Serial cloning of mice reaches limit in 58th generation with accumulated mutations

Researchers at Universidade of Yamanashi published a study on Tuesday in the journal Nature Communications that demonstrates the limits of successive cloning in mammals. The experiment conducted over 20 years produced more than 1,200 clone mice from a single female donor through somatic cell nuclear transfer. The clonal line reached the 58th generation, when the individuals born died a few days after birth despite having no visible anomalies.
Professor Teruhiko Wakayama led the research that began in 2005 at the Riken institute and continued at Universidade of Yamanashi. Scientists collected cumulus cells from cloned females and transplanted their nuclei into enucleated donor eggs. The surrogate mothers gestated the embryos and the process was repeated every three or four months with cells obtained from the new generations. Todos the individuals generated maintained the female sex and agouti coloration of the original donor.
- The cloning success rate rose from 7.4% in the first generations to 15.5% in the 26th generation.
- From the 27th generation onwards, efficiency began to decline progressively.
- In the 58th generation the average success rate reached just 0.6% and no offspring survived beyond a few days.
Accumulation of harmful mutations over generations
Complete genome sequencing revealed that the clones accumulated mutations at a rate three times higher than that observed in mice born through natural reproduction. Essas changes included loss-of-function mutations and missense mutations that were fully transmitted to subsequent generations without the genetic recombination mechanism present in meiosis. Researchers attribute the increase primarily to the nuclear transfer process and subsequent embryonic development.
In the first 25 generations, the cloned animals presented normal appearance and life expectancy equivalent to that of conventional mice. From the 27th generation onwards, harmful mutations began to manifest themselves more evidently in the reduction of the viable birth rate. Mesmo thus individuals born up to the 57th generation were still able to live without serious clinical signs.
Differences between cloning and sexual reproduction
In natural reproduction, the formation of gametes allows genetic recombination that helps eliminate or dilute harmful mutations. Já in cloning, the somatic nucleus carries all existing mutations and new changes arise during the procedure or during the development of the embryo. Essa absence of recombination explains the progressive accumulation observed in the Japanese study.
The experiment involved exclusively female mice and totaled 1,206 individuals over 58 generations. The researchers highlight that the initial increase in the success rate may have been influenced by the use of reagents such as trichostatin A acid, but even with technical optimizations the genetic limit was imposed.
Implications for applications of cloning technology
Cloning by somatic cell nuclear transfer has the potential for mass production of animals with high genetic value and for the conservation of threatened species. However, the study indicates that the indefinite repetition of the process is not viable in mammals due to the inevitable accumulation of genetic damage. Melhorias techniques are still needed to reduce the introduction of new mutations during the procedure.
Since the birth of the Dolly sheep in 1996, mammalian cloning has technically evolved, but genetic issues such as those now documented remain central. The work of Universidade and Yamanashi provides concrete data on the biological limits of the technique on a scale never before tested.
Long-term experiment details
Scientists maintained consistent experimental conditions with constant participation from Wakayama and collaborators over the two decades. At each cycle, new cumulus cells were extracted from adult cloned females and used to generate the next generation. The process made it possible to monitor the cumulative impact of mutations in real time.
In the 58th generation, the puppies were born without apparent deformities, but died within a few days. The study authors consider it highly likely that the lethal mutations compromised essential functions during the neonatal period. Análises genomics confirmed the clonal origin of all animals from the initial donor.
Comparison with conventional reproductive techniques
In vitro fertilization and natural mating maintain repair and recombination mechanisms that prevent the systematic accumulation of deleterious mutations. In the case of serial cloning, this natural filter is absent, which explains the divergence observed from the middle of the experiment. The researchers reinforce that sexual reproduction remains essential for the genetic sustainability of mammal populations.
The study published this Tuesday represents the longest follow-up ever carried out on successive cloning in mammals. Ele provides direct evidence that the process cannot be extended indefinitely without serious genetic consequences.






