Delhi summit highlights Brics’ evolving influence, revealing internal rifts amid Iran conflict
Global leaders convened recently in India’s capital, Delhi, for a significant summit that underscored the shifting dynamics of international relations. The gathering, which brought together some of the world’s most powerful figures, served as a crucial platform for reassessing geopolitical alignments, particularly in the wake of escalating tensions surrounding the Middle East conflict. Discussions centered on the future of global governance, with a clear emphasis on member nations becoming proactive “rule-shapers” rather than passive “rule-takers” in the international arena.
The assembly featured heads of state from the Brics group, including Chinese President Xi Jinping, Russian President Vladimir Putin, Iranian President Masoud Pezeshkian, Abu Dhabi’s Crown Prince Sheikh Khaled bin Mohamed bin Zayed Al Nahyan, and South African President Cyril Ramaphosa, alongside host Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi. Their presence together, given historical and ongoing rivalries, was a diplomatic achievement in itself, showcasing India’s growing capacity to convene diverse global players.
Despite the high-level attendance, the path to a unified vision for a new global order proved challenging. Deep-seated disagreements among members created underlying tensions throughout the weekend’s proceedings, making it difficult to achieve concrete, universally accepted outcomes.
Navigating a complex alliance of diverse interests
The Brics bloc comprises nations that are hardly traditional allies, marked by histories of border disputes and even military confrontations. For instance, India and China were involved in a deadly border clash in 2020, and Iran and the United Arab Emirates have found themselves on opposing sides of the Middle East conflict, with Tehran reportedly launching missiles and drones that affected its fellow Brics member’s interests.
This inherent diversity highlights the delicate balance India must strike in its diplomatic endeavors. The summit’s ability to bring these leaders into direct dialogue, particularly between long-estranged parties, stands as a testament to the diplomatic reach required to bridge such significant divides.
Strategic autonomy versus anti-Western alignment
A fundamental divergence within Brics concerns its overarching purpose. For several key members, including China, Russia, and Iran, the group represents a strategic vehicle to diminish the influence of the United States and Western Europe on the global stage. This perspective views Brics as a counterweight to existing Western-dominated international structures, seeking to create a multipolar world order.
However, India has consistently expressed reluctance to position Brics as an explicitly anti-Western bloc. Prime Minister Modi himself asserted during the summit that the group is “not against anyone,” emphasizing its role as a platform for collaboration rather than confrontation. This distinction is crucial for Delhi, which aims to maintain robust relationships with nations across various geopolitical spectrums, even those at odds with each other.
According to veteran Indian diplomat and former ambassador Anil Trigunayat, while some members might prefer an anti-Western stance, India’s objective has been to foster “strategic autonomy in an era of war” and promote greater cooperation among its members. This approach allows India to pursue its national interests without being confined to a binary geopolitical choice, enhancing its flexibility on the world stage.
Achieving consensus amid glaring divisions
One of the summit’s notable successes was the adoption of the “New Delhi Declaration,” a joint statement achieved despite significant internal disagreements that had prevented similar consensus in earlier ministerial meetings this year. This outcome signals a diplomatic breakthrough, though it was largely accomplished by carefully sidestepping contentious issues rather than resolving them directly.
The declaration, adopted on the first day, is particularly revealing for what it omits. Regarding the ongoing Middle East conflict, it called for “maximum restraint” and condemned “attacks on civilian infrastructure and peaceful nuclear facilities” but notably refrained from assigning blame to any specific party. It also reiterated support for a two-state solution and opposed forced displacement or actions that could “legitimise or prolong occupation,” framing these points cautiously within existing UN resolutions.
Notable exclusions and cautious diplomacy
Significantly, the New Delhi Declaration made no mention of the Russia-Ukraine conflict, a marked departure from previous Brics statements. This omission underscores the group’s careful navigation of sensitive geopolitical issues to maintain internal cohesion, particularly given the varying positions of its members on the war.
Similar caution was observed in discussions on trade. The declaration expressed concerns over “indiscriminate rising tariffs” and condemned unilateral sanctions, yet it meticulously avoided naming the United States. This strategic omission was likely designed to prevent provoking the ire of Washington, especially considering past warnings from former US President Donald Trump regarding Brics proposals, such as linking central-bank digital currencies for cross-border trade, which he deemed “anti-American.”
Praveen Donthi, a senior analyst at the International Crisis Group, noted that the absence of direct country mentions, even when condemning the Middle East conflict, bears the hallmark of Indian diplomacy. He also expressed surprise at the strong reference to tariffs, suggesting it might have been an opportunity for India to subtly convey its displeasure on trade matters without direct confrontation.
Forging new dialogues in a shifting global order
Beyond the formal declarations, the summit provided a crucial platform for high-level bilateral meetings that would have seemed improbable just months prior. A significant development was the face-to-face talks between Iran’s President Pezeshkian and Abu Dhabi’s Crown Prince Sheikh Khaled bin Mohamed bin Zayed Al Nahyan—the highest-level known meeting between the two nations since the Middle East conflict began. This interaction offered Tehran a valuable opportunity to demonstrate that it is not isolated amidst US and Israeli military actions and economic pressures.
As Iran continues to navigate stringent US sanctions, including Washington’s “Operation Economic Outcast” and a naval blockade on its ports, President Pezeshkian actively sought to deepen economic ties with other Brics members, including Malaysia, India, and Ethiopia. These efforts highlight Iran’s strategic pivot towards multilateral economic partnerships to mitigate the impact of Western sanctions.
The summit also marked Chinese President Xi Jinping’s first visit to Delhi in seven years. Despite deep mistrust between China and India stemming from their 2020 border dispute, tensions between the two Asian giants have shown signs of easing. Although President Xi’s visit was brief, lasting less than 24 hours and notably skipping a gala dinner hosted by Prime Minister Modi, the leaders engaged in cordial discussions.
Official readouts indicated that both leaders agreed to strengthen business ties, enhance transport links, and address existing barriers to trade. This signifies a gradual warming of relations, with Anil Trigunayat suggesting a mutual willingness on both sides to foster cooperation. While substantial progress remains to be seen, the very occurrence of such high-level engagements at the Brics summit underscores its vital role in facilitating dialogue and potentially reshaping complex international relationships in a rapidly evolving global landscape.






