Request to make information of juror and former court employee in Alex Murdaugh case public

The South Carolina Attorney General’s Office has formally asked a judge to release documents from an investigation. The request involves the exclusion of a member of the jury in the trial of Alex Murdaugh, convicted of double murder in 2023, and materials about alleged jury manipulation by a former court employee.
In March 2023, then-Judge Clifton Newman had removed Juror 785 from the case. The decision occurred days before the final arguments and the deliberations phase, motivated by alleged inappropriate conduct by the juror.
Subsequent investigations by judges, law enforcement, prosecutors and defenders indicated misconduct by former Colleton County Court Clerk Becky Hill. She allegedly maintained improper communication with jurors, raising suspicions that she altered the way they interpreted Alex Murdaugh’s testimony. This type of interference compromises the integrity of the judicial process, especially in high-profile cases, and is one of the central reasons for the request for public access to details.
In May, the South Carolina Supreme Court vacated Murdaugh’s sentences for the murders of his wife and son. The court justified that Hill’s biased statements justified the need for a new trial, appointing Judge Debra R. McCaslin to preside over future stages of the process and the case’s intricate legal debates.
On July 6, the state attorney’s office formally requested McCaslin to release investigation reports on Juror 785 and Becky Hill. Prosecutors are aligned with Murdaugh’s defense of publicizing the files, as long as jurors’ personal data and other sensitive information is properly anonymized.
Investigation and dismissal of juror 785, the “egg juror”
Before Murdaugh’s initial trial began in January 2023, Newman had issued an order to protect the jurors’ identities. This measure prohibited the disclosure of any data that could identify them, allowing the press to mention them only by their designated numbers. Throughout the process, the magistrate made repeated warnings about the prohibition of discussing the case with third parties.
However, on February 28, 2023, on the eve of closing arguments, Judge Newman was notified that Juror 785 disregarded the court order when discussing the details of the case.
In response to accusations of misconduct, Newman conducted two confidential hearings, where the judge himself and lawyers questioned witnesses. Later, on March 2, the topic was discussed in a public session, with Newman stating that Juror 785 talked about the process with at least three individuals, expressing opinions on the evidence exposed so far.
The testimonies collected in these private sessions were kept confidential by the judge. Juror 785 was removed for violating the rules, and was replaced by an alternate. Upon leaving the courtroom, she questioned Newman about the possibility of recovering her personal items, including a carton of fresh eggs, a fact that earned her the nickname “egg judge” or “egg lady”.
Juror removal was the subject of debate the following year, in January 2024, when Jean Toal, then Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, presided over a hearing on Murdaugh’s request for a new trial. At the time, Murdaugh’s defense accused Becky Hill, author of a book about her experience in the trial, of manipulating the jury, allegedly instructing them “not to be fooled” by the defendant’s testimony.
Over the course of the two-day hearing in Columbia, cross-examination brought to light that Hill had reached out to Newman to discuss a Facebook post. She mistakenly assumed that the post belonged to Juror 785’s ex-spouse, who described an ex-wife serving as a juror and considered her unfit for the role, as reported by Hill. She further stated that Juror 785 was overly communicative, but denied having initiated any of these dialogues.
In contrast, Juror 785 informed Newman in March 2023 that it was Becky Hill who questioned her about the Facebook post and whether she had communicated with her ex-husband. Later, in a deposition, Juror 785 recorded that Hill proposed reactivating the restraining orders against her ex-spouse and suggested that “the Murdaughs probably influenced him” when he contacted her on the morning of the verdict. Juror 785 also stated that Hill inquired about her and the other jurors’ votes.
Joe McCulloch, a Columbia lawyer defending Juror 785, filed a request with the state Supreme Court months later seeking publicity of documents from closed hearings during Murdaugh’s initial trial. The request was rejected by the magistrates.
In December 2025, Becky Hill pleaded guilty to abuse of power and perjury. A magistrate, considering the one day she had already served in prison, sentenced her to three years probation and community service.
The State Law Enforcement Division also investigated allegations of jury tampering against Hill. However, prosecutors, in a final decision, chose not to pursue criminal charges, citing a lack of sufficient evidence.
There is still no forecast for McCaslin’s decision on the release of files related to Juror 785 and Becky Hill. The Lexington County judge made her first public appearance in this high-profile case on June 29, when she scheduled Alex Murdaugh’s retrial for April 5, 2027.
Alex Murdaugh, currently 58 years old, remains in prison, serving cumulative sentences: 27 years in a state prison and 40 years in a federal unit. The sentences were imposed on the former lawyer after he admitted guilt on several counts of financial crimes.







