Zanin condemns doctor for misogynistic hazing of freshmen medicine students at Unifran in 2019

Minister Cristiano Zanin, of Supremo Tribunal Federal, sentenced doctor Matheus Gabriel Braia to pay compensation for collective moral damage. The decision refers to his participation in a prank applied to freshmen medical students from Universidade, Franca, to Unifran, in February 2019, in the city of Franca, in the interior of São Paulo. The fixed amount corresponds to 40 minimum wages, an amount that will be intended for Fundo Estadual of Interesses Difusos Lesados.
The legal action started from Ministério Público of São Paulo and reached the STF after processing in lower courts. Previous decisions had removed the responsibility of the then student, now a doctor. Zanin reversed these understandings when analyzing the appeal.
Decision reverses previous acquittals
The lower courts considered that the content of the prank call, although vulgar, did not constitute harm to the community. The first instance in Franca dismissed the action as unfounded. Tribunal of Justiça of São Paulo maintained the acquittal by pointing out the jocular tone and voluntary participation of the students.
Superior Tribunal of Justiça also ruled out collective reparation. The ministers understood that the offense had an individual nature and did not affect the group in a broad way. Essas positions were contested by Ministério Público from São Paulo, who appealed to the STF.
Minister highlights dignity of the human person
Zanin stated that previous decisions disregarded human dignity and the protection of women. Ele classified the demonstrations as forms of psychological violence that contribute to the naturalization of aggression. The minister highlighted that practices of this type cannot be treated as jokes.
The analysis considered the context of the speech given during the “oath”. Freshmen were instructed to promise sexual submission to seniors and to never refuse an attempt at coitus. The men, in turn, swore to use, manipulate and abuse students from other courses.
- The speech was led by the then veteran Matheus Gabriel Braia.
- The event took place at the medical course at Unifran.
- The recording of the prank was widely circulated on social media at the time.
Repercussion of the video expands the scope of the damage
The wide dissemination of the video on social media expanded the reach of the content and reached the female community. Zanin took this aspect into account to recognize collective moral damage. The decision determines that the compensation amount be paid and directed to the state fund.
The case involved medical freshmen in 2019. The hazing included elements that authorities considered sexist, misogynistic and sexist. The conviction reinforces the interpretation that acts of this nature go beyond the individual scope.

Psychological violence cannot be minimized
Demonstrations that involve promises of sexual submission constitute psychological violence according to the decision. Elas contribute to the normalization of aggressive behaviors, including physical ones. The minister assessed that the alleged joking tone does not take away the seriousness of the act.
Universidade of Franca is located in the interior of São Paulo. The episode occurred during reception activities for new students. The public civil action sought compensation for the damage caused to the group of women.
Details of the oath and university context
The text of the oath determined that the students would not refuse sexual advances made by veterans. Essa guidance was repeated collectively during the event. The speech also included explicit references to manipulation and abuse directed at male freshmen.
The participation of Braia consisted of conducting and reading the text. Ele He was a senior in medical school at the time. Após Upon graduation, the student became a doctor and continued to practice the profession.
Fund will receive compensation resources
Payment of 40 minimum wages will be sent to Fundo Estadual of Interesses Difusos Lesados. Esse mechanism allocates resources to actions to defend collective rights. The amount is equivalent, on the date of the decision, to approximately R$64,800, considering the current value of the minimum wage.
The monocratic decision of Zanin responds to the extraordinary appeal presented by Ministério Público of São Paulo. The case was processed under number RE 1588622 at the STF. Ainda Appeal against conviction is possible.
Recognition of collective harm to women
The conviction is based on the understanding that hazing affected the dignity of women collectively. The naturalization of content that promotes sexual submission was highlighted in the analysis. Práticas University women who involve gender humiliation cannot be relativized as mere animus jocandi.
The 2019 episode generated repercussions when it came to light. Relatos and recordings circulated among students and online. The legal action sought to hold those involved responsible for the creation and execution of the ritual.
Minister Cristiano Zanin handed down the decision this Monday, March 30, 2026. The determination reaffirms the constitutional protection of human dignity in educational environments. The case serves as a precedent for analyzing similar conduct in university hazing.






