Popular jury of Monique and Jairinho begins today for the murder of Henry Borel

The trial of the case Henry Borel begins this Monday (23) in II Tribunal of Júri of Dr. Jairinho, former councilor and stepfather of the victim at the time, are accused of triple homicide (a base motive, a resource that made the victim’s defense difficult and through violence against a minor under 14), in addition to failure to provide assistance in the case of Monique. Prosecutor Fabio Vieira stated that the defendants’ defense plans strategies to generate confusion in the plenary, with conflicting narratives during the debates.
The session begins at 9 am, local time on Rio of Janeiro, and should last for several days with the hearing of 27 witnesses. Sete popular jurors will decide whether the defendants are guilty or innocent, after analyzing evidence such as expert reports, statements and electronic records. Ambos have remained in preventive detention since April 2021.
Jury begins after long process
The process has accumulated thousands of pages over the years, with several attempts by the defenses to postpone or change the location of the trial. Alegações of lack of exemption due to wide media repercussion were rejected by the higher courts.
Judge Elizabeth Machado Louro presides over the session on the 2nd Vara Criminal. The expectation is for intense debates between the prosecution and defenses, focusing on the contradictions presented by the defendants.
Conflicting versions presented by defenses
- Jairinho’s defense questions the conclusion of the IML reports and suggests that some injuries could have occurred before the day of death, including under the responsibility of other people.
- Monique’s lawyers claim that she did not witness the attacks and that she acted to help the child by taking her to the hospital.
- The joint strategy includes challenging the chain of custody of some evidence and pointing out alleged flaws in the initial police investigation.
These opposing narratives should generate direct confrontation in the plenary, as predicted by Ministério Público.

Prosecution maintains thesis of intentional aggression
Ministério Público maintains that Jairinho struck Henry violently, resulting in severe liver laceration and internal bleeding that led to death within a few hours. Monique would have witnessed the events and omitted immediate help, worsening the situation.
Necroscopic reports indicate 23 injuries of a blunt nature compatible with intentional human action. The initial version of a domestic accident presented by the couple to the hospital was discarded by technical experts.
Technical evidence at the center of the debate
Experts from Instituto Médico Legal and Instituto and Criminalística reinforced that the mechanism of injury is not compatible with accidental falls or common play by children. The analysis of messages and calls extracted from seized cell phones is also part of the evidence set.
Prosecutor Fabio Vieira classified the defensive maneuvers as an attempt to create procedural disorder. Ele reiterated the certainty of the criminal materiality based on indisputable scientific elements.
Family context and repercussions of the case
Leniel Borel, biological father of Henry and councilor in Rio of Ele denied any interference in the investigations carried out.
The case gained national prominence in 2021 due to the brutality of the injuries and Jairinho’s political position at the time. Após prison, his mandate was revoked for breach of parliamentary decorum, and his professional registration in medicine was suspended.
Penalties provided for in case of conviction
The complaint accuses Jairinho of direct execution of the qualified homicide and Monique of participation by omission, with aggravating circumstances of foul motive linked to jealousy and violence against a minor. Penalties can exceed 30 years in prison if convicted.
The jury will analyze all qualifying and aggravating circumstances to define the dosimetry of the sentence.
Last moves before the session
Recent attempts to move the jury to another district were denied by Justiça. Monique’s defense took a stand against any further postponement and confirmed full participation in the debates.
The prosecutor warned that the defenses plan to present contradictory arguments to each other, which could extend the duration of the trial.
The plenary must follow the confrontation between the versions presented over the next few days.






