Kremlin conducts State Duma elections in occupied Ukraine, facing global rejection and accusations of staged legitimacy
Russia initiated its State Duma elections on Friday, marking the first parliamentary vote since its full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022. The electoral process extends into Ukrainian territories currently under Russian occupation, a move widely seen as an attempt by Moscow to fabricate an impression of popular endorsement for its military actions and the annexation of eastern Ukrainian regions.
This electoral exercise has immediately drawn sharp international criticism, primarily due to the exclusion of independent observers. Critics argue that the Kremlin’s refusal to permit monitoring by organizations such as the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe (OSCE) underscores a deliberate disregard for democratic principles and international obligations, signaling that the elections are neither free nor fair.
Elections under scrutiny: Absence of independent observation
The decision by Russia to not invite an election observation mission constitutes a significant breach of its international commitments, according to international bodies. Pere Joan Pons, President of the OSCE Parliamentary Assembly, emphasized that election observation is not optional but a fundamental agreement among all OSCE participating states, serving as a cornerstone for transparency and accountability in democratic processes.
The absence of independent oversight is a critical indicator for many, suggesting that the outcomes are predetermined rather than reflecting genuine voter sentiment. This lack of transparency further fuels skepticism about the legitimacy of any results emanating from these polls, particularly in the contested regions.
Suppressing dissent and consolidating power
Since the 2022 invasion, Russia has implemented stringent censorship laws, effectively criminalizing any form of dissent regarding its military operations or armed forces, and actively suppressing what it deems as misinformation about the conflict. This repressive environment significantly curtails freedom of expression and political opposition within the country.
Illustrating this crackdown, a Russian court recently sentenced Lev Shlosberg, a prominent critic and leader of one of Russia’s few opposition parties, to over 11 years in a penal colony for criticizing the war. Prior to his sentencing, Russia’s Supreme Court had already barred his Yabloko Party from participating in the September Duma elections. All nine parties listed on the ballot are reportedly supportive of President Vladimir Putin, including the Kremlin’s own United Russia Party, further narrowing the scope of political choice for voters.
Annexation and the international community’s stance
Following its 2022 invasion, Moscow unilaterally annexed several occupied Ukrainian territories, a move not recognized by Ukraine or the international community. In 2023, President Putin signed legislation paving the way for elections to be held in these annexed regions. Critics contend that these elections serve as mere “window-dressing” for Putin, aiming to bolster his narrative that the war and annexations are legitimate and lawful actions.
The international community consistently rejects Russian sovereignty over these areas. According to Keti Korkiya from the Foundation for Defense of Democracies Russia Program, while Russians might offer symbolic support for Putin and the war, their willingness to bear a personal or economic cost remains limited. This reluctance, she suggests, explains why Russia has not initiated another wave of mobilization.
The territories unilaterally annexed by Russia include:
- Donetsk
- Luhansk
- Kherson
- Zaporizhzhia
Coercion and intimidation tactics
The upcoming elections, much like previous polls in Russia, are unfolding amidst a pervasive climate of fear and manipulation, rather than an environment conducive to the free exercise of democratic rights. Jaroslava Barbieri, a research fellow at the Ukraine Forum at Chatham House, described the situation as a “total regime of terror.”
Residents in occupied Ukrainian areas have reportedly been compelled to acquire Russian passports, which authorities then use to compile voter lists. Election officials are frequently accompanied by Russian soldiers carrying ballot boxes door-to-door. While framed as a security measure against potential Ukrainian partisan strikes, these actions are widely interpreted as direct intimidation and a flagrant violation of international law. Volodymyr Ariev, a member of the Ukrainian Parliament, has urged people in these territories to boycott the staged Russian elections, emphasizing their illegality under international law. He advised residents to avoid their homes on election day to prevent being coerced into voting.
Russia’s Central Election Commission (CEC) has approved new electoral regulations for occupied Ukraine, emphasizing early and at-home voting to minimize large gatherings, which they claim could be exploited by Ukrainian attacks. Meanwhile, Russia’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs announced preparations for overseas voting are nearly complete, with 326 polling stations established at Russian embassies and consulates in 152 countries.
Kremlin’s quest for legitimacy amid stalled conflict
In August, President Vladimir Putin stated that the State Duma elections would reaffirm Russia’s stability on the global stage, highlighting the “maturity” of Russia’s political system and its resilience in the face of foreign aggression. However, as Russia’s battlefield momentum appears to stall, and the conflict increasingly reaches Russian territory, the Kremlin is actively seeking political legitimacy through these elections.
Ivana Stradner, who specializes in Russian information security and influence operations, notes that the State Duma elections offer the Kremlin an opportunity to create the appearance of public support. This manufactured consent is intended not only for United Russia but also for the continuation of Putin’s aggressive actions in Ukraine. She suggests that when military success becomes harder to promote, the ballot box transforms into another tool to “sell the war.” In the 2024 presidential elections, the annexed Donetsk and Luhansk regions reportedly delivered over 90% support for President Putin, significantly exceeding the targeted 70%. Stradner aptly summarized the situation, stating that in Putin’s version of democracy, voters get to choose everything except the actual outcome.






