Series ‘Elle’, prequel to ‘Legally Blonde’, disappoints with forced narrative and tedious performance on Prime Video

The film “Legally Blonde”, released in 2001, achieved resounding box office success and became a true cultural phenomenon. The production grossed about six times its $18 million cost and inspired a sequel, “Legally Blonde 2: Red, White and Blonde,” as well as a popular Broadway musical and countless Halloween costumes for the main character, Elle Woods.
This feature film was also instrumental in boosting the career of actress Reese Witherspoon. Although she already had important roles in productions such as “Cruel Intentions” and “Election”, it was “Legally Blonde” that established her as a Hollywood star, and she has always shown a special affection for the work and for Elle Woods.
Consequently, there was great anticipation when, in 2024, it was revealed that Witherspoon and her company, Hello Sunshine, were developing a prequel series for Prime Video. Titled “Elle”, the plot unfolds in the mid-90s, showing Woods during his penultimate year of high school.
The premise of the series finds the vibrant and optimistic Elle, played by Lexi Minetree, experiencing an intense culture shock. After his father, a plastic surgeon (Tom Everett Scott), makes a mistake performing a rhinoplasty on a Hollywood celebrity, the Woods family decides to secretly move to Seattle. There, at Rainier West High, she faces contempt from her classmates for her enthusiasm and Californian style, something that clashes with the grunge atmosphere of the time, despite the popularity of series such as “Barred at the Prom” and “Melrose Place”.
However, despite seeming like a captivating idea on paper, Elle Woods’ setting in 90s Seattle proves artificial and shallow in practice. The original film “Legally Blonde” built a fun and exaggerated universe, while the series “Elle” portrays Seattle as a dark environment, inhabited by melancholy teenagers, who ignore Kurt Cobain’s death, which occurred more than a year before the events of the plot. The challenge of prequels often lies in replicating the essence of the original work, and ‘Elle’ illustrates this difficulty by attempting to recreate the magic with a radically different tonal approach.
Eventually, Elle manages to fit in, first forming a connection with the school secretary, Donna (Amy Pietz), and then becoming close to the quirky but friendly Dustin (Zac Looker) and Liz (Gabrielle Policano). She falls in love with a cross country athlete, Jacob Moskovitz, discovering that he is already dating Shannon (Danielle Chand), an older student with whom she surprisingly forms a bond. Additionally, Elle keeps in touch with a friend from her hometown, played by Jessica Belkin, who visits her and serves to highlight the supposed changes in her.
If this narrative reminds us of clichéd “fish out of water” stories, the impression is correct. A large part of the plot of “Elle” is retconned, featuring elements that are literal copies or, at the very least, explicit references to the original “Legally Blonde” plot. The teenage protagonist is tricked into dressing inappropriately for a party, replicating the prom scene from the film. She also solves a crime using a fashion detail, produces a video for an internship application and wins over an arrogant colleague with kindness and persistence, following in the footsteps of the story that gave rise to it.
The plot of “Elle” is not just limited to typical high school conflicts. There is also a light legal thriller, which involves a school principal, Matt Oberg, under suspicion of embezzlement, as well as marital problems between Elle’s parents, played by Tom Everett Scott and June Diane Raphael. Added to this are issues involving school superintendent and mayoral candidate Dean Wilson, the last role of the late James Van Der Beek.
Despite having a talented supporting cast, most episodes of “Elle” drag on, becoming unnecessarily exhausting. Lasting between 45 and 60 minutes, the stories could be quicker and more fun if they were around 30 minutes long. Situations predictable from the beginning go on unnecessarily long, and even the lighter moments, such as the interactions between Elle and her mother, are undermined by an almost comical excess of merchandising. In the first ten minutes, the series forces references to products such as L’Oréal, Nexus, Dove and Ferrero Rocher, generating an oppressive and embarrassing experience. It is notable that other Prime Video productions, such as “Off Campus”, demonstrate more skill in this aspect. With the second season already guaranteed, it is clear that Prime Video is betting on the series’ potential, especially its profitability.
While “Legally Blonde” won over the audience with its humor, originality and engaging rhythm, “Elle” presents itself as a dark, tedious and tiring production. It’s unfortunate that even with Witherspoon, Hello Sunshine, and showrunners Laura Kittrell and Caroline Dries’ visible affection for the source material, their attempt to recreate the same magic has actually dimmed the prequel’s brilliance.
The series “Elle” is available to the public starting this Wednesday on Prime Video.







