US court overturns Jimmie Chris Duncan’s conviction after 27 years on death row due to rigged evidence

In June 2026, the Louisiana Supreme Court overturned the conviction of a man who spent 27 years on death row in the United States. Jimmie “Chris” Duncan, 57, was released after a video called into question the key evidence in his trial. The court unanimously ruled that the bite mark evidence used in the case was fraudulent.
In another case, a recent police chase in the US resulted in the deaths of four teenagers when a pickup truck collided with a train.
Still in the United States, a landowner discovered more than 200 cannonballs from the American Civil War buried on his land.
Key recording altered course of investigation
Duncan’s 1998 conviction stemmed from the death of Haley Oliveaux, the daughter of the defendant’s girlfriend, who drowned in a bathtub in 1993 while in his care. Initially, doctors and investigators did not identify bite marks on the child’s body. However, a subsequent examination conducted by pathologist Steven Hayne and forensic dentist Michael West changed the focus of the investigation. Years later, footage surfaced revealing West applying and scraping a dental mold of Duncan into the girl’s skin, manipulating the evidence that supported the accusation of rape and murder.
This crucial recording was never shown to jurors, even though the defense requested access before the trial. West and Hayne’s conclusions led to Duncan’s death penalty, with deliberation that lasted less than three hours. Decades later, the bite mark analysis methodology was largely discredited by science, and West himself admitted in 2012 that the technique should not be used in courts, suggesting DNA tests as an alternative.
The Innocence Project integrated the video into its defense strategy in 2022, arguing that the footage showed evidence tampering. After a hearing in 2024, Judge Alvin Sharp described the images as “appalling” and overturned the conviction. The Louisiana Supreme Court endorsed the decision, concluding that no reasonable jury would convict Duncan in light of the new evidence. The president of the court, John L. Weimer, compared the use of bite mark analysis to ancient medieval “water trials”, reinforcing that sentences based on invalid evidence undermine confidence in the judicial system.
Even with the annulment, prosecutors declared their intention to subject Duncan to a new trial. Jerry Jones, a former prosecutor in the initial case, maintained his belief in the defendant’s guilt, but admitted that the bite mark evidence “was bad” and should not have been used.






