Practical Magic 2 hits rotten 33% score on Rotten Tomatoes

Sandra Bullock and Nicole Kidman faced widespread critical resistance on September 8, 2026, as early evaluations on Rotten Tomatoes assigned Practical Magic 2 an initial rotten score of 38% based on 24 submitted reviews. The narrative takes place 25 years after the original story, following the Owens sisters as they confront their family curse when it targets Sally’s daughter amid an unfocused screenplay that several writers described as overly lengthy despite praise for the lead actresses. A minority of reviewers praised director Susanne Bier for implementing a darker tone, describing the feature as a cute enough spell prior to theatrical distribution.
Critical reception on Rotten Tomatoes showed poor marks for the continuation starring Sandra Bullock and Nicole Kidman nearly three decades after the 1998 production.
The original 1998 cinematic release centered on sisters Sally Owens and Gillian Owens, two witch descendants plagued by an ancestral affliction that kills any man who falls in love with them. Actresses Stockard Channing and Dianne Wiest portrayed their eccentric aunts, Franny and Jet.
Adapting the 2021 book The Book of Magic by author Alice Hoffman, the new sequel places the timeline 25 years after the original events as the sisters journey from Massachusetts to the U.K. to protect Sally’s daughter Kylie, played by Joey King, from the ancestral curse.
Filmmaker Susanne Bier, known for directing The Perfect Couple and Bird Box, reunited Dianne Wiest and Stockard Channing while recruiting cast members Lee Pace, Maisie Williams, Xolo Maridueña and Solly McLeod. The project enters general release after early preview screenings.
The official review embargo expired at 12 p.m. ET, 9 a.m. PT. Subsequent Rotten Tomatoes tallies dropped to a 33% rotten score across 30 published notices. The site still withheld its official Critics Consensus, Audience Summary and verified Popcornmeter metric.
The ratings remain low.
Detailed reactions divide reviewers assessing the sequel
Critic Liz Shannon Miller assigned a rotten label to the feature while complimenting the work of Sandra Bullock and Nicole Kidman. She stated, “Even when cursed with a substandard script, Bullock and Kidman still cast quite the spell.”
Critic Todd Gilchrist judged the sequel rotten, writing, “This late sequel delivers a retread of the signposts that made the original a beloved fixture for certain moviegoers, while failing to correct the flaws that made everyone else all but forget it for three decades.”
Reviewer Clarice Loughrey similarly filed an unfavorable critique on the platform. She wrote, “Kidman and Bullock are superstars. The film yearns to be viewed as stylishly earnest. But no one’s seemingly sat down to properly think through what story deserves to be told about these characters nearly three decades down the line.”
Contributing another negative appraisal, critic Leila Latif recorded, “The Owens women remain bewitching company, but this belated sequel trades the original’s unruly feminist magic for something disappointingly conventional. The midnight margaritas are back. The magic, sadly, isn’t.”
Analyst Sophia Ciminello expressed disapproval regarding narrative pacing. She observed, “The trouble with Practical Magic 2 is that the screenplay feels a bit unfocused, with stretches of the movie feeling overlong when it can’t rely on the presence of its movie stars.”
Critic Larushka Ivan-Zadeh designated the entry rotten, writing, “Nicole Kidman and Sandra Bullock are back as the now middle-aged girls who just want to have fun. They don’t get enough of it in Practical Magic 2.”
Reviewer Brian Truitt delivered a fresh assessment that praised director Susanne Bier. He wrote, “Bier, like Griffin Dunne previously, isn’t afraid to get a little dark and weird with the magic. Toss in a smattering of talented actresses and you’ve got a witches’ brew that’s fairly satisfying.”
Critic Nick Schager backed the production with a fresh designation, writing, “It’s no classic follow-up à la Top Gun: Maverick, but it casts a cute enough spell.”
Writer Adrian Horton also favored the movie with a fresh badge on the aggregator. She stated, “The midnight margarita redux may feel obligatory, but there’s just enough magic here to still, despite everything, cast a peculiar spell.”
Preview screenings precede the wider theatrical rollout of Practical Magic 2.







