Video game fans on Reddit highlight underperforming titles that follow favorites

A discussion in the Reddit community brought to light which games are considered “flops” that, despite modest sales or average reviews, have won the hearts of a loyal base of players. The conversation, which took place on August 4, 2026, demonstrated that commercial success does not always define the relevance of a title for those who are really dedicated to it.
Several examples, ranging from major releases to niche productions that ended up forgotten by the market, were cited and discussed by users. The list revealed that below-expected performance does not prevent a game from developing an engaged community.
Immortals Fenyx Rising was fondly remembered by the community
Ubisoft’s open-world adventure game Immortals Fenyx Rising received the most likes on the Reddit post. Many users regretted the cancellation of the game’s sequel. Others agreed that the game still offers a very fun experience, even for those who had previously played The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild, a title to which Immortals Fenyx Rising has often been compared since its release.
The Ubisoft title stood out for its charisma within the company’s catalog. However, its debut occurred in a period full of major releases, being released just a few weeks after Assassin’s Creed Valhalla, which may have affected its visibility.
Guardians of the Galaxy received mixed reception after Marvel’s Avengers
Another game that generated consensus in the discussion was Marvel’s Guardians of the Galaxy. The launch surprised many, delivering an engaging story and a cast of characters with remarkable chemistry. However, several comments indicated that the main obstacle to its success was that it arrived on the market shortly after the failure of Marvel’s Avengers.
Many gamers assumed that Marvel’s Guardians of the Galaxy would follow the same game-as-a-service formula and so didn’t give the space adventure title a chance. Those who decided to try the game, however, particularly praised the campaign, the characters and the captivating narrative.
Avowed divides opinions among players, but has its defenders
Despite the criticism it has received since its release, the Avowed RPG has appeared frequently in discussion. Game enthusiasts positively highlighted the combat system, exploration and the fact that it offers a relatively short campaign by the standards of modern RPGs, lasting between 12 and 15 hours and multiple possible endings. Some users of the platform expressed that they missed this more concise format, arguing that not every RPG needs to exceed the 100 hour mark of play.
Prey continues to be seen as a gem that the market forgot
Prey, the immersive sim developed by Arkane Studios, was also mentioned among the favorites. Although some users pointed out optimization problems, bugs and a marketing strategy considered weak for a game of that size, many agreed that the title presents some of the most innovative and creative mechanics ever seen in the genre.
God Hand is a game with dedicated fans
Among the titles released by Capcom, God Hand may be one of the most forgotten, but it maintains one of the most loyal communities in the gaming universe. The game offered a unique combo mechanic, combined with a very peculiar humor, which won over many players.
Even praising the game’s gameplay, Reddit users believe that the title’s high difficulty, along with its eccentric humor (which would even prevent it from being produced today), may have limited its reach in the mainstream market.
Mafia 3 was a game with good potential
2K’s classic open-world franchise Mafia tried to innovate with its third title, but the result was met with a mixed reception. The gameplay ended up becoming repetitive and the lack of variety in missions and activities negatively impacted the overall experience.
Still, for Reddit users, the game is made up for by its powerful narrative. In the discussion, Mafia 3 was praised for presenting an engaging story, especially for telling it in a documentary format, which gave the game a very particular charm.
- Outriders
- Vampyr
- Mass Effect: Andromeda
- The Callisto Protocol
- Forspoken
- DmC: Devil May Cry
- Heroes of the Storm
- Need for Speed Heat
- Titanfall
- Saints Row (2022)
- The Outer Worlds
- The Legend of Dragoon
- Days Gone
Commercial performance does not define quality for many players
The discussion demonstrates that commercial performance, press reviews or controversies at launch are not always the determining factors in the quality of a game for those who actually try it. In many scenarios, titles that initially went unnoticed found a second life thanks to promotions, inclusion in subscription services like Game Pass, or simply because players decided to give it a chance years after release, revealing an appreciation that the market was unable to immediately capture.







