Police arrest Florida woman over sex acts with family dog

Deputies from the Charlotte County Sheriff’s Office arrested 38-year-old Malia Elizabeth Nummerdor in Port Charlotte on September 15 on felony charges of sexual activity involving animals after home video captured her with the household pet.
Investigators launched an inquiry after Erik Nummerdor posted allegations on Facebook on September 11 regarding his estranged wife and their dog, Ranger. A detective reviewed the public messages and noted claims of photographic and video evidence depicting the conduct inside the residence.
Surveillance system installed inside the bedroom
Erik Nummerdor met with a detective on September 14 and stated he set up two cameras inside the residence, including one in his bedroom to identify who was taking money from a coin container. The recording device remained visible, displayed a blinking red light, and operated continuously by overwriting older material in rolling intervals. Erik later turned over a laptop containing the original files so authorities could inspect the footage.
A detective who examined the video observed an adult woman nude from the waist down positioned with the animal in a manner consistent with sexual activity.
Interrogation details and statements from the suspect
Authorities questioned Nummerdor on September 15 while noting she appeared impaired and acknowledged consuming drugs or alcohol. She denied the allegations.
Nummerdor confirmed to investigators that she appeared in the bedroom recording and identified the canine as Ranger, yet she asserted that no sexual conduct had occurred while claiming that her estranged husband placed the equipment without her knowledge, accessed her personal digital accounts, and held the 2024 footage to threaten her prior to his public posts. The Charlotte County Sheriff’s Office reported that she “could not provide a consistent explanation for what was seen on the camera.” Deputies noted that calls to a phone number listed for Erik Nummerdor went unanswered.
Evidence presented during the investigation
The case file documents several evidentiary elements collected by the Charlotte County Sheriff’s Office:
- Surveillance files saved on a laptop provided by Erik Nummerdor
- Screenshots capturing an adult female with the family dog
- Public messages and comment threads published on social media on September 11
- Statements regarding equipment operating inside the residence during 2024
Custody status and statements from local leadership
Under Florida law, sexual activity involving animals constitutes a second-degree felony. Sheriff Bill Prummell condemned the incident in an official statement released by the agency.
Prummell stated that no animal should face such treatment and expressed shock regarding the matter. “There are only a few times in my career that I have been at a loss for words,” Prummell stated. “I simply cannot comprehend this behavior.”
Nummerdor was booked into the Charlotte County Jail, where records set her bond at $35,000.






