Miyamoto reveals what he considers Ocarina of Time’s biggest flaw

The protagonist of The Legend of Zelda series, Link, often enlists the help of a creature or resource that acts as a guide, offering advice or commentary throughout the journey. However, not all of these assistants win the players’ affection. Shigeru Miyamoto, one of the franchise’s creators, admitted that Navi’s inclusion in Ocarina of Time represents the “biggest weakness” of the acclaimed title.
In an interview rescued from the Ocarina of Time Encyclopedia, given in 1999, Miyamoto was direct in stating that the fairy Navi, who guides Link at the beginning of the game, may not have been the best idea. The reason, according to the director, was not the fact that the winged creature was “annoying”, as many players have complained for decades, but rather because the game’s “tips” system did not fully satisfy him.
“It’s incredibly difficult to design a system that offers appropriate, personalized guidance for the player’s situation. To do this right, we would need to dedicate as much time as it takes to develop an entire game, and I was very afraid that we would end up in trouble if we sought perfection in this aspect…”, Miyamoto explained about the challenge of creating ideal assistance.
He continued about the character’s behavior: “If you read Navi’s lines, you’ll see that she repeats the same things all the time. I know this may sound bad, but we purposely left her with a bit of a ‘silly’ behavior. I believe that if we had tried to make Navi’s tips more sophisticated, this ‘silliness’ would have ended up standing out even more.”
Miyamoto revealed that he even considered completely removing the hint system and Navi from the game. However, he considered that some players might have difficulty advancing in certain areas, especially considering that the Zelda franchise is known for its complex puzzles.
“This would have made the game even less accessible to players. You can see Navi as a resource for those who stop playing for a month or so, and then start playing again wanting to remember what they were supposed to do. It’s a bit of an expensive excuse, I know”, explained the creator about the decision to keep the fairy.
In the end, Miyamoto commented that the game experience is individual, with some players facing more challenges than others. The difficulty for each person to progress in the game varies.
“We tried to make tips accessible to players, but I heard a lot of people say they couldn’t get ahead without a strategy guide. However, as we looked closer, we realized that the parts where people need tips vary from player to player; there’s no standard. But that’s inevitable in a game like Zelda, which combines action and puzzle solving,” he concluded.
Regardless of criticism or praise, Navi remains one of the most iconic guides in the Zelda series, marking the memories of many fans of the game.







