New Mexico court orders Meta to pay R$4.8 billion for damages to minors

A recent court decision, handed down on the 6th, forced Meta to pay US$567 million (equivalent to R$2.8 billion in direct conversion) after the New Mexico Court concluded that its platforms harmed the well-being of children. The company was also ordered to review how its platforms work for younger users. Meta, however, expressed disagreement with the decision and announced that it intends to appeal.
The determination came from judge Bryan Biedscheid, who drew a parallel between Meta and an industry whose main product is advertising and content. The judge described the company as a “public nuisance” comparable to air pollution, arguing that the company should allocate resources to a fund focused on mitigating damage.
“The court considers Meta’s platforms to be analogous to a factory,” the judge wrote in his analysis. He added that “advertising and other content displayed on these platforms, such as what is produced by the factory; and the psychological harm and exploitation of children, such as pollution, which needs to be addressed.”
The judicial understanding is that teenagers in New Mexico are facing a mental health crisis, and Meta would have acted as a catalyst for this process. The amount of US$567 million will be directed to mental health programs aimed at young people.
Conviction adds values and company will have to review platforms
This verdict marks the end of a trial divided into two stages. The previous phase, concluded in March, resulted in Meta’s conviction by a New Mexico jury, which ordered the payment of US$375 million (about R$1.9 billion) for violating consumer protection law with Facebook and Meta. The sum of the two convictions reaches a total of US$942 million, which corresponds to approximately R$4.8 billion.
In addition to the financial fines, the Court established that Meta must implement several changes to its platforms over a period of five years. Among the requirements are:
- Delete accounts and all information collected from users under the age of 13.
- Disable push notifications between 8am and 3pm on school days and between 10pm and 7am at other times for younger audiences.
- Ensure New Mexico teen accounts are private by default.
- Adopt age verification methods that do not collect personal data from children.
- Establish a human review system for reports of child sexual abuse content before forwarding them to the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children (NCMEC).
- Submit semi-annual reports to the court on the progress of implementations.
- Prevent teen accounts from being suggested to adult users.
- Prohibit the display of nudity for users under 18.
Meta’s position on the court decision
Through a spokesperson, Meta reiterated its disagreement with the court’s decision and confirmed that it will file an appeal.
“We strive to keep people safe on our platforms and have been transparent about the challenges of identifying and removing bad actors and harmful content,” the company stated. Meta added: “We remain confident in our track record of protecting teens online and will continue to defend ourselves against allegations that distort the facts.”






