US Supreme Court upholds birthright citizenship and rejects Trump plan

The United States Supreme Court blocked former President Donald Trump’s attempt to impose limitations on the automatic citizenship granted to children born on American soil. The most recent court decision preserves a precedent of more than 150 years guaranteed by the Constitution and represents a milestone on the limits of presidential power.
Challenges to automatic citizenship by birth in the country
The concept of citizenship by birth establishes that any child born in a given territory automatically acquires nationality, regardless of the immigration status of their parents. This principle, known as *jus soli* (right of the soil), differs from *jus sanguinis* (right of blood), where citizenship is transmitted by the child’s parents.
The historical importance of the 14th constitutional Amendment
Established in the American Constitution in 1868, the 14th Amendment was initially created to guarantee citizenship to formerly enslaved individuals born in the USA, in the post-Civil War period. The legislation explicitly states: “All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States”, a text later ratified by federal citizenship legislation in 1940.
Trump’s proposed decree to restrict the right
On his first day in his second term, then-President Trump issued an executive order seeking to instruct federal agencies to limit birthright citizenship, specifically for children of undocumented parents or those with short-term permits. The order faced immediate legal challenges and was suspended by lower courts, prompting the Trump administration to request the Supreme Court’s intervention to validate the measure’s constitutionality.
The central controversy centered on the interpretation of the phrase “subject to their jurisdiction” in the 14th Amendment. Trump’s argument indicated that this clause would exclude children of individuals without permanent or legal residency. However, the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) argued that the expression refers to the physical permanence of those born in American territory, regardless of their parents’ immigration status.
Donald Trump labeled birthright citizenship as a “fraud”, claiming that it favored high-income foreigners and undocumented immigrants, burdening American taxpayers by offering financial support to the children of people with undocumented status. In contrast, the ACLU argued that nullifying this practice would result in the creation of a “permanent underclass” of citizens born in the United States.

Consequences of a possible change in citizenship policy
Currently, almost all newborns born on American soil automatically become United States citizens. For the approximately 3.6 million babies born annually in the country, the birth certificate is a fundamental document for accessing Social Security numbers, applying for passports and receiving benefits in early childhood, as well as serving as proof of citizenship for voter registration and employment in adulthood.
If Trump’s proposal were validated, estimates from the Migration Policy Institute indicate that around 255,000 children born annually to foreign parents would lose their right to legal status. This could lead to difficulties in proving citizenship in other countries, rendering some children stateless in practice. Lack of clear legal status could also expose newborns to immediate risk of deportation.
Immigrant rights activists warned of the possibility of a widespread “bureaucratic nightmare” for all parents of newborns. They highlighted that children from families with lower purchasing power would be especially vulnerable to losing access to health services and food assistance programs. With the change, the birth certificate would no longer be sufficient proof of citizenship for any child, including those of American citizens.
Donald Trump had declared that the decree would not apply retroactively, affecting only babies born after its implementation. However, several experts have expressed concern that any legal basis validating a new interpretation of the 14th Amendment could, in the long term, be used by future administrations to revoke the citizenship of specific individuals.
The tradition of birthright citizenship in the USA and its history
Birthright citizenship is deeply rooted in American tradition, having been reaffirmed by courts and legislators for more than a century. In previous years, the Supreme Court itself had already refuted arguments similar to Trump’s. An example is the emblematic decision of 1898, in the case of Wong Kim Ark v. United States, which addressed the legal status of children born to foreign parents, where Judge Horace Gray stated:
“The [14th] Amendment, in clear words and with manifest intent, includes children born, within the territory of the United States, of all other persons, regardless of race or color, domiciled in the United States.”
In April, during oral arguments in the case, Supreme Court justices expressed skepticism about Trump’s intention to eliminate birthright citizenship. At that moment, Justice Elena Kagan highlighted that the administration was trying to dismantle a legal tradition with roots in English common law, and that the 14th Amendment had incorporated “that tradition” without seeking “to impose any restrictions on it.”
According to data from the Pew Research Center, at least 32 other nations have citizenship legislation similar to that of the United States, covering countries such as Brazil, Canada, Argentina and Mexico. On the other hand, European nations have traditionally employed more stringent criteria for granting citizenship. France, Greece and Spain, for example, grant birthright citizenship only to children of parents who were also born in those countries. Australia, Germany and the United Kingdom, in turn, extend citizenship to any child born to a legal resident.
Other recent Supreme Court rulings favorable to Trump
The previous week, the Supreme Court had granted two important victories to Donald Trump’s administration. First, the court authorized the government to discontinue humanitarian protections that allowed hundreds of thousands of Haitians and Syrians to reside and work legally in the United States. The Court then ruled that the government could prevent migrants seeking asylum from physically entering the border with Mexico while they wait for protection from persecution.
The administration had asked the Court for permission to reinstate a policy initially implemented in 2016, part of Trump’s immigration strategy. This border blockade policy prevented asylum seekers from entering American soil, where laws guaranteed them the right to request asylum and receive protection.
Current legislation determines that any alien “physically present in the United States” has the right to request asylum. However, in a 6 to 3 vote, the Court ruled that foreigners must fully cross the border to access this right, declaring that migrants who remain in Mexican territory do not “arrive” in the United States by merely “trying, unsuccessfully, to set foot in this country.”
In a second decision, also approved by 6 votes to 3, the Superior Court supported an initiative by the Trump administration to revoke the guarantees against deportation of approximately 350,000 Haitians and 6,000 Syrians, as well as beneficiaries from approximately twelve other countries. The former Republican president has systematically sought to end Temporary Protected Status (TPS) as a pillar of his more restrictive immigration policy.






