Cloned mice die in the 58th generation due to accumulated genetic mutations

A team of researchers from Universidade of Yamanashi, in Japão, led by Professor The experiment, carried out over 20 years from a single female mouse, produced more than 1,200 clones in series. The first 57 generations reached adulthood without apparent problems, but all individuals in the 58th generation died within a few days of birth.
Scientists observed that the re-cloning success rate increased initially, reaching 15.5% in the 26th generation. From that point on, the index began to fall progressively until it reached just 0.6% in the 58th generation. Análises genetic tests revealed that mutations appeared three to four times more frequently from the 45th generation onwards when compared to mice generated by natural mating over 60 generations.
Accumulation of genetic mutations compromises successive generations
The identified mutations were transmitted in full to the following generations and accumulated throughout the process. In most cases, they affected only one of the genes in a pair, which allowed the normal gene to compensate for the failure and maintain the animals’ survival for many generations.
However, the reproductive capacity of clones began to decline sharply after the 50th generation. The researchers found that deleterious mutations were increasing significantly, especially loss-of-function mutations and larger structural variants that impacted coding regions of the genome.
Serial re-cloning reveals limits of technology
The re-cloning process involved the nuclear transfer of somatic cells from already cloned mice to continuously generate the next generation. Essa line of research began in 2005 and lasted for almost two decades with controlled experimental conditions.
During the first phases of the study, the clones presented normal appearance, longevity similar to that of conventional mice and preserved fertility. The team had previously reported that serial cloning could be maintained without reducing efficiency for at least 25 generations.
Genomic analysis confirms increase in harmful mutations
Complete genome sequencing showed that mutations were concentrated in functional regions and that the proportion of deleterious variants was higher in more advanced generations. Essas changes included large deletions and point mutations that, when accumulated, exceeded the threshold tolerable by organisms.
The researchers highlighted that, although the clones appeared identical to the original animal in phenotypic terms in the initial stages, genetic differences became evident as the generations advanced. Accumulation occurred gradually, without significant epigenetic abnormalities associated with the cloning process.
Mating with normal males restores reproductive viability
When cloned females from advanced generations were mated with non-cloned males, the resulting offspring had a number of births close to the normal standard. Essa recovery indicated that sexual mating allowed the elimination or compensation of accumulated harmful mutations.
The data suggest that reproduction by combining genetic material from two different individuals acts as a natural mechanism to purify the genome and avoid collapse caused by the accumulation of errors in clonal replication. Essa discovery reinforces the importance of sexual reproduction for the maintenance of mammalian lineages.
Long-term experiment advances understanding of reproductive biology
Professor Teruhiko Wakayama, a pioneer in cloning mice from somatic cells since 1998, led the work that involved the team’s constant participation over the years. The study was published in the magazine Nature Communications this Tuesday.
The results indicate that, despite technical advances in nuclear transfer, serial cloning encounters fundamental genetic barriers. The technology remains relevant for preserving valuable genetic resources, but does not replace the natural processes of reproduction in mammals.
- Mutation occurs more frequently in cloning than in natural mating
- First 57 generations reached maturity without visible changes
- Success rate dropped drastically after the 26th generation
- Cross-mating with normal males normalizes reproduction
Limits of serial cloning open new perspectives for research
The scientists observed that the deleterious mutations did not impede the early development of embryos until the final generations, but did affect postnatal viability. The absence of apparent physical anomalies in the 58th generation puppies reinforces that the problem lies in accumulated subtle genetic changes.
This line of investigation, initiated more than 20 years ago, contributes to the understanding of the mechanisms that guarantee genomic stability in species. The findings help to define the practical applications of cloning in the conservation of endangered species or in animal production.
The team plans to continue exploring ways to mitigate the accumulation of mutations in reproductive engineering processes. The results highlight that reproduction between males and females remains essential for the healthy perpetuation of mammalian lineages.






