Katia Itzel García’s refereeing at the 2026 FIFA World Cup sparks controversy due to omission in Japan match

A failure to inspect equipment by Mexican referee Katia Itzel García, acting as fourth referee at the 2026 World Cup, sparked debate after the game between Japan and the Netherlands. Japanese player Keito Nakamura, who scored one of the goals, played the match without the mandatory shin pads, a detail that should have been checked before the start of the match and in the second half. The situation raised questions about the rigor of arbitration procedures in a major event like the World Cup.
The responsibility of the fourth referee in equipment inspection
The role of the fourth referee in football is not limited to assisting the main referee in substitutions or additions. One of their essential duties is checking the players’ equipment, ensuring that everyone complies with the established safety rules. The failure to check Keito Nakamura’s shin pads highlighted the critical importance of this stage, which aims to protect the athletes’ physical integrity. Shin guards, also known as espinilleras, are mandatory protective items to prevent serious injuries to the legs during collisions and disputes inherent to the game.
IFAB rules on the use of shin guards in football
The International Football Association Board (IFAB), responsible for the Laws of the Game, is clear about the mandatory use of shin guards. This standard aims to protect players from direct impacts and serious injuries. Failure to comply with this rule may expose the athlete to unnecessary risks, especially in high-intensity matches such as those at a World Cup.
Check out the essential points of IFAB rule 4.2 on mandatory equipment:
- Shin guards must be manufactured from appropriate material and be adequately sized to provide reasonable protection.
- They must be completely covered by the player’s socks.
- Responsibility for the size and fit of shin guards rests with the players themselves.
- The fourth referee has the duty to inspect all players before the start of the match and substitutes before they enter the field.
Fernando Guerrero’s criticisms and the repercussions of the case
Former referee and commentator Fernando Guerrero, known as “El Cantante”, used his social networks to point out Katia Itzel García’s mistake. Guerrero regretted that the fourth referee did not notice the absence of shin guards on Keito Nakamura, who scored Japan’s first goal in the draw against the Dutch team. The criticism highlighted that checking the equipment is a basic and non-negotiable procedure, the negligence of which on a stage like the World Cup is a cause for concern for the refereeing community and fans.
The impact of omission on the safety of athletes on the field
The absence of shin pads, even if it does not invalidate a goal, represents a significant risk to the player’s health. The IFAB rule is not a formality, but an essential protective measure against fractures, contusions and other injuries to the tibia and fibula. In a contact sport like football, where collisions and tackles are constant, the lack of protection exposes the athlete to serious consequences, which could compromise their career. The episode with Nakamura highlights the importance of each member of the refereeing team in ensuring a safe and fair gaming environment.
Katia Itzel García’s trajectory at the World Cup and previous debates
Katia Itzel García made history by participating in the 2026 World Cup, acting as fourth referee in the clash between the Netherlands and Japan. The Mexican referee expressed pride and responsibility for the choice. However, her career had already been the target of criticism and defense, including from colleagues such as César Arturo Ramos Palazuelos, who defended her against questions about her performance in Liga MX. This most recent incident adds a new chapter to the discussion about the level of demand and pressure faced by referees in international tournaments.






