Alexandre de Moraes faces STF inquiry vote for September 15

The Supremo Tribunal Federal scheduled a full court session for September 15, 2026, to determine whether Justice Alexandre de Moraes will face an investigation connected to Banco Master. Chief Justice Luiz Edson Fachin called the meeting for 10:00 a.m. in Brasília. This proceeding represents the first time in the history of the institution that sitting justices will vote on opening an inquiry against an active member of their own bench.
Public television networks will broadcast the entire plenary deliberation in real time without restriction. Chief Justice Luiz Edson Fachin gathered assessments from fellow magistrates across recent days to establish the procedural framework for the broadcast.
Court organization and vacant seat
Ten justices currently compose the supreme bench following the retirement of Luís Roberto Barroso, whose seat remains unoccupied after his departure in October 2025. Seating positions in the courtroom follow historical seniority rules, placing Gilmar Mendes, Cármen Lúcia, Dias Toffoli, Luiz Fux, Alexandre de Moraes, Kassio Nunes Marques, André Mendonça, Cristiano Zanin, and Flávio Dino along the semicircular bench. The prosecutor general occupies the designated desk directly to the right side of the court presidency.
The scheduled session will observe a defined order of business:
- Formal reading and collective approval of the minutes from the previous judicial session.
- Reading of the case report by Chief Justice Luiz Edson Fachin to establish legal parameters.
- Institutional oral presentation delivered directly by the Procuradoria-Geral da República.
- Announcement of the lead vote by Chief Justice Luiz Edson Fachin on opening or archiving the case.
- Individual voting calls for each sitting justice until the final judicial declaration.
Chief Justice Luiz Edson Fachin will deliver his vote immediately after the institutional presentation by the federal prosecution. The clerk will then call upon the remaining magistrates individually to cast their ballots until the formal tally is proclaimed. Ten justices hold seats.
Prosecutor General Paulo Gonet confirmed his personal attendance at the plenary session, although his voting recommendation remains unannounced. Federal Police investigators previously identified messages sent by businessman Daniel Vorcaro that made direct reference to the head of the Public Prosecutor’s Office of the Union. Gonet has kept his formal positioning undisclosed ahead of the oral statement.
Questions of participation and conflicts of interest
Legal debate persists over whether Alexandre de Moraes can participate in the vote, given that the underlying petition concerns his own judicial conduct. Dias Toffoli also faces scrutiny regarding his participation due to previous commercial ties with a firm that negotiated a hotel stake with an investment fund linked to Daniel Vorcaro. Toffoli stepped down as rapporteur of the inquiry in February, and he subsequently declared himself conflicted during the evaluation of Vorcaro’s preventive arrest. His potential presence during the final ballot count remains undecided.
Internal rules allow any justice to request an official review of the case files, an action that could suspend the deliberations even if other members choose to record their votes beforehand. The upcoming session marks the first instance where members of the supreme court must rule directly on a probe aimed at a peer.
Alexandre de Moraes formally requested that the plenary examine the conduct of Justice André Mendonça during the same September 15 hearing. Chief Justice Luiz Edson Fachin dismissed the request for immediate joint consideration. Fachin scheduled the review of decisions issued by André Mendonça for September 23.
Public perception and academic assessments
Public skepticism toward the high court reached 56 percent in a survey released by the Quaest institute on September 14. That measurement showed an increase from the 46 percent disapproval recorded in the previous poll conducted in August.
Professor Gustavo Sampaio, who teaches law at Universidade Federal Fluminense, argued that total procedural openness serves as the only path to restore institutional credibility among citizens. He pointed out the exceptional nature of the internal conflict currently affecting the supreme bench.
“There have been more dramatic moments, but on the level of internal conflicts within the Supremo Tribunal Federal, a true civil war, this has no precedent in history. Consequently, the session next Tuesday is decisive, not only for the court to resolve matters that need resolution, but also for Brazilian society, which is the ultimate recipient of everything that occurs in Brasília, to follow the work of the high court with close scrutiny. For this purpose, the court must dedicate maximum transparency, open this session, and grant frank access to the press and the public, so that the image of the tribunal can gradually regain its deserved standing before the Brazilian people,” Sampaio said.
Rubens Glezer, a professor of constitutional law at Fundação Getulio Vargas, stated that managing the plenary will require rigid adherence to procedural rules to contain potential disputes among the justices. He noted that the leadership of the court will face structural limits during the hearing.
“Chief Justice Luiz Edson Fachin has several tools at his disposal to organize and coordinate this meeting, attempting to prevent it from degenerating into an overt exercise of political opposition among the justices, in the sense of degrading and criticizing rather than merely disagreeing. His authority, however, is not absolute. He concentrates significant powers as presiding officer and rapporteur, which provides specific prerogatives, yet he can face continuous interruptions from colleagues seeking case reviews, early votes, or procedural points of order. It remains vital that Fachin attempts preliminary understandings to prevent open conflict from reaching the floor, but turbulence may still happen. He will attempt to pacify and coordinate, but he lacks the legal power to impose that harmony,” Glezer said.
Professor Gustavo Badaró, from the Universidade de São Paulo, emphasized that the judiciary owes an institutional explanation to the public regarding the accusations against its members. He maintained that organizational integrity supersedes individual magistrates.
“Observing transparency is fundamental. The Supremo Tribunal Federal is experiencing, in the words of its former justices, the sharpest crisis in its history. The conduct of its members, the legality of its inquiries, and the impartial role of the institution have never faced such intense questioning from public opinion. The institution is greater than all of its individual justices combined. Because of that reality, the court must provide an answer to society regarding this matter,” Badaró said.
The case records remain under examination by the presidency ahead of the scheduled morning opening in Brasília. Court officials continue operational preparations inside the main plenary chamber for the upcoming broadcast.







