New RPG Echoes of Aincrad debuts with divided reception and average scores from international critics

The game “Echoes of Aincrad”, the long-awaited launch that took place on Thursday, July 9, 2026, generated a series of varied international reviews, with the PC (Steam) version scheduled for July 10. The first evaluations point to a lukewarm reception from specialized vehicles.
The Metacritic platform, which aggregates scores from different publications, recorded an average of 60 for the PC version, based on nine reviews. The PS5 edition obtained a slightly higher average of 64, from 34 reviews. Both ratings place the title in the “mixed or average” range on the platform’s rating system, indicating that the game did not reach a positive critical consensus, despite its origins in a popular franchise.
The title is an RPG based on a well-known novel and anime, where players find themselves trapped in a virtual MMORPG world. The central plot revolves around the fight for survival, with the premise that death in the game implies death in real life. The purpose of the game is to delve deeper into the anxieties and challenges of being in a digital reality where the threat of losing your life is constant.
“Echoes of Aincrad” is compatible with PC (via Steam), PS5 and Xbox Series X|S. The global launch is set for July 9, 2026, with the Steam version arriving a day later on July 10. The game also supports the Japanese language.
For TrueGaming, which awarded 75/100 to the PS5 version, the game, despite its weaknesses, is an excellent option for those looking for a dungeon exploration experience. However, the publication emphasizes that anyone looking for a broader open-world RPG, with greater diversity of exploration, may be disappointed with this title from the “Sword Art Online” franchise.
GAMES.CH, with a rating of 73/100 for the PS5, described “Echoes of Aincrad” as a high-quality action RPG at its core. However, the review criticized the game’s repetitive design and missed opportunity to explore the anime’s rich history in a new way, preventing it from reaching its full potential.
GameBlast rated the PS5 version 70/100, highlighting that fans of the original series will be attracted by the engaging plot, epic battles and extensive character customization options. On the other hand, the portal pointed out flaws in character development, limited exploration, uninteresting activities and repetitive enemies, which make combat tiring and less attractive for new players.
MonsterVine gave the game a 60/100 on PS5, noting that “Echoes of Aincrad” had the potential to be a milestone in the “Sword Art Online” franchise. However, the publication lamented the presence of dated mechanics and monotonous missions. MonsterVine concluded that the story and visuals may be enough for fans, but other players will likely find little value in the title.
IGN and IGN Spain, both with 60/100 for the PS5, agreed that “Echoes of Aincrad” is not a bad game in the series, even presenting memorable moments that surpass other titles in the franchise. However, reviews state that the initially promised ambition and dreams fall far short of the actual gameplay experience. Problems with pacing, quality of life and content reuse overshadow its strengths.
The RPG Fan, who gave the PS5 52/100, gave a scathing review, mentioning that the greatest possible compliment to the game is to no longer feel nostalgic for the PS3 generation. The publication stated that any positive feelings before playing had completely disappeared, suggesting that the title failed to capture the advancement one would expect from a contemporary game.
Finally, Combo Infinito rated the PC version with just 50/100, declaring the failure of “Echoes of Aincrad” as serious. Criticism points to an empty world, superficial combat and an unappealing customizable protagonist. The portal considered the disastrous technical performance and lack of optimization as the biggest problem, culminating in the worst adaptation in the series’ history.
In summary, the Metacritic reviews for “Echoes of Aincrad”, released on July 9, 2026 (July 10 for the Steam version) on the PC, PS5 and Xbox Series X|S platforms, show a clear dichotomy. The narrative was widely praised, but the game received significant criticism regarding the repetitiveness of the gameplay and the lack of exploration elements.







