US Supreme Court decision maintains citizenship by birth, contradicting Donald Trump

A recent deliberation by the United States Supreme Court confirmed, this Tuesday (30), the validity of citizenship by birth on American soil. The decision rejected an executive order by Donald Trump that intended to restrict this right for children of undocumented immigrants or visitors.
By a 6-3 majority, the high court justices reaffirmed a historic and widely accepted interpretation of the 14th Constitutional Amendment. They determined that, with very rare exceptions, all individuals born in American national territory are considered citizens. Historically, this amendment, ratified after the Civil War, was crucial in guaranteeing civil rights and citizenship to freed slaves and their descendants. The limitations proposed by then-President Trump had already been invalidated in previous court instances and were never implemented.
A few hours before the official announcement of the verdict, the Republican politician used his digital platforms to release news suggesting that his initiatives to restrict citizenship by birth could be successful even without the approval of the Supreme Court. Until the closing of this report, on Tuesday afternoon (30), Donald Trump had not publicly commented on the outcome of the trial.

Understand the birthright citizenship guaranteed by the 14th Amendment
The concept of birthright citizenship is consolidated in the 14th Amendment to the United States Constitution, which states that “all persons born in the United States are citizens of the United States”. When he began his second term, Donald Trump signed a decree aimed at reducing this right, however, without clearly detailing the criteria for granting citizenship. This initiative by the former president was part of his campaign promises, strongly focused on combating immigration.
The legal issue reached the Supreme Court from a dispute originating in New Hampshire, known as “Trump versus Barbara.” This name alludes to the lawsuit filed by a Honduran immigrant, resident in the state, named Barbara, who challenged the Trump administration alleging the unconstitutionality of a measure that aimed to restrict American citizenship.
Barbara and her spouse live in the United States as undocumented immigrants, and are already parents to three children, all born in Honduras. The decision to take legal action against the government came when Barbara discovered she was expecting her fourth child, who would be born on American soil and, according to the proposed restrictions, would not have the right to citizenship.






