generational threshold requirements are accepted for merit analysis. Profissionais from the legal field classify the stance adopted by the judges as extremely strict, consolidating a definitive legal barrier.
With the closure of this highly complex litigation, Estado establishes an efficient mechanism for administrative control over the granting of citizenship. The new legal reality requires interested parties to reevaluate their strategies and thoroughly check their eligibility before starting any bureaucratic procedure with official bodies.






