Holy See considers appeal by deacon excommunicated after denouncing priest for abuse of his son

Permanent deacon Scott Peyton awaits a decision from Vaticano on the appeal against his excommunication imposed by Diocese from Lafayette, on Louisiana. The canonical punishment was made official almost two years after the religious decided to move away from Igreja Católica. The case has been pending in Dicastério for Doutrina of Fé since May 2024. The defense asks for the immediate annulment of the diocesan decree.
Peyton’s departure from the Catholic environment occurred as a result of the sexual abuse suffered by his son, committed by a priest from the same congregation. The process raises profound debates about the application of canon law in situations of family trauma. Especialistas question the pastoral stance of religious authorities during the crisis. The prolonged uncertainty keeps the deacon’s status in suspense before the community.
Broken Confiança and the revelation of the crime in the rural parish
Scott Peyton’s path to Catholicism began with his conversion as an adult, in 2001. Ele and his wife, Letitia, raised their six children under the strict precepts of the religion. Family commitment was evident in daily activities. Peyton even reversed a vasectomy medical procedure to conform to Catholic family planning guidelines. His ordination as a permanent deacon took place in 2012.
The diocese has appointed the new deacon to the parish of São Pedro, located in the rural community of Morrow. The place was already frequented by the family. Lá, a close friendship formed with the local parish priest, Father Michael Guidry. The priest attended Peyton’s house regularly. Ele attended meals and praised the service provided by the couple. The deacon’s children used to help with domestic chores in the rectory.
The proximity hid a dark scenario. In May 2018, Peyton’s son, Oliver, revealed a secret he had kept for three years. The young man reported having been drunk and sexually abused by Guidry in 2015. The report shocked his parents. The unrestrained confidence in the priest’s figure instantly crumbled. The family then began a journey for justice that would definitively alter their relationship with the religious institution.
Exposição family public and the reaction of diocesan leadership
Civil and religious authorities were notified quickly after the crime was revealed. Scott and Oliver reached out to the local sheriff’s office on May 21, 2018. Quatro days later, investigators questioned Guidry. The priest admitted inappropriate conduct at the time, but remained free. The formal denunciation of Diocese by Lafayette occurred on May 29th. Employees demonstrated empathy at first contact.
The leadership’s stance changed drastically the following week. Bishop J. Douglas Deshotel chose June 2, the date of the wedding of Peyton’s eldest son, to announce the accusation during masses. The statement provided specific details. The small community identified the family immediately. Oliver’s name ended up exposed in court documents and local press reports. The breach of anonymity forced the parents to reveal the case to distant relatives abruptly.
A press conference given by the bishop worsened the tension. Deshotel stated that Father Guidry could return to the ministry if the complaint was found to be without credibility. The statement ignored the confessions already made by the priest to the police. The bishop also mentioned that the victim’s parents attended another church in the city of Ville Platte. The diocese offered financial psychological support. The benefit, however, was accompanied by a warning about the cancellation of payments in the event of legal proceedings.
Prisão of the priest and the isolation of the victim in the community
The police closed in on the attacker in mid-June 2018. Guidry gave a new statement, this time accompanied by a lawyer. Ele confessed to the abuse in detail, configuring the crime before the law. The arrest took place the following day. The priest was formally charged, posted bail and was later sentenced to prison. The reaction of the faithful of the São Pedro parish surprised the victim’s family.
Membros from the congregation organized a lunch in honor of the priest. Eles also helped with moving belongings from the rectory. Boatos questioning the veracity of Oliver’s report circulated around the city. Scott Peyton’s isolation has increased considerably. Apenas six of the more than one hundred deacons in the diocese kept in touch with him. The family decided to file a civil lawsuit against Guidry and Diocese of Lafayette in August 2018.
The clergy reacted to the lawsuit with threats to remove Peyton from clerical status. The civil case only came to an end in 2021, with an agreement. The diocese recognized the credibility of the accusations and permanently removed Guidry from ministry. Financial support for the family’s psychological treatment was cut immediately after the document was signed. Scott Peyton founded a non-profit organization to support other victims of abuse.
Cronologia of the legal clash and religious separation
The emotional exhaustion accumulated over the years forced the family to seek spiritual alternatives. Eles started attending an Anglican congregation in search of a welcoming environment. The formalization of Catholic separation required specific documentation.
- Ordenação of Scott Peyton as permanent deacon in Diocese of Lafayette in 2012.
- Abuso sexual act committed by priest Michael Guidry against Oliver Peyton in May 2015.
- Revelação of the crime to the parents and complaint to the civil and religious authorities in May 2018.
- Priest Prisão and public announcement of the case by bishop Deshotel in June 2018.
- Abertura of the civil case against the attacker and the religious institution in August 2018.
- Resolução of the case in court and definitive expulsion of the priest from the ministry in 2021.
- Envio of deacon’s letter of resignation from active ministry in December 2023.
- Recebimento of the official decree of excommunication issued by the diocese in March 2024.
- Apresentação formally appeals to Vaticano for defending Peyton in May 2024.
The resignation letter sent by Peyton in December 2023 explained the reasons for his departure. Bishop Deshotel’s initial response struck a sympathetic tone. The scenario changed three months later. The excommunication decree arrived unexpectedly in March 2024. The extreme measure surprised legal experts at Igreja.
Debate on canon law and the search for a definitive answer
Excommunication represents one of the most severe sanctions in Catholicism. Canon lawyer Dawn Eden Goldstein took on Peyton’s defense free of charge. Ela classified the diocesan decision as a serious pastoral failure. The jurist argued that the deacon did not cause a public scandal nor did he attempt to exercise Catholic ministry after resigning. The lack of prior dialogue on the part of the bishop is the basis for the appeal sent to Roma.
Former Faculdade dean of Direito Thomas R. Kline, Nicholas Cafardi, presented a different technical view. Ele explained that the concept of schism generates an automatic penalty. The official separation of authority from the Igreja results in excommunication without the need for imposition by a bishop. The objective of the sanction would be medicinal, aiming at the future reconciliation of the individual through a profession of faith.
The defense refutes the automatic schism thesis based on the context of trauma. Goldstein compared the situation to leaving an abusive marriage. Continued pastoral failures and antagonism from the diocese have put the family’s faith at risk. The lawyer maintains that the excommunication sounds like retaliation for the success of the civil case. Peyton awaits clear positioning from Vaticano. The deacon reiterated that he never intended to cause a canonical rupture, merely seeking to protect his family and find spiritual peace.






