Dbrand cancels and refunds Companion Cube case for Steam Machine after legal notice from Valve

A decision by Valve led the company dbrand to immediately cancel all sales of its Companion Cube case for Steam Machine and refund consumers. Valve’s legal notice confirmed that the accessory’s design used the game developer’s intellectual property without proper permission. The product, inspired by the Portal universe, had become a pre-sales success in a short time.
Development without permission led to mass cancellations
dbrand publicly admitted, through a post on Reddit, to having invested more than seven months in developing the Companion Cube case. This intense work involved over a thousand hours of engineering and the creation of 44 injection molding tool sets, all without seeking prior approval from Valve. The project emerged as a joke after the announcement of the Steam Machine, but the public’s great interest turned the idea into a real product.
Released for pre-order on June 22, the $99 case quickly became the second best-selling product in dbrand’s 15-year history. The company, however, knew the risk. In its official communication, dbrand expressed regret for having turned the idea into reality without consulting Valve, a decision that, according to them, will be regretted for a long time.
The impact of Valve’s legal notice and dbrand’s stance
Valve’s legal team contacted dbrand shortly after pre-sales began. Valve’s lawyers made it clear that Companion Cube is the company’s exclusive intellectual property and that dbrand did not have a license to use it. In light of the infraction, the immediate recall of the product and all promotional material was required.
dbrand classified Valve’s action as “direct, fair and respectful”. The manufacturer tried to negotiate a retroactive license, but Valve refused the proposal. Despite pointing out that it was losing money on each unit sold of the US$99 case, dbrand considered it a passion project, which highlights the importance the company placed on design, despite the commercial risks.
How Refunds Affect Steam Machine Consumers
All orders placed during the short sales period will be fully refunded. Customers do not need to take any action to receive their funds back. The original product page on dbrand now redirects to the explanatory post on Reddit, where the company details the situation and refund process.
dbrand did not announce plans for a replacement product or an alternative design for Steam Machine owners who were interested in the case. Additionally, the 44 injection molding tool sets developed specifically for the cube design cannot be reused for other unlicensed Portal-themed products, representing a significant material loss to the company.
The incident served as an example of a company openly acknowledging a serious error. dbrand stated that “being proud of what we did didn’t give us the right to do it” and that “Valve did nothing wrong. We should have asked first.” In an interaction on Reddit, when a user called dbrand “fucking stupid,” the company’s official account responded simply, “Yes.”
Intellectual property and the creation of third-party accessories
This case highlights the challenges inherent in developing unofficial products that use licensed intellectual property, even when there are good intentions on the part of the manufacturers. Companies, big and small, often underestimate the strictness of copyright and trademark laws, especially in the gaming world, where fan passion can inspire the creation of products that legally belong to another party.
For other companies considering creating accessories for the Steam Machine or any other platform with established IP, the lesson is clear: licensing approval must be obtained before development begins, not after. Skipping this crucial step can result in high development costs, product cancellations, and reputational damage.
Recommendations for future accessory manufacturers
To avoid problems similar to what occurred with dbrand and Valve, developers of accessories for gaming platforms should consider the following points:
- Prioritize licensing:Always obtain license approval before investing significant time and resources into product development.
- Use official resources:Valve, for example, makes CAD files available for the Steam Machine’s outer casing, allowing manufacturers to create custom faceplates without infringing on intellectual property.
- Understand the limits:Clearly distinguish between what is a fan-inspired creation and what constitutes direct IP infringement that incorporates protected characters, settings, or assets.
- Attention to risks:Be aware of the financial and image risks that come with producing and selling products without the necessary licenses.
- Proactive communication:Maintain an open dialogue with intellectual property holders to explore partnerships and licensing agreements.
Currently, for users who were hoping to purchase the Companion Cube case, there are no plans for a licensed version. Customization of the Steam Machine continues to be possible through third-party designs that utilize CAD files provided by Valve, with custom faceplates being the most affordable and legally safe option.






