Ohio Supreme Court denies appeal, and Mackenzie Shirilla’s defense calls for reconsideration of conviction

Lawyers representing Mackenzie Shirilla, convicted of double murder, presented a formal request to Ohio’s highest court on Tuesday (2), asking the court to reevaluate the decision not to hear her appeals. The movement seeks to reopen the discussion about the process.
The Ohio Supreme Court had on June 23 denied a request to review Shirilla’s post-conviction appeals. At the time, the court argued that the petition was filed after the deadline and that the trial court did not have jurisdiction to excuse the delay.
Now, Shirilla’s legal team is urging the judges to reconsider, arguing that their client faced a series of confusing and inconsistent deadlines, which would have made it difficult to meet procedural dates.
Shirilla was convicted in 2023 of murdering her boyfriend, Dominic Russo, and their friend, Davion Flanagan, in a case that shocked the community.
A Cuyahoga County Common Pleas Court judge on August 14, 2023, found Mackenzie Shirilla guilty of causing the deaths of Dominic Russo and Davion Flanagan in a 2022 car accident in the city of Strongsville.
The sentence imposed was life imprisonment, with eligibility for parole after serving 15 years. Prosecutors maintained that the evidence indicated an intentional accident, based on surveillance video, data from the vehicle’s black box and records that the car was traveling at nearly 100 miles per hour without braking.
Shirilla’s lawyers, in court documents, stated that the request for review was due to a scheduling error, which led to the initial delay in the presentation.
Court records indicate that the defense missed the deadline to file the post-conviction appeal by just one day, a failure that the legal team attributed to the omission that 2024 would be a leap year. The complexity of the deadlines and the failure to consider the extra day in February were central to the defense in justifying the delay.
However, last month, the Ohio Supreme Court reaffirmed that the trial court had correctly determined that it lacked jurisdiction to consider the petition.

Understand Ohio Appellate Law
Under Ohio law, convicted defendants generally have a period of 365 days from the recording of their trial transcripts to contest their conviction. Prosecutors allege that Shirilla’s deadline began on October 23, 2023, and that her lawyers filed the appeal a day late, on October 24, 2024.
Shirilla’s new attorneys, in turn, filed another appeal with the Ohio Supreme Court on April 27, 2026. They argue that the deadline should have started at a later date because a separate transcript was filed weeks after the main trial record. Furthermore, the defense maintains that Shirilla would have been acquitted if she had received effective legal assistance.
In its June ruling, the Ohio Supreme Court focused on the issue of jurisdiction and said Shirilla’s lawyers’ arguments did not fall within the exceptions allowed by law.
The court’s ministers indicated that, for this reason, the court of first instance did not have the authority to resolve the procedural delay. Despite the unanimity, Minister R. Patrick DeWine presented a dissenting vote on the issue.
Mackenzie Shirilla’s first parole hearing is scheduled for 2037.






