Joy Behar firmly states belief that a woman will not secure U.S. presidential victory, sparking debate
During a recent broadcast of the popular talk show “The View,” co-host Joy Behar reiterated her long-held contention that the United States is unlikely to elect a woman as president. Her comments ignited a spirited discussion among the panel regarding identity politics and the complex factors influencing presidential campaigns. This stance has periodically resurfaced in national conversations about political representation and voter behavior, drawing both agreement and sharp criticism from various commentators.
The debate on the show began after an unrelated segment about Illinois Governor JB Pritzker’s use of a GLP-1 medication, quickly shifting focus to the broader implications of identity in American politics. Behar asserted that the nation would more readily vote for an individual identifying as “obese, Jewish, Black, homosexual” than for a woman. This provocative statement underscores a deeply rooted skepticism among some observers about the political viability of female candidates at the highest level of government.
Panelists weigh in on electability and identity
Guest host Star Jones echoed Behar’s sentiment, pointing to past presidential campaigns as evidence. “We just had one of the most beautiful, brilliant women run for president. And you see what we got,” Jones remarked, alluding to former Vice President Kamala Harris. Behar further supported this by referencing former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton’s unsuccessful bids for the White House, suggesting a systemic barrier for women.
However, not all panelists agreed with this stark assessment. Co-host Sara Haines offered a counterpoint, emphasizing that electoral outcomes are multifaceted. “You don’t win on identity alone, and you don’t lose on identity alone,” Haines argued, highlighting the interplay of policy, personality, and political strategy. Alyssa Farah Griffin, the program’s Republican co-host, expressed a more optimistic outlook, predicting that a woman would occupy the Oval Office within the next two decades, reflecting a belief in evolving societal attitudes and political landscapes.
Expert critiques of Behar’s perspective
Outside the show, Behar’s comments drew scrutiny from political analysts and experts. Patrice Onwuka, vice president for economic policy and director of the Independent Women’s Center for Economic Opportunity, characterized Behar’s viewpoint as a byproduct of prioritizing identity politics over practical considerations. Onwuka contended that the electoral failures of prominent female candidates were rooted in their platforms and public personas rather than their gender.
Onwuka specifically cited instances such as Hillary Clinton’s handling of the 2012 Benghazi attacks and her controversial “deplorables” remark directed at Donald Trump supporters, as well as Kamala Harris’s tenure as vice president, which Onwuka described as “failed” due to policy outcomes like increased illegal immigration. These criticisms suggest that policy positions and personal conduct play a more decisive role in voter perception than identity markers alone.
Jonathan Alpert, a psychotherapist and author, also weighed in, dismissing Behar’s explanation as overly simplistic. Alpert argued that the losses of two female candidates to Donald Trump do not conclusively prove that Americans will never elect a woman president. Instead, he suggested, it merely indicates that those specific candidates were unsuccessful in those particular elections. While acknowledging that sexism might influence some voters, Alpert cautioned against attributing millions of votes solely to gender bias, advocating for a more nuanced understanding of electoral dynamics.
Previous remarks and future possibilities
This is not the first time Behar has voiced her skepticism about a female president. In a July episode of “The View,” she challenged her co-hosts to name a woman who could realistically win the presidency. During another segment that same month, she explicitly dismissed Kamala Harris as a viable candidate for 2028, despite her affection for the vice president. “I love her, she was great, but she didn’t win one time. What makes you think she’s going to win again?” Behar questioned, implying that those who believe Harris could succeed are out of touch with political realities.
The ongoing discussion about female electability gains further relevance with recent political developments. Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, a Democrat from New York, revealed in a New York Times interview that she is considering a presidential run in 2028. Ocasio-Cortez openly acknowledged the role of her identity as a woman and a Latina in her political considerations, especially “living under a very regressive administration.” She expressed a willingness to confront discussions about electability head-on, suggesting that her identity is an integral part of her potential candidacy rather than a hindrance.
- The debate highlights persistent questions about gender and leadership in American politics.
- Diverse viewpoints from “The View” panelists and external experts underscore the complexity of voter behavior.
- Past electoral outcomes for prominent female candidates continue to fuel skepticism and analysis.
- The potential 2028 candidacy of Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez brings renewed focus to identity in presidential campaigns.
The national discourse surrounding the possibility of a woman president remains vibrant and contentious, with figures like Joy Behar sparking renewed debate with their firm pronouncements. As the political landscape evolves and new candidates emerge, the interplay of identity, policy, and voter sentiment will undoubtedly continue to shape the path to the nation’s highest office.






