Who was better on debut: Mbappé, Haaland or Messi? FIFA releases Power Ranking scores for the World Cup

Big names in world football, Kylian Mbappé, Erling Haaland and Lionel Messi had a memorable debut in the World Cup on a recent Tuesday (16), scoring goals and being crucial for their teams. The difficulty in defining the best performance is remedied, in part, by FIFA’s “Power Ranking”, which assigns scores to athletes.
Argentine star Lionel Messi experienced a particularly historic night when he scored three goals, reaching the mark of one of the greatest scorers in World Cups, alongside Klose. However, both Frenchman Mbappé and Norwegian Haaland also shone brightly, finding the net twice each.
The “Power Ranking” of football’s highest governing body is an initiative conceived under the leadership of Arsène Wenger, well-known former Arsenal coach and current FIFA Global Head of Development.
This evaluation system operates based on an extensive database, culminating in the generation of three distinct classifications: one for attacking performance, another for creativity and the third for defensive actions.
Among the three talents that stood out on Tuesday, the ranking analysis revealed that each one stood out in a specific aspect. Mbappé achieved the best performance in terms of attack, considered the most relevant by the system. Messi, in turn, demonstrated superiority in creativity, another important element. Haaland had his highlight in defense, where he obtained the highest score.
The individual evaluations of athletes in the FIFA Power Ranking
- Kylian Mbappé: In attack, he achieved 9.14 points; in creativity, 6.85; and in defense, 4.16.

- Lionel Messi: His offensive performance scored 8.62; creativity, 7.84; and defensive performance, 4.90.

- Erling Haaland: Recorded 7.60 in attack; 4.96 in creativity; and 5.37 in defense.

Comparative analysis reveals overall performance of stars
Although FIFA does not provide an aggregate score for each athlete in its system, a calculation of the average of the three categories evaluated places Lionel Messi ahead with 7.12 points. Kylian Mbappé appears next, with an average of 6.71, and Erling Haaland completes the trio with 5.97 points in his overall performance.






