Pentagon launches rigorous combat assessments to prioritize battlefield commanders for general promotions
The U.S. Department of Defense is implementing a significant overhaul in its selection process for senior military leaders, introducing a new series of battlefield-style assessments. This initiative represents the most profound change in decades for how future generals across all military branches will be chosen, aiming to ensure that strategic command is entrusted to officers with proven combat capabilities rather than those primarily focused on career advancement.
Internal documents reveal that each military service has developed its unique version of this new standardized evaluation, known as the Joint Warfighting Evaluation (JWE). This assessment is designed to gauge operational planning, decision-making prowess, and leadership under simulated combat scenarios, serving as an additional metric for promotion boards starting with the fiscal year 2027 cycle. The move underscores a broader effort to identify and elevate individuals best equipped to face the complexities of modern warfare.
A new era for military leadership selection
This transformative push originated from Secretary of War Pete Hegseth’s directive to reform military evaluations and promotions. The core objective is to identify officers who demonstrate exceptional performance in combat situations, moving beyond a system that might inadvertently reward those who merely build strong career records through administrative efficiency. The new approach seeks to cultivate a leadership cadre deeply rooted in practical warfighting experience.
Stu Scheller, the senior Pentagon adviser spearheading this initiative, highlighted a critical distinction in the current system. “People figure out they don’t have to be the best at their job, they have to be the best at making sure their boss thinks they’re the best,” Scheller explained. He emphasized that these two attributes are fundamentally different, and the existing framework, while producing many capable military personnel, lacks a dedicated mechanism to truly assess the finest military commanders for the battlefield.
The joint warfighting evaluation: How it works
The Joint Warfighting Evaluation is designed to be a comprehensive, stand-alone function that complements, rather than replaces, the traditional promotion system. While performance reports from superiors will remain the foundational element of promotion decisions, the JWE will provide an independent measure of an officer’s ability to solve complex military problems under simulated command conditions. This dual-track assessment aims to offer promotion boards a more holistic view of a candidate’s potential.
The assessments incorporate various sophisticated methods, from online simulations to multi-hour, in-person wargames. Some versions present officers with intricate military problems, forcing them to make critical decisions as an AI-powered adversary dynamically reacts to their moves. Others bring officers into specialized war colleges, where evaluators observe their real-time responses to enemy counteractions in dynamic, high-pressure environments. Scheller noted, “You make a move, enemy makes a move, how I react based on a time environment,” illustrating the interactive nature of these tests.
Diverse assessment models across military branches
The specific format and intensity of the Joint Warfighting Evaluation will vary significantly across the different branches of service, tailored to their unique operational contexts and leadership requirements. The Pentagon has developed six distinct versions, one for each of the five military services and an additional one through the Joint Staff, reflecting a flexible yet standardized approach to evaluating command potential.
- The Army plans to subject approximately 900 eligible colonels to a remote written assessment, followed by a digital wargame designed to test tactical and strategic acumen.
- The Air Force will administer a two-hour online analysis test, succeeded by a one-hour interactive simulation, for roughly 1,330 colonels.
- The Space Force will adopt a similar foundational format for its approximately 125 officers, adapted to the unique challenges of space operations.
- The Navy’s version is considerably more intensive, requiring about 308 captains from unrestricted line and information warfare communities to travel to the Naval War College for a three-hour written assessment, culminating in a two-to-three-hour wargame.
- The Marine Corps has devised an eight-hour remote evaluation for up to 175 colonels, utilizing an AI-enabled platform that integrates written assessments with situational judgment tests, simulating high-stakes combat decision-making.
Scheller acknowledged that no exercise can perfectly replicate the immense pressures of actual combat, and the Pentagon anticipates that these assessments will evolve as they gather data and learn what methods prove most effective. This iterative approach ensures continuous refinement and improvement of the evaluation process.
Integrating new metrics with established career paths
The Pentagon’s leadership has made it clear that the Joint Warfighting Evaluation is not intended to replace the existing promotion system entirely. Instead, it will serve as an additional, crucial data point for promotion boards. Performance reports and an officer’s comprehensive career record will continue to form the bulk of the evaluation. The weight assigned to this new JWE data point remains under consideration, with Secretary Hegseth retaining judgment on its ultimate influence.
The initial phase of these evaluations is set for the upcoming year. Eligible O-6 officers will undergo their assessments between approximately February and June 2027, preceding the O-7 promotion boards scheduled from July to September. Following this inaugural cycle, the Pentagon intends to thoroughly study the results to determine the optimal influence the JWE should exert on future promotion decisions and how the assessments might need to be adapted for subsequent years.
Broader reforms in defense leadership
The introduction of the Joint Warfighting Evaluation is a key component of a wider reform agenda championed by Secretary Hegseth, focused on modernizing how the Pentagon selects, evaluates, and retains its senior military leaders. Last year, Hegseth informed hundreds of generals and admirals that the military’s promotion system was undergoing a comprehensive reexamination, with pledges to accelerate the promotion of top performers and expedite the removal of underperformers.
Beyond evaluations, Hegseth has also initiated efforts to streamline the military’s upper echelons. This includes an order for a 20% reduction in active-duty four-star positions and a broader 10% cut in general and flag officer positions as part of a strategic restructuring of military commands. Furthermore, the Secretary has assumed a more direct role in the critical decision-making process regarding which officers are awarded a star, signaling a hands-on approach to shaping the future leadership of the U.S. armed forces.






