Cosmic expansion slows down as study questions dark energy

Researchers at the Tata Institute of Fundamental Research in Mumbai and the University of Oxford reported on 7 September 2026 that cosmic expansion may be slowing rather than accelerating. The scientists reanalyzed observational evidence from exploding stars and determined that the standard theoretical model of the universe may rest on an illusion caused by uncorrected stellar data. The conclusion remains disputed.
Physicists published their letter in volume 549, issue 3, of the Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society under digital object identifier 10.1093/mnras/stag844. A counter-investigation published in the exact same journal issue defended the existence of cosmic acceleration.
Researchers reexamine dataset of 1,700 stellar explosions
Professor Subir Sarkar of the Rudolf Peierls Centre for Theoretical Physics at the University of Oxford led the analysis alongside Animesh Sah and Mohamed Rameez from the Tata Institute of Fundamental Research.
The research team focused its investigation on Pantheon+, a catalog containing measurements of more than 1,700 Type Ia supernovae collected over several decades. Astronomers have tracked these thermonuclear stellar detonations for more than 25 years to gauge how cosmological distances change across cosmic history. Those supernova observations provided the foundation for the discovery of accelerated cosmic expansion, an achievement honored with the 2011 Nobel Prize in Physics. Working across several institutions, the physicists applied a newly formulated adjustment that accounts for the varying ages of the progenitor stars that generate these high-energy blasts before reaching their peak luminosity in distant galaxies.
“There is increasing evidence that the brightness of Type Ia supernovae depends on the age of the stars they come from,” said Professor Subir Sarkar of Oxford’s Rudolf Peierls Centre for Theoretical Physics. “If this effect is not accounted for, it can lead to the erroneous conclusion that the expansion rate is accelerating.”
Stellar age corrections alter cosmic acceleration findings
Applying the age adjustment to the Pantheon+ sample removed the observational preference for uniform cosmic acceleration across deep space. The adjusted numbers indicate that the cosmos experiences an overall deceleration rather than a runaway expansion pushed by quantum vacuum energy.
Sarkar and his colleagues also evaluated whether the measured acceleration behaves identically across all celestial directions.
Standard cosmological frameworks assume complete spatial isotropy, expecting physical processes to appear uniform on grand scales. The team determined instead that the apparent outward acceleration varies by direction, pointing primarily along the local motion of the solar system toward the cosmic microwave background hotspot. Sarkar explained that quantum vacuum energy cannot produce an uneven directional effect across the sky, meaning that anisotropic acceleration rules out dark energy entirely.
Competing study from Oxford defends standard expansion model
The assertion faces immediate resistance from cosmologists who examined the same broader physical question and arrived at the opposite result. A separate study published under identifier 10.1093/mnras/stag797 in the same issue of Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society argues that observational data continue to support cosmic acceleration.
- Phil Wiseman, Brodie Popovic, Mark Sullivan, Adam G Riess, and Dan Scolnic contributed to the counter-investigation.
- Rebecca C Chen, Tamara M Davis, Lluís Galbany, Isobel M Hook, Saurabh W Jha, Lisa Kelsey, and Yukei S Murakami co-authored the report.
- Mickaël Rigault, Benjamin M Rose, Brian Schmidt, Mat Smith, and Maria Vincenzi rounded out the collaborative team defending the standard model.
Professor Maria Vincenzi from the University of Oxford stated that her team analyzed supernova astrophysics alongside galaxy evolution to verify standard cosmological conclusions. “The lead authors of our study are world experts in understanding how the environments of Type Ia supernovae affect cosmological measurements with more than a decade of experience in both supernova astrophysics and galaxy evolution,” Vincenzi said. “Our recent findings provide further confidence in the cosmological framework that has emerged over the past three decades and allow the research community to focus on one of the biggest unanswered questions in physics: the nature of dark energy itself.”
Rubin Observatory survey prepares to evaluate conflicting data
Both scientific camps now await new observational measurements from the Legacy Survey of Space and Time conducted at the Vera C. Rubin Observatory. The survey instrument will measure hundreds of thousands of Type Ia supernovae across the southern sky over its operating lifetime.
The incoming survey catalog will expand the current observational baseline far beyond the 1,700 explosions logged in Pantheon+. Astronomers will apply both mathematical models to the larger dataset to determine whether the apparent acceleration shifts across differing celestial directions.
The future catalog will provide statistical power to test the validity of dark energy models against progenitor age adjustments.






