Portuguese court upholds compensation for nurse convicted of murder and dismemberment

A nurse sentenced to 23 years in prison for the murder and dismemberment of a young man in 2020 will receive compensation of 30 thousand euros, equivalent to approximately R$175 thousand. The court decision was handed down in favor of Mariana Fonseca in Portugal, who had been illegally dismissed by the Algarve Local Health Unit (ULS) after the crime.
Mariana Fonseca, who was 29 years old at the time of the events, was convicted of the robbery and murder of Diogo Gonçalves, which occurred in the Algarve region in 2020. Her accomplice in the crime, Maria Malveiro, the nurse’s girlfriend, was found dead in a cell in December 2021. Although the criminal conviction is unquestionable, the decision for compensation highlights an important legal distinction: dismissal, even in cases of serious crimes, must follow due labor process, and failures in this procedure may give rise to the right to compensation, regardless of criminal guilt.
ULS do Algarve sought to reverse the decision, appealing to the Évora Court of Appeal. However, the judges chose to maintain the sentence established in the first instance, confirming the nurse’s right to compensation.
Nurse was detained in Indonesia after being on the run
Nurse Mariana Fonseca was captured in March in the city of Jakarta, Indonesia. She remained a fugitive from Portuguese justice for around a year before her arrest and extradition.
Chronology of the murder and legal proceedings
The brutal crime that shocked Portugal occurred in March 2020, when Diogo Gonçalves was drugged, asphyxiated to death and had his body dismembered. Parts of the victim’s corpse were discarded in garbage bags, found on a hillside and in a wooded area. Investigations revealed that not all of Diogo’s remains were recovered by the police.
Mariana Fonseca’s judicial path had twists and turns: initially, she was acquitted in the first instance. However, at a higher court, the Court of Appeal, she was sentenced to 25 years in prison. After appealing the sentence, the sentence was reduced to 23 years, confirming his guilt in the crime.







