Metacritic review defines the 15 best RPGs in history with Baldur’s Gate 3 at the top

The role-playing genre in video games has undergone profound transformations in recent decades. The Metacritic portal’s evaluation system works as a historical thermometer of this evolution, aggregating scores from specialized vehicles around the world. The calculation uses a weighted average that gives greater weight to the most relevant publications in the electronic games industry. Quando there is a tie in the final score, the platform uses the total volume of analyzes collected as a tiebreaker to establish the definitive order.
The updated list of the 15 greatest RPGs of all time has a technical tie for first place, with three titles reaching 96. Baldur’s Gate 3, Mass Effect 2 and Elden Ring share the top of the historical ranking. The selection ranges from recent releases that redefined design standards to classics that laid the fundamental foundations of the genre. The catalog reflects the diversity of narrative approaches and mechanics that keep players engaged for hundreds of hours across different platforms and console generations.
Tríade with maximum rating consolidates excellence in different combat styles
First place belongs to Baldur’s Gate 3, a project by Larian Studios that won the Jogo award from Ano in 2023. The work adapts the rules of the Dungeons & Dragons system to digital format, offering strategic turn-based combat from an isometric perspective. Players take control of a group of adventurers infected by mind-eating parasites in Reinos Esquecidos. The title costs R$299.90 for PS5, R$259.95 for Xbox Series X and Series S, and R$199.99 for PC through the Steam and GOG stores.
Mass Effect 2 takes second place, representing the culmination of BioWare’s sci-fi franchise originally released in 2010. Comandante Shepard returns to recruit a team of experts and combat the threat of the Collectors aliens. The gameplay mixes third-person shooters with a branching dialogue system. Mass Effect Legendary Edition brings together the trilogy for R$249.00 on PlayStation consoles, Xbox and computers, with frequent reductions in promotions.

Elden Ring rounds out the elite group with its open world proposal focused on high difficulty. FromSoftware carries over the Soulslike formula to the Terras Intermédias, demanding precision in confrontations against colossal bosses. The game allows extensive customization of attributes and weapons, in addition to introducing a new mounting system for the studio. Comercializado for R$299.90 on consoles and R$274.50 on PC, the title has an adaptation planned for Nintendo Switch 2 in 2026.
Japanese Obras set the pace with long narratives and turn-based systems
The presence of oriental productions in the ranking demonstrates the continued strength of JRPGs in the global market. Persona 5 Royal, from developer Atlus, expands the base game with new school semesters and additional characters. The protagonist Joker leads the Phantom Thieves on raids through Metaverse, alternating dungeon exploration with the routine of a student in the contemporary Japão. The title requires time management and costs R$299.90 on PlayStation consoles, R$295 on Nintendo Switch and Xbox platforms, and R$249.90 on PC.
Square Enix is present with two classics from the first PlayStation. Final Fantasy IX revived the franchise’s medieval aesthetic, following the thief Zidane Tribal in a plot about wars between nations in the world of Gaia. The system of skills linked to equipment offers tactical depth to confrontations. Chrono Cross, released in 1999, focuses on Serge’s journey through parallel dimensions. The The Radical Dreamers Edition Remastered Edition modernizes Yasunori Mitsuda’s graphics and soundtrack for current platforms.
The Atlus catalog gains additional reinforcements with two other major productions that appear on the list of best reviews:
- Persona 4 Golden transports the social simulation formula to the rural town of Inaba, where students investigate murders linked to a midnight television channel.
- Metaphor: ReFantazio introduces a new intellectual property focused on a fantasy realm, combining real-time combat against smaller enemies and turn-based battles against bosses.
Bethesda open-ended Mundos and isometric classics ensure longevity
The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim maintains its commercial and cultural relevance more than a decade after its original release in 2011. Bethesda has built a vast province filled with dungeons, factions, and dragons, allowing the player to ignore the main quest to live a complete virtual life. The title received multiple adaptations and costs R$199.50 on modern consoles, with prices starting at R$39.99 on computers. Seu predecessor, The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion, also joins the list with its setting in the Cyrodiil region.
The legacy of tabletop rules-based isometric RPGs looms large with Baldur’s Gate 2: Shadows of Amn. BioWare’s sequel released in 2000 pits the protagonist against the wizard Jon Irenicus. Version Enhanced Edition has revitalized the interface and graphics for modern operating systems and mobile devices. Seguindo the same school of tactical design, Divinity: Original Sin 2, also from Larian Studios, offers complex elemental interactions in combat and total freedom to solve missions in the Rivellon universe.
Ação frenetic and science fiction shape the rest of the selection
Blizzard Entertainment revolutionized isometric action with the release of Diablo in 1996. Tristram’s descent through the catacombs of the city introduced procedural map generation and the relentless search for gear of varying rarity. The fast-paced, click-focused combat against hordes of demons in the world of Santuário has established an entire subgenre in the industry. The game remains accessible on Battle.net for R$45 or via Xbox Game Pass.
The universe of George Lucas found its best interactive adaptation in Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic. The narrative set four millennia before the cinematic saga gives the player freedom to explore the light or dark side of Força. Moral choices affect the character’s appearance and the fate of the galaxy. The BioWare classic costs R$49 on Xbox consoles, R$32.99 on PC and R$84.72 on Nintendo Switch.
Fallout 3 completes the list, marking the transition of the post-apocalyptic franchise to the three-dimensional environment. Exploring the ruins of Washington A.D. two hundred years after a nuclear holocaust mixes first-person shooter mechanics with the VATS tactical targeting system. Deep skill customization ensures varied approaches to conflict across the wastelands. The title can be purchased for R$49.90 on Microsoft platforms and from R$39 on digital computer stores.






